login
Questions
Unanswered
Tags
Users
Ask a Question
My Feed
G2G Help
Categories
All categories
The Tree House
(45.2k)
Appreciation
(19.2k)
Genealogy Help
(98.9k)
Photos
(5.4k)
Policy and Style
(16.1k)
Requests for Project Volunteers
(3.3k)
WikiTree Help
(16.0k)
WikiTree Tech
(17.2k)
Who is responsible for "clean up"?
+5
votes
241
views
I received a note that someone had "added a source" to a profile I created. Would someone please check to make sure it is in acceptable format? I think it came from a gedcom.. Is this acceptable and if needs improvement . . who is responsible? BTW - someone just taught me how to use editbot. THANK YOU WIKITREE!
WikiTree profile:
Sterling Evans
arborists
merges
profile_improvement
asked
Dec 30, 2018
in
Policy and Style
by
anonymous
retagged
Dec 30, 2018
by
Maggie N.
Please
log in
or
register
to add a comment.
Please
log in
or
register
to answer this question.
4
Answers
+4
votes
Best answer
If you go on the Changes Tab up there in the line you can see who made changes on the profile.
answered
Dec 30, 2018
by
Jelena Eckstädt
G2G Astronaut
(
1.5m
points)
selected
Jan 4, 2019
by
William Arbuthnot of Kittybrewster
Please
log in
or
register
to add a comment.
+9
votes
Barbara, it looks like there was a merge after which things didn't get cleaned up as there is duplicate information in two formats. Generally speaking the person who completes the merge or adds citations should be responsible for the clean-up unless it was otherwise agreed. Sometimes I offer to do clean-up just to motivate people to go ahead and merge where it is appropriate.
Also, your <references /> tag along with == Sources == needs to be the last thing on the profile so that all of the inline citations get listed. Right now none of the inline citations (of which there are many) in the profile after the Sources section are able to be seen. You can just copy and paste that down above Acknowledgments and the delete it earlier on.
In Edit mode you want to see
== Sources ==
<references />
(with any bullet point or * citations coming after this)
as the last thing BEFORE ==Acknowledgments ==
answered
Dec 30, 2018
by
T Stanton
G2G6 Pilot
(
367k
points)
Please
log in
or
register
to add a comment.
+2
votes
I find that often duplicate children are created in merges which is obvious on the parent's new profiles, yet it is not noticed or ignored by the person who completed the merge. The person who created the merge in the first place should be responsible for fixing these duplicates.
answered
Dec 31, 2018
by
George Churchill
G2G6 Mach 9
(
97.2k
points)
Please
log in
or
register
to add a comment.
+2
votes
I agree with the other answers listed, and while ideal if the person completing the merge performs the needed clean up, since this is a Wiki, I feel we all, in a sense, are responsible for 'clean up'.
answered
Dec 31, 2018
by
Susan Keil
G2G6 Mach 6
(
67.3k
points)
Please
log in
or
register
to add a comment.
Related questions
+26
votes
4
answers
384
views
Who is responsible for clean up after merging
asked
Dec 15, 2013
in
Genealogy Help
by
Anonymous Roach
G2G6 Pilot
(
198k
points)
profiles
mentors
arborists
merges
+12
votes
7
answers
725
views
Who would be interested in helping clean up WikiTree?
asked
Jul 1, 2012
in
Requests for Project Volunteers
by
Lindsay Tyrie
G2G6 Mach 1
(
19.6k
points)
volunteer
euroaristo
merges
arborists
projects
+7
votes
2
answers
158
views
How do you clean up a file after a merge?
asked
Aug 31, 2017
in
WikiTree Tech
by
Stephen Waltermyer
G2G Crew
(
370
points)
profile_improvement
arborists
style
+6
votes
1
answer
362
views
Would you like to clean up this profile?
asked
Jan 31, 2017
in
Genealogy Help
by
Jacqueline Girouard
G2G6 Mach 7
(
74.6k
points)
merges
acadian
profile_improvement
pre-1700
notables
+11
votes
1
answer
247
views
Is there a proper way to edit/clean up this type of "source"...
asked
Nov 5, 2016
in
Genealogy Help
by
Mary Cole
G2G6 Pilot
(
110k
points)
profile_improvement
clean-up
sources
style
merges
+11
votes
2
answers
193
views
Hunting for accidentally Rejected Merges with LNAB Unknown - not a good day!!
asked
Nov 21, 2020
in
The Tree House
by
Esmé van der Westhuizen
G2G6 Pilot
(
148k
points)
unknown
arborists
merges
lnab
improvements
profile_improvement
+8
votes
2
answers
297
views
How do you determine whether an existing profile whose info is all private is the same as a person you want to add?
asked
Feb 21, 2020
in
WikiTree Help
by
Colleen Vachuska
G2G6 Mach 3
(
36.7k
points)
arborists
merges
privacy
privacy_level
profile_improvement
+6
votes
0
answers
128
views
Can the merge display be improved? Parents are being lost.
asked
Apr 17, 2018
in
The Tree House
by
Philip Smith
G2G6 Pilot
(
340k
points)
improvements
arborists
leaders
profile_improvement
profiles
merges
+10
votes
5
answers
233
views
How easy is it for new comers to find information on what to do after a merge?
asked
Feb 13, 2017
in
Genealogy Help
by
Jacqueline Girouard
G2G6 Mach 7
(
74.6k
points)
merges
data_doctors
profile_improvement
arborists
+10
votes
3
answers
271
views
Call out for help
asked
Feb 10, 2017
in
Genealogy Help
by
Lisa Murphy
G2G6 Pilot
(
330k
points)
sayers
wheeler
merges
profile_improvement
arborists
WikiTree
~
About
~
Help
~
Search
~
Surname
:
...