We have two Elizabeths as his daughter. Which one is correct? [closed]

Question

https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Maris-33

https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Maris-16

I am sensing it's the one that never left England?

Answer 1

George and brother Richard both married an Alice, so could they both have a daughter named Elizabeth?

Alternatively are George and Richard one and the same?

A rather perplexing issue.

Comments

Thanks, Marion. I figured it out and detached the England one. There were enough sources for the Mendenhall one.

---

I know this topic is closed but just want to add a general comment - I have an ancestor who had 2 daughters both called Margaret, we know this is correct because they married different men and were both mentioned in his will.