Wow, that's quite a collection of Abigails he has there! And the marriage date is all the same, given the possibility of Old Style year causing the difference between 1729 and 1730, because the event occurred in February.
At first glance, there seems to be a majority vote for Goodale/Goodell (probably the same name). But different parents...................I see you have been working on this for some time. What is causing your hesitation to declare that Abigail Goodale daughter of David is best supported by the available evidence?