April, I haven't found a Phillip Wingate in my line, but I can't get beyond my 4Ggrandfather, an Edward Wingate born 1788, I'm not sure where, either SC or NC most likely...census records record SC as birthplace. We cannot get a YDNA to test with his line, because he had 4 sisters and 4 daughters...I haven't been able to find a direct male line to do DNA for Wingate. All the male cousins and uncles of his died before DNA became the way to find ancestors. If you think your line matches Manley Asa Wingate, perhaps you could share some DNA results? Have you matched with any Potters? I have matched some on Gedmatch, pretty far back, but I think Edward's mother may have been a Potter...any suggestions?? Kathy Wingate