My ancestor, John George is described as "from Germany" in the book "Biological Review of Leading Delaware County Citizens", and in early census lists, but I suspect, due to his age, anglicized name, and lack of immigration records, that he may actually have been second or third generation American born, from the German community in Rhinebeck, NY. Johann Wilhelm George arrived on the 8th Palatine ship, October 1710, and he was living at the Livingston Plantation in Summer 1711. <ref 1711 Livingston Plantation Records, John George was living in Rhinebeck, NY and working as a gardener at the Livingstone Plantation in 1790. <ref 1790 Census records and the aforementioned Biological Review.