Philip (Munsch) Munch
Privacy Level: Open (White)

Johann Philipp (Munsch) Munch (1749 - 1796)

Johann Philipp (Philip) Munch formerly Munsch
Born in Zittersheim, Alsace (now Bas-Rhin, France)map
Ancestors ancestors
Husband of — married about 1773 in Marylandmap [uncertain]
Descendants descendants
Died at age 47 in Fort Valley, Shenandoah County, Virginia, USAmap
Problems/Questions Profile manager: Daniel Bly private message [send private message]
Profile last modified | Created 3 Jan 2017
This page has been accessed 562 times.

Biography

The place and date of birth for Philip Munch, who settled on Passage Creek in the "Fort Valley" of Shenandoah County, Virginia, in the late eighteenth century was lost over the years, but family tradition among his descendants was that he was German speaking from Alsace, which was under French rule when he was born.[1] Some have also suggested that he is the "Philipp Munsch" who arrived in Philadelphia, October 26, 1768, aboard the ship Betsy.[2] There is now solid evidence that this "Philipp Munsch," the only Philipp Munsch on any eighteenth century ship list, is indeed, Philip Munch of Shenandoah County, Virginia, who signed his name on a 1793 petition and on his will as "Philip Munsch."[3] It is now possible to identify Philip's parents and several generations of his Alsatian ancestors. There was a large Munsch family at Zittersheim and Erckartswiller in the northwest corner of Alsace in the 17th and 18th century. This is an area where there was large scale immigration to America, including the Reitenauer / Ridenour family that settled in the "Fort Valley" of Shenandoah County about the same time Philip Munsch settled in "The Fort." There were at least four Philipp Munsches born in these villages between 1738 and 1750, the time frame in which Philipp Munsch, of Virginia was probably born. Three of these can be eliminated because they died young or married and remained in Alsace. However, Johann Philipp Munsch, born at Zittersheim, January 12, 1749, son of Johann Adam and Eva Catherina, did not die or marry there and cannot be found in any records there after 1768 and his father, Johann Adam, also immigrated with his second wife, and shows up in Frederick County, Maryland by 1766. Philipp Munsch was an ideal candidate for emigration. He was a second son, his mother died when he was young, his father remarried and moved to Erckartswiller and had no particular status in the community and also emigrated. The fact that Philip Munsch in Virginia named his oldest daughter Catherine, and sons; George, Adam, Philip, Peter, and John, all the most common names used by the Munsches of Zittersheim and Erckartswiller, further supports the conclusion that he is Philipp Munsch, son of Adam and Catherina.

Philip Munch remained behind when his father left for America in 1765, but three years later, he too left his homeland and arrived in Philadelphia in October 1768. He apparently did not spend any time in Pennsylvania, but quickly joined his father in Maryland, married about 1773 and was living in Frederick County, Maryland by 1774, and had three children baptized there. [4] He then moved to Virginia with his young family in 1778-79 to Powell's Fort Valley in Shenandoah County Virginia about the same time the Cullers and Ritenour families also moved from Maryland to the Fort Valley. [5] He first appears in Shenandoah County, Virginia, records in 1779, when Jacob Neuschwander sold him a warrant to 222 acres of land in Powell's Fort Valley, which Neuschwander had surveyed in 1778. [6] In 1783 Philip Munch appears in Shenandoah County with six people in the household and in 1785 Philip Munch was included in a list of "Fort Valley" families in a Shenandoah County census, with seven people in his household. He appears to have occupied the 222 acres in Powell's Fort from the time he acquired it. There was some conflict over Fairfax grants and not until the Fairfax-Hite suit was settled did Philip Munch finally get confirmation of his patent in April 1796. The personal property and tithe listing for Shenandoah County show Philip Munch with only one person over age 21 (himself), and no one between 16 and 21 from the earliest records until 1794, when he also had one male in the 16 to 21 age range and in 1796, two males between 16 and 21.[7] Philip became ill in the fall of 1796 and wrote a will in German, October 2, 1796. He began by saying I, Philip Munsch sense that my end is near, therefore, I must go hence, and I am determined to write my last will and testament in my own hand. He mentioned that his wife was to care for the children until they came of age but did not name them. He then signed his will "Philip Munsch." The will was translated by David Jordan and probated December 14, 1796. His widow, Magdalena, along with his neighbor, David McInturff, was administrator of his will. [8] Philip Munch implied in his will that all his children were still underage and this is confirmed by personal property tax records. They were parents of ten children, one died young but nine survived into adulthood. When Magdalena wrote a will in February 1807, she named three daughters and two sons who were still living at home. The nine surviving children are named in a deed dated March 11, 1811, involving the land inherited from their father.

Sources

  • Zittersheim Paroisse protestante Registre de baptemes, mariages, sepultures, 1743-1783, p. 19 (register), image #12. Archives du Bas-Rhin: http://archives.bas-rhin.fr/detail-document/ETAT-CIVIL-C555-P2-R127275#visio/page:ETAT-CIVIL-C555-P2-R127275-3154636
  • Shenandoah County, Virginia Census,1785, cited in John W. Wayland, A History of Shenandoah County, Virginia, Strasburg, VA (1927), Second Edition, (1980), p. 234.
  • Petition by Inhabitants of Powel's Fort and the South River Tract, November 5, 1793. Library of Virginia Collections, Accession #36121, Box 229, folder 32, Library of Virginia, Richmond, Virginia.
  • Shenandoah County, Virginia, Will Book "E," p. 62. Shenandoah County Court House, Woodstock, Virginia.
  • Munch Cemetery, Powell's Fort Valley. Find A Grave: Memorial #146874896 This is only a memorial. The June 3, 1796, death date is clearly wrong because Philip wrote his will, October 2, 1796. There was a cemetery on his land that disappeared over the years, but several field stones, some with short inscriptions were uncovered when a modern monument were erected on this site in 1997. A recovered stone gives Philip's death date as October 8, 1796. Orie A. Munch, Homeplace History Tradition and Memories (private publication), 1992. p. 130. Copy in Shenandoah County Library, Edinburg, Virginia.
  • Heirs of Philip Munch: A deed dated March 11, 1811, in which the children of Philip and Magdalena Munch convey their interests in the land inherited from their father to their brother, Daniel Munch. Shenandoah County Deed Book "S," pp. 105-6. Shenandoah County Court House, Woodstock, Virginia.

Note: Philip Munch, who lived in the Fort Valley of Shenandoah County, Virginia, is listed on dozens of Ancestry Family Trees as "Philipp Simon Muench," born at Friesbach in the German Palatinate in 1728, married Magdalena Elisabetha Mueller about 1768 in Pennsylvania and lived in Pennsylvania until about 1790, before coming to Virginia. There are a number of reasons to refute these assumptions: First, "Münch" in German is pronounced "Monk" or Menk," whereas Philip Munch of Shenandoah County pronounced his name with the German "sch" ending, spelled his name Munsch and never appears with a middle name. Second: Philip Simon's 1728 birthdate should have been an immediate red flag, since Philip in Virginia had a young family at the time of his death. Third: Philip Munch settled in Virginia by 1779 and stayed, Simon Muench (also appears as Minnich), was in Pennsylvania at the same time and therefore could not be the same person. In all the Ancestry trees there is not one shred of documentation identifying Philip Simon Münch, born in 1728, as the same Philip Munch who settled in Virginia or that his wife's family name was Mueller (Miller), much less identifying her parents, listed on some of the sites. There is an oral tradition that the family name of Magdalena, wife of Philip Munch in Virginia, was Mueller. This may be true, but this also lacks solid documentation and there is no record of her having a middle name Elizabeth.

Footnotes

  1. Letter from Irene Munch, Seven Fountains, VA, to Lizzie Brockway, Anna, OH, dated July 15, 1907. She states in the letter that her "great-grandfather, John Philippe Munch, and a brother came from Alsace-Lorraine before the American Revolution and that his wife, Elizabeth Miller came from the same area of Germany. I am not sure her first name was Elizabeth. They had six sons and four daughters, George a single man and Adam died young. Daniel and his sisters lived all their lives in Shenandoah County, Virginia." The entire letter has been posted on the memorial of Silas Munch at Find A Grave (Find A Grave: Memorial #146651103 by Patrick O'Flaherty, a Munch descendant.
  2. Ralph Strassburger and William J. Hinke, eds. Pennsylvania German Pioneers, 1727-1775, Norristown, PA (1934), Volume I, p. 224, transcript List 273C. Volume II (facsimile signatures), list 273C, p. 835.
  3. The only major difference between the two signatures is the German spelling, "Phillipp," on the 1768 signature and the English spelling, "Philip," on the 1796 signature. The German spelling with two "els" (somewhat unusual) and a terminal "s" is almost identical to the way several of his contemporaries in Zittersheim signed their name (see signatures of Johann Philipp Munsch and Philipp Munsch on the death record of his father Georg Munsch). The spelling of Munsch in the 1768 and 1796 signatures of Philip is remarkably similar with a relatively small capital "M" and especially with the distinctive loop over the "u." This is not an umlaut (two dots), but in German script a small dash or check is used, much like a dot over 'i" so that the "u" is not mistaken for another similar letter, but in this case it is an unusually large loop which they all used. Both signatures also have a slight downward slope in the last two letters of the name. Considering a difference of 28 years the two signatures bear a remarkable similarity.
  4. Parish Register, Evangelical Lutheran Church, Frederick, Maryland, p. 84. Digital image of a transcript at FamilySearch.org. https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-L9XF-W763?i=119. Ibid. p. 97. Digital image of a transcript at FamilySearch.org: https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:HYPS-LMT2, and p.109. Digital image of transcript found at FamilySearch.org: https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:HYP3-XGN2
  5. Philip Munch and John Cullers almost certainly knew each other in Maryland. They had children baptized within days of each other at the Frederick Lutheran Church in the spring of 1776. https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-L9XF-W763?i=119
  6. Peggy Shomo Joyner, ed. Abstracts of Virginia's Northern Neck Warrants and Surveys, Volume III, 1710-1780, Portsmouth, VA (1986), p. 17. Jacob Neuschwander signed a request that the deed to the land he had surveyed be made over to Philip Munch, March 31, 1779.
  7. Shenandoah County, Virginia Personal Property Tax Rolls, 1782-1799, microfilm roll #1, Shenandoah County Library, Edinburg, Virginia.
  8. Photostat copy of Philip's original German will, Will Book "E," Copy, p. 62a. Shenandoah County Circuit Court, Court House, Woodstock, VA. Most of the Ancestry trees also have his place of death as "Shenandoah, Page, Virginia." Shenandoah, a small town in Page County, Virginia, probably popped up on an auto-menu, but it is on the other side of the Massanutten Mountain and over 30 miles from Powell's Fort Valley, in Shenandoah County, Virginia and was only established as a town a hundred years after Philip Munch's death.




Is Philip your ancestor? Please don't go away!
 star icon Login to collaborate or comment, or
 star icon contact private message the profile manager, or
 star icon ask our community of genealogists a question.
Sponsored Search by Ancestry.com

DNA Connections
It may be possible to confirm family relationships with Philip by comparing test results with other carriers of his Y-chromosome or his mother's mitochondrial DNA. However, there are no known yDNA or mtDNA test-takers in his direct paternal or maternal line. It is likely that these autosomal DNA test-takers will share some percentage of DNA with Philip:

Have you taken a DNA test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.



Comments: 1

Leave a message for others who see this profile.
There are no comments yet.
Login to post a comment.
Images of records posted in this profile now prove that the German name of Philip Munch, of Powell's Fort Valley was originally '"Munsch" and not Munch. Therefore his LNAB should be changed to "Munsch."
posted on Munch-273 (merged) by Daniel Bly

M  >  Munsch  |  M  >  Munch  >  Johann Philipp (Munsch) Munch