| William Palmer migrated to New England during the Puritan Great Migration (1621-1640). (See Great Migration Begins, by R. C. Anderson, Vol. 3, p. 1383) Join: Puritan Great Migration Project Discuss: pgm |
Contents |
In 2013, in Caleb Johnson's article entitled "Possible Clues to the English Origins of Fortune Passenger William Palmer" he shares research showing that William Palmer was perhaps the son of William Palmer, Sr., and his wife Alice Knight, baptized at Upper Clatford, Hampshire, England, August 13, 1581. This was the same parish in which Stephen Hopkins's baptism entry is found three baptismal entries before William's. The connection is further supported by Johnson's research in which he quotes a letter written by Plymouth Colony Governor, William Bradford, and his assistant Isaac Allerton, dated September 8,1623, referring to Stephen Hopkins' brother providing nails to be used in Plymouth Colony. William Palmer was the only known nailer in Plymouth Colony, and was perhaps a brother-in-law to Bradford.[1]
In the letter mentioned above, Bradford wrote, "...we have had of his brother here...", which suggests that Hopkins' "brother" was in Plymouth in 1623. In 1627, William Palmer and his wife Frances are included within Stephen Hopkins' household. Despite doing further research, Caleb could not find an obvious connection between the Stephen Hopkins and William Palmer families such that the specific nature of their "brotherhood" could be determined. Johnson offers several ideas, and suggests that a clue may be related to the will of Alice Palmer of Wherwell (which borders Upper Clatford), dated February 21, 1624-5 in which she mentions her son Stephen Palmer (Stephen being an uncommon first name), and a small debt to Henry Hopkins.[1]
Johnson acknowledges Anderson's work in The Great Migration Begins, in which Anderson estimated that Palmer was born by 1581; the baptism entry Caleb found fits with Anderson's estimate.[1] Perhaps more research will uncover additional information.
According to Anderson in The Great Migration Begins ..., William Palmer was born c. 1581, based on the estimated date of his first marriage. His origin is unknown,[2] but may have been England.[3]
William married at least twice (possibly was an earlier marriage).[3] His two marriages, according to Anderson were: 1) Frances Unknown, about 1606; she died before 1637; and 2) Mary Unknown[2] William married Frances in England. She was probably the mother of William, Jr., according to Barclay,[3] and Frances was the mother of William, Jr., according to Anderson.[2] We know by William's will that two, or possibly three, older children remained in England when the family emigrated.[3] Frances may have been the mother of these children, also, according to Barclay,[3] and Frances was the mother, according to Anderson.[2]
Children:
William married, by 1637, probably in Plymouth, to "a young woman," Mary Unknown (who was expecting when William wrote his will). Mary married c. 1644-6, second, and as his second, to Robert Paddock; and on 24 March 1650/1, third, Thomas Roberts. Child born posthumously to William Palmer Sr.:
William sailed in 1621 aboard the Fortune.[2] He was likely of the London (not Leiden) group of Pilgrims.[citation needed] Palmer suggests he was initially on the Speedwell, and returned to London after that ship faltered, coming the next year on the Fortune with his son, William, age 8.[4] [QUESTION: Is William's age actually listed on the passenger list?] His first wife, Frances, arrived a little later, in 1623, aboard the Anne.[2]
The family settled at Plymouth where William worked as a "nailer."[2] His inventory included a bellows, an anvil, a vice, the tools of nail-making.[2] In 1623, William and Frances received two and one acres, respectively, as their shares of the Plymouth land division.[2] In the 1627 division of cattle, William, Frances, and William, Jr. are 8th, 9th, and 10th on the seventh company list.[2] William was taxed £1 7s in 1633, and 18s in 1634; William and his son, William, are both on the freeman list of 1633.[2][3]
He received a two-acre grant as a passenger on that ship - one acre for his servant William Carvanyell and one for himself. His son William also accompanied him in the Fortune, but was not yet 10 at the time of the land grants.321 His wife Frances followed on the Anne and received one acre, indicating she was not accompanied by any children over the age of 10. [citation needed]
Will, dated 7 November 1637 and proved 4 December 1637:
William Palmer of Ducksborrow, nailer, being ill in body" named "my loving friends Mr. William Bradford, Mr. Edward Winslowe and Mr. Thomas Prence my executors"; "whereas I have married a young woman who is dear unto me I desire them to deal well with her but my desire is that my estate consisting of land, household goods, ... may be sold and turned into money all except such moveables as my executors think meet to give her for her personal comfort. Next my estate being wholly sold my desire is that my wife may not have less than one third and if she be with child then another third to be preserved and improved by my executors for that child as mine heir and that if in case she be not with child, then I would have mine executors as in conscience they are persuaded out of the remainder of my estate deal with Rebecca my grandchild and Moyses Rowley whom I love, but not so as to put into their father or mother's hands but preserve it for them till they come to years of discretion"; "somewhat to Stephen Tracy"; "somewhat towards the meeting house at Plymouth"; "young Rowley to be placed with Mr. Partridge that he might be brought up in the fear of God and to that end if his father suffer it I give to Mr. Patridge £5"; "in case my son Henry or daughter Bridgett be living, if they demand it, I give them 40s. apiece if they be living." Further "it was the will of the testator that his wife should be ruled by her ancient Mr. Edward Winslow in her marriage if she look to partake in any part of this estate, otherwise not" [MD 2:147-48, citing PCPR 1:28].[5][6]
The inventory of "all the moveable goods of Will[ia]m Palm[e]r the elder, taken 13 November 1637, totaled £111 12s. 4d. [MD 2:148-52, citing PCPR 1:28-29].[5][6]
Born by about 1581, based on estimated date of first marriage. Nailer who came to Massachusetts Bay in 1621on the "Fortune." First settled in Plymouth, then moved to Duxbury. Died in Duxbury between 7 November 1637 (data of will) 13 November 1637 (date of inventory). On 2 January 1637/8 Mr. Hopkins was presented for allowing excessive drinking in his house. "Old Palmer " was one of the men said to have been drunk there, and Widow Palmer an Widow Palmer's man were two of the witnesses, suggesting that the Widow may have blamed mr. Hopkins for allowing her husband to drink too much. Married: (1) By about 1606 n 1623 and had died by 1637. (2) By 1637 Mary_____; she married (2) by 20 October 1646 Robert Paddock; she married (3) Plymouth 24 March 1650/1Thomas Roberts.
Disputes as to origin, birth and parentage, etc. Misinformation about this man is spread across the Internet. There are many claims that have no documented source. They include:
Carlton Palmer Jr's work, referenced above, has some good information in it, but much is not cited.[4] Where he cites his work, it appears solid. Otherwise, I don't see how we can go with his claims without additional confirmation. (For example, he suggests strongly-- although admits its not proven-- that the emigrant William Palmer was son of another William Palmer in London, mariner, will dated 13 Apr 1602. (Anderson in GMB does not go with Carlton Palmer.)
In 1956 Florence Barclay produced the definitive article on William Palmer, resolving many of the outstanding problems, outlining the careers of the two sons of the immigrant named William, and pointing out several errors in Savage, particularly the mixing of William (b. 1612) with the man who went to Newtown, Long Island [TAG 32:39-45]... Carlton A. Palmer, Jr., has published several articles attempting to outline the three Williams and their wives and arriving at conclusions contrary to those of Florence Barclay [The Augustan Society Omnibus 9:101-103, 107; MQ 50:188-90]. Unfortunately, his misunderstanding of the meaning of "son-in-law" undermines his own arguments."[3]
This would seem to indicate we should go with Barclay's findings.
See also:
Have you taken a DNA test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.
Featured National Park champion connections: William is 13 degrees from Theodore Roosevelt, 20 degrees from Stephanus Johannes Paulus Kruger, 11 degrees from George Catlin, 12 degrees from Marjory Douglas, 21 degrees from Sueko Embrey, 12 degrees from George Grinnell, 25 degrees from Anton Kröller, 13 degrees from Stephen Mather, 20 degrees from Kara McKean, 15 degrees from John Muir, 15 degrees from Victoria Hanover and 23 degrees from Charles Young on our single family tree. Login to find your connection.
The birth of William Palmer, to Johis Palmer, in Waterside, South Yorkshire, is recorded in the Howden parish records, 12 August, 1582. The village of Waterside is only 14 miles from the town of Scrooby, the gathering place of the original Mayflower Pilgrims who would leave England for Holland beginning in 1608. William Palmer married, on 16 Oct 1613, in the parish minster at Howden, a woman named Frances Wallis. Knowing that the wife of William Palmer of the Plymouth Colony was named Francis, confirms that this William Palmer, born in Waterside Yorkshire, so close to Scrooby, who married Francis Wallis, is almost certainly the Pilgrim William Palmer of Plymouth, and his wife Francis. We might also note that William Palmer named a daughter Bridgitt. The wife of the Pilgrim leader John Robinson was Bridgitt.
The original group of Scrooby emigres left for Amsterdam, starting in 1608, moving in small groups, then, in 1609, moving on to Leiden, Holland, where the congregation settled.
William and Frances apparently followed the Scrooby congregation to Holland, sometime after their 1613 marriage, embarking from there for Plymouth in 1621 and 1623. Their presence in Leiden is supported by the bequest, in William's will, to Stephen Tracy of Plymouth, documented as having been with the Pilgrims in Leyden. Presumably Stephen was close to the family in Leiden, and may have been a support to Frances during William's absence between 1621 and 1623, William (and his son William) having left on the second ship to sail for Plymouth, the Fortune, which sailed from London in early July 1621. Francis, and Stephen Tracy, followed in 1623, in the Anne.
William was apparently married, at least once, before his marriage to Frances Wallis. His will mentions bequests to his two children, Henry and Bridgitt "...if they be liveing." To have been left behind when William and Frances emigrated to America, they must have been older, too old to have been born after William and Frances' 1613 marriage. If they were children of Frances, they would have been at most 9 years in 1621, and likely would have accompanied Frances when she arrived in Plymouth in 1623. Additionally, William's son William J., who sailed with William Sr on the Fortune, was also too old to have been a son of Francis. He was aged 21 by 1633, when he is documented as a Freeman of Plymouth, therefore, William Jr had to have been born no later than 1612, which would imply a marriage before 1611, and before William's 1613 marriage to Frances.
It may be that William's previous wife had died shortly after William Jr's birth, and shortly before William's marriage to Francis.
There were three other marriages involving a William Palmer, in the area around South Yorkshire, between 1596 and 1608. A William Palmer married Margret Elebye in Nov 1596, at Selby Abbey, Yorkshire - 5 miles from Howden, and 12 miles from Waterside. Another marriage was to Helein Sanderson, at St Martin le Grand, in the city of York, on 30 August 1601, 17 miles from Howden, 24 miles from Waterside. And another, to Elizabetha Pagett, on 3 July 1608, at Darrington, 16 miles from Howden, and 12 miles from Waterside. Any could have been a marriage to William who married Frances in 1613. The comment from William's will "if they be living," suggests that perhaps Henry and Bridgitt were beyond their teens, when William sailed for America, making it less likely that Elizabetha Pagett, of the 1608 marriage, was the mother of Henry and Bridgitt, as well as William's unknown daughter who married Henry Rowley; that unknown daughter did not accompany William or Francis to Plymouth, indicating that she was already married, and older than her brother William Jr, when William and his son William Jr. sailed for Plymouth.
The marriage to Margret Elebye in 1596, when William was 14, would be possible, but completing an apprenticeship at that young age, though, even in the less-skilled trades, and being established enough to immediately marry, would be uncommon.
The August 1601 marriage to Helein Sanderson would seem more likely, as William's older children, Henry and Bridgitt, would still have been old enough to have been apprenticed at the more typical ages of 12 to 14, or to have been married, before William sailed for America in 1621. She could also have been the parent of both William Jr and William's unknown daughter who married Henry Rowley. Also, a Henry Sanderson was born 14 June 1562, in Doddington, Lincolnshire, about 20 miles from Scrooby, both old enough to have been the father of Helein and with the right name to have been the namesake for William Palmer's first son - Henry. It's worth noting, though, that Elizabetha Padgett, of the 1608 marriage, could easily have been the mother to the youngest child, William Jr, as a 2nd wife to William Sr (thus making Francis William's 3rd wife).
William was granted 2 acres during the 1623 land allotment for those on the Fortune, indicating that his son William Jr. must have accompanied him; William's wife Frances received 1 acre during the drawing for those on the Anne.
William Sr. had another daughter who married Henry Rowley; we don't know her name. He left a bequest to his grandson Moses Rowley in his will, but he did not mention Moses' mother, who must have died before the will was written. She did not accompany William or Francis on the voyage to Plymouth. She must have married Henry Rowley in either Leiden, or perhaps even before William and Francis emigrated from England to Leiden. We know Moses must have been born by about 1630, so his mother must have been born by about 1610 at the latest. The average age for women to marry in Puritan society at the time was about 23 years old, so she would have been born probably about 1605 to 1610. She could have been the daughter of either Helein Sanderson or Elizabetha Pagett.
William and his family removed to Duxbury after 1633 along with Myles Standish, John Allen, Jonathan Brewster, Love Brewster, William Bassett, Steven Tracy, William Sprague and others.
William Jr died before the 1637 death of his father. He died sometime between 1 Jan. 1635, when he was admitted as a freeman in Plymouth Colony, and the 25 Aug 1636 inventory of his estate. His widow, Elizabeth, remarried to Deacon John Willis of Duxbury. Elizabeth and her 2nd husband John Willis later sued William Sr's estate, claiming interest in a property owed to Elizabeth by right of her marriage to William.
It's not known when William's wife Francis died, but it was probably in the mid-1630's. By the time William wrote his 7 Nov 1637 will, William was remarried to a younger wife, Mary, whom he suspected, and who indeed was, pregnant; "...whereas I have marryed a yeong woman who is deare unto me... my desire is that my wife my not have lesse than one third then if in case shee be wth child as myne heire." William died shortly after writing his will - the inventory was taken 13 Nov 1637, 6 days later - Mary delivered their son 27 Jun 1638, in Duxbury, after his death. She named their son William, thus giving William Sr. two sons named William, a practice not uncommon at the time, when an earlier child died.
Thank you for your work on considerable post. Might this effort be best advanced on a linked WikiTree Free Space Page, where you and others could collaborate to provide sources and inline citations? Such work might form the basis for an array of G2G questions, so the effort could engage an even broader audience. --Gene
I do not have Johnson's book, but Johnson also wrote, "Possible Clues to the English Origins of Fortune Passenger William Palmer," The Mayflower Descendant, 62 (2013):66-; digital images by subscription, AmericanAncestors.
From p. 67, citing Upper Clatford parish registers for, "William the son of William Palmer [baptized] the 13th day of August [1581]."
Johnson associates the father was "William Palmer [Sr.] married Alice Knight on 2 October 1580 at Upper Clatford, Hampshire." Further claiming there are two other children baptized of this William [Sr.]--Robert in 1583/4 and Rose, 1587.
It's possible I missed something in my brief review of the 2013 article, but it sounded to me as though the immigrant's association as son of William and Alice was promising, perhaps even probably, but still lacking related documents to prove the son was the immigrant. Ala, finding a connection that would explain "why Stephen Hopkins considered William Palmer to be his brother.
In the final paragraph or so, Johnson mentions one or more clues in the records that, with further digging, might provide and answer and thus the needed proof.
Others might approach this differently, I would suggest ...
(1) If there are not already entries on WikiTree for the possible parents (I didn't find them), they could/should be added to the database. There seem to be enough information in the 2013 article to support profiles for both. likewise for the two other children baptized, Robert and Rose.
(2) Profile of the immigrant, William Palmer, is lacking a section for Research Notes (generally just before Sources). A note could be added to that new section, Possible Parents referencing the material in MD 2013 article (perhaps there is more in the book that should be added also), and links between the profiles could be made there.
Would you be comfortable undertaking this work?
Thank you again for supporting WikiTree.--Gene
Edited to add: I see Sharon has added a research maintenance category. Would you be willing to take it from there, Bruce?
edited by GeneJ X
The first marriage occurred in England approx. 1606 and was to Frances (Blossom?). She preceded him in death in either 1636 or 1637 (unsure which because of how they did years back then). He then married Mary, who was much younger than him as stated in his will and he ended up dying in November of 1637. She got remarried to a Robert Paddock by Oct of 1646.
The following Wikipedia page has some information: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passengers_of_1621_Fortune_voyage William Palmer – He was one of the older passengers, born in 1581. He was a nailer by profession. He came without his family and received one acre in the 1623 land division. Member of the 1626 Purchase investment group as “Willm. Palmer.” His family came over on the Anne in 1623 and his wife Frances received one acre in the 1623 land division as an Anne passenger under “ffrance wife to Wit Palmer.” In 1627 his wife Frances and son William shared in the division of cattle list as “William Pallmer,” wife “ffrances” and son “Willm Pallmer Jnor.” He died in Duxbury, November, 1637.[26]
Please approve if you agree these represent the same person.
Thanks!