no image

Sarah (Beall) Magruder (1669 - 1734)

Privacy Level: Open (White)
Sarah Magruder formerly Beall
Born in Largo, Fife, Scotlandmap
Ancestors ancestors
Wife of — married in Prince George's, Province of Marylandmap
[children unknown]
Died in Prince George's, Province of Marylandmap
Beall-81 created 9 May 2011 | Last modified
This page has been accessed 1,851 times.

Categories: Uncertain Existence | Sarah Beall Magruder Legend.

Research suggests that this person may never have existed. See the text for details.

Contents

Proposed Disposition of Profile

Various theories have been proposed regarding the Sarah who married Samuel Magruder. While this has been disproven, The most prevalent legend regarding this Sarah is that she was Sarah Beall, daughter of Ninian.

The proposed disposition of this file is to record the various theories under the following free space profile: http://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Space:The_Mystery_of_Sarah_Magruder linked to this profile of Sarah Beall, which would live on as a "legend."

Questions about Identity

This Sarah Beall and her family may or may not have actually existed and are the stuff of legends.

There are a number of theories as to who this Sarah is:

  • Sarah was born 1658, [1] was son of James, born say 1634, of Largo, Fife Co, Scotland.
  • Sarah was the daughter of Col. Ninian Beall. Note that Ninian Beall's father James was b. 1600. No major authors give credence to this. If Sarah were daughter of Ninian, then in the marriage of Elizabeth Magruder and Ninian Jr one would have the marriage of Sarah's daughter to Sarah's younger brother, a most unlikely combination!
  • Sarah was the sister of Mary Bell, who married John Pottenger That seemed to be corroborated by the fact that a Sarah Bell and a Mary Bell were transported into Maryland (although it seems most unlikely that they were sisters, since they arrived in Maryland 15 years apart. Brice Clagett (bclagett@cov.com believes there were no Beall Sisters: I suspect the "Beall sisters" myth for the wives of Samuel Magruder and John Pottenger originated in some one's speculation that Samual Magruder's wife Sarah must have been a Beall because the Beall and Magruder families were neighbors in Maryland and of Scottish origin, and that Samuel Magruder named a son Ninean Magruder. Then, I suspect, it was deduced that John Pottenger's wife must have been Sarah Beall's sister because he was Samuel Magruder's "brother."
  • Immigrated to Maryland in 1690 with Rev. Nathaniel Taylor. (FMMB ). Transported to MD 1675 (Immigration records, Brice Clagett) while Mary transported 1660. FMMB has arrival 1690 with Rev. Nathaniel Taylor. However, Brice Clagett (bclagett@cov.com) believes it unlikely that Mary and Sarah were sisters, or that Sarah was the wife of Samuel Magruder. The idea that Samuel Magruder's wife Sarah was nee Beall probably originated with Samuel's having named a son Ninean Magruder, but that falls far short of proof. (Ninean is a not-uncommon Scots saint's name; Col. Ninean Beall was the most prominent Scots settler in Maryland and a close neighbor, and presumably friend, of the Magruders.)
  • 1686 Sarah Beall married Samuel Magruder, b. 1654
  • From the merged file: Spouse: Sarah Beall. Born: 1669 in Largo, Ligensheim, Fifeshire, Scotland, and died 9 MAY 1734 in Prince George's Co., MD. She was the daughter of Ninian BEALL and Ruth MOORE.
  • From the merged file: Due to a fire of Calvert county records there is no evidence that her father was Ninian Beall. If not, she was a relative. Ninian Beall's will mentions grandsons that are Sarah's sons. I see that Ninian is Sarah's father. He does have a dau. listed as Sarah. In this span of time there are three different Beals that married their cousins and combined with the Magruders. They are all from Scotland. Joshua and Josiah Beall are the same person.

The Legend of Sarah Beall

Sarah Beall's name exists primarily on popular genealogies.[2][3][4]

Sarah Beall is said to have been born in 1669 in Largo, Fife, Scotland. [5][6][7][8]

Sarah Beall is sometimes said to be the daughter of Ninian Beall, but she is not listed in his will, and subsequent relationships between Sarah and Ninian's descendants would be incestuous if she were his daughter.

Sarah Beall is said to have married Samuel Magruder[9]

Sarah is said to have died on 09 MAY 1734 in Prince George's County, Maryland[10]

Sources

  1. or 1669-1734: Alberta Utz
  2. Source: #S-2050775419 Note: http://trees.ancestry.com/rd?f=sse&db=genepool&h=3752683&ti=0&indiv=try&gss=pt Note: http://trees.ancestry.com/rd?f=sse&db=genepool&h=3752682&ti=0&indiv=try&gss=pt
  3. Source: #S-2050775418 Note: http://trees.ancestry.com/rd?f=sse&db=genepoolb&h=325563&ti=0&indiv=try&gss=pt
  4. Source: #S-2050775427 http://trees.ancestry.com/pt/AMTCitationRedir.aspx?tid=13232476&pid=-35437701
  5. Source: #S-2050775419
  6. Source: #S-2050775418 Title: Family Data Collection - Births. Edmund West, compiler. The Generations Network, Inc., 2001, Provo, UT, USA.
  7. Title: Family Data Collection - Individual Records. Edmund West, compiler. Ancestry.com
  8. Title: Ancestry Family Trees, Ancestry.com.
  9. Family Data Collection - Marriages. Edmund West, compiler. The Generations Network, Inc., 2001, Provo, UT, USA.
  10. Source: #S-2050775419

Will of Ninian Beall

Beall, Ninian,Prince George's Co.,15th Jan., 1717; 28th Feb., 1717.

  • To son Geo. and hrs., 480 A., “Rock of Dumbarton,” on Rock Creek, and personalty.
  • To son Charles and hrs., 1,000 A., “Dunn Back,” on Wattes Creek, s. side Gr. Choptank, and personalty.
  • To granddau. Mary Beall and hrs. (dau. of son Ninian, deceased), after payment of legacies, ½ of personal est., also that part of “Bacon Hall” lying on s. side of road to “Mt. Calvert,” and to have her share at marriage.
  • To grandson Samuel Beall, ex., and hrs., water mill on Collington Branch and remaining part of “Bacon Hall,” providing that at 21 yrs. he makes over to afsd. Mary Beall a tract of land called “Sams Beginning” on s. side of sd. road to “Mt. Calvert.” Shd. he die before he be of age to convey land afsd., then the entire tract of “Bacon Hall” is bequeathed to sd. granddau. Mary Beall.
  • To son-in-law Andrew Hambleton, personalty.
  • To son-in-law Joseph Belt and hrs., 245 A., “Good Luck,” he to allow to heirs of testator 4,000 lbs. tobacco.
  • Two grandchildren of deceased son Ninian to be cared for and educated.
  • Test. directs that a tract of 400 A., “The Recovery,” in the Freshes of Patuxent R., at head of Weston Branch, and adj. land bequeathed to Joseph Belt, be sold for payment of debts.
  • Sons Charles, Joseph Belt and Geo. to aid executor until he arrives at age of 21 yrs.
  • Test: John Busey, Rebecca Getward, Ed. Willet. [11]


More Genealogy Tools



Sponsored by MyHeritage




Search
Searching for someone else?
First: Last:

DNA
No known carriers of Sarah's ancestors' mitochondrial DNA have taken an mtDNA test.

Have you taken a DNA test for genealogy? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Family Tree DNA.



Collaboration

On 19 Jun 2017 at 22:19 GMT Donna Roberts wrote:

It is possible that William Mills is her father.

Samuel and Sarah named a son William and had a grandson by their son Samuel, named William Mills Magruder.

Sarah who married Samuel Magruder could not be a daughter of Ninian Beall Citation:

Source text: It is well documented that Ninian Beall had a son Ninian Beall, Jr. who married Elizabeth Magruder, daughter of Samuel Magruder and wife Sarah. See the 1731 will of Samuel Magruder's widow Sarah where she named a daughter Elizabeth, wife of William Bell. Elizabeth had married first, Ninian Beall, Jr (son of Ninian and Ruth) and secondly William Beall. If Elizabeth Magruder's mother Sarah was a daughter of Ninian Beall, Sr., that would mean that her first husband Ninian Beall, Jr. (son of Ninian, Sr.) was her blood uncle. Marriages of that close a relation were forbidden then, just as now. There is NO evidence in original records to indicate that Sarah was a Beall, much less a daughter of Ninian. The "thought" that she was a Beall appears to originated from the fact that Samuel Magruder and wife Sarah had a son named Ninian. It was not uncommon to name family members after friends, church elders, leaders of the community, etc., of which Ninian Beall would have been all three to the Magruder family. Members wanting to join a lineage society in the early 1900s "created" [forged/falsified] this relationship so that they could join under Ninian Beall, and thousands of people have accepted this forgery as fact, and spread it through their records.

Reason attached to person: to show why Sarah cannot be a daughter of Ninian Beall

On 19 Jun 2017 at 14:59 GMT Sandra Scarborough wrote:

Maryland, one of the original 13 colonies, ratified the Constitution, Monday, April 28, 1788, prior to that it was referred to as the Province of Maryland

On 16 Apr 2016 at 19:27 GMT Sandra Scarborough wrote:

Beall-537 and Beall-81 appear to represent the same person because: duplicate

On 25 Mar 2015 at 20:57 GMT A. (Johnson) Tomkins wrote:

I would like to remove Sarah's existing parents, Ninian and Ruth (Moore) Beall, from this profile. Please let me know if this is okay. Based on the evidence Jack Day listed (in the profile itself) and Maryland and Virginia Colonials, which corroborates that Ninian Beall did not have a daughter named Sarah, I believe these parents should be removed.

On 3 Jun 2014 at 03:50 GMT Sharon Casteel wrote:

Beall-201 and Beall-81 appear to represent the same person because: Both are married to the same Samuel Magruder. (Though there's apparently some debate about whether Sarah is actually a Beall; see the thread here: http://genforum.genealogy.com/magruder/messages/1126.html. Nonetheless, whether or not Sarah's a Beall, I suspect they're the same Sarah!)



Sarah is 15 degrees from Kevin Bacon, 16 degrees from Joseph Broussard, 22 degrees from Helmut Jungschaffer and 14 degrees from Queen Elizabeth II Windsor on our single family tree. Login to find your connection.

B  >  Beall  |  M  >  Magruder  >  Sarah (Beall) Magruder