Anthony Buckner (1731 - 1780)

Born 30 Apr 1731 in St Pauls Parish, Stafford, Virginia

Husband of Amy (Powell) Buckner — married 20 Apr 1755 in St Pauls Parish, Stafford, Virginia

Descendants

Died 18 May 1780 at age 49 in Halifax, Virginia, USA

Biography

Anthony Buckner is a well-known mystery in Buckner genealogy. His family is fairly well documented in the parish registers of St. Paul's Parish in Stafford County, VA, at least by the standards of 18th century records. This documents the birth of his and Amy's daughter Parthenia (14 Oct 1758), the marriage of "Anthony Buckner Thomas" to Amy Powell (20 Apr 1755), and the birth of "Anthony Buckner son of Jane Kelley alias Thomas" (30 Apr 1731).^[1] Anthony left a will^[2] which has been a key piece of information in figuring out his biography.

They had 10 children known from his will:

• Parthena (1758-1827)
• Rice
• Anthony (d. 1806, Pittsylvania County)
• Elisha
• William
• Linney
• Winifred (m. John Edmunds)
• John (probably died young - no later evidence of him is known)
• Elizabeth
• Dullender (m. William Walden)

Amy Powell was probably the daughter of William and Amy Powell who was born in St Pauls Parish 10 Sep 1736, per the same parish registers.^[1]

The usual interpretation of this is that Anthony was the illegitimate son of Jane Kelly and an unknown Buckner. One might go a little further and surmise that Jane Kelly was the widow of Wilford Kelley, who died 24 Aug 1728.^[1] Wilford and Jane Kelly had a son Thomas born in 1728 and a daughter Sarah in 1721, and it can also be surmised that Jane's maiden name was Thomas. It's not impossible that she was the same Jane Kelly who married Henry Smith on 24 Sep 1733 either, though this connection seems more tenuous.

On the Buckner side, there were numerous Buckners in the parish, and the conventional register transcription records the deaths of two different Anthony Buckners on 21 Mar 1733/4 and 1 Dec 1734. This double death record has led some to suspect errors in the transcription, though in any case there was an Anthony Buckner there in the parish who could reasonably be the father of the present Anthony Buckner. Because an Anthony Buckner is said to have witnessed the estate of John Bulling on Apr 27, 1734, the latter death date is probably that of the adult Anthony Buckner, and the earlier death date might be for that Anthony's if this is correct.

The relationships of these Buckners to the 17th century immigrant brothers John and Phillip Buckner is unclear, though as the earliest Buckner recorded in the register is Robert Buckner (d. 25 Oct 1718) it is natural to suppose that at least some of them descended from Phillip, who named sons Robert and Andrew in his will. Beyond that point, there are several theories, but solid data is lacking.

An important question is whether the Robert Buckner who died in 1718 was Robert, Phillip's son, or perhaps Robert's son or even a nephew or cousin. There seems to be a more or less continuous string of records of Robert Buckners from around 1710 up into the late 1720s, but it turns out that the later ones belong to a wholly different Robert Buckner ("of Gloucester County"), who now appears to be a hitherto undocumented son of Thomas Buckner of Gloucester. Thus Robert, Phillip's son, is probably the one who died in 1718 and can be ruled out as Anthony Buckner Thomas's father.

Another possibility is that some or all these Buckners in the parish register were children of Anthony Buckner, a contemporary of Robert's who lived in Stafford Co. as late as 1708 and was married to an Ellis. This Anthony may have been the son of the elder Anthony Buckner, who apparently died around 1689 and was probably an immigrant brother or cousin of John and Phillip Buckner. However, one other thing we should take into account is that Wilford Kelley's land was located near the Upper Machodoc Creek (now in King George Co.) which is very close to where Phillip lived and on the other side of the county from where Anthony's land was (on the Aquia Creek). William Buckner of York's land was also in this area, and by 1731 it had descended to his younger son John, who died in 1748 without (known) issue. The list of known male Buckners that would likely have been living in that area thus includes John (son of William, son of John the immigrant), Peyton (probably a son of Robert, but this is uncertain), Anthony Jr. (d. 1734), and another John Buckner who died in 1752. This last John had a sister named Sarah who married Thomas Price. After John's only child Susan (or Susannah) died in 1755, his land was inherited by his sister, so it is clear that Sarah (Buckner) Price was the only legitimate descendant of their father who was alive in 1756. This means that Peyton and John (d. 1752) could not be brothers, as Peyton's children were then still alive. Some evidence suggests that Peyton and John were coheirs of Phillip's 90-odd acre property on Gambo Creek (near Upper Machodoc), which might imply that one was the son of Robert and one was the son of Andrew, though it is not clear which was which. The occurrence of the name "Anthony" is clearly an important clue though. Peyton had a son named Anthony as well, to complicate things. Thus we really have 4 decent possibilities for Anthony Buckner Thomas' father. Anthony Jr. is attractive simply because of the names, plus the likelihood that he had no other offspring, which could explain the apparent legitimization of Anthony Buckner Thomas (and his wealth), but any of the other three John, Peyton, or John is attractive based on the geographic proximity to Wilford Kelley's land.

In Halifax county, Anthony Buckner and/or Thomas is also known from a Feb 1769 court record there in which he was assigned to road service as a corvee, under the name "Anthony Buckner" (the "Thomas" part seems to have disappeared after he left Stafford County).^[3]

An interesting thing to note is that Anthony was, to judge from his estate, quite successful as a planter. One scenario is that Anthony Buckner/Thomas may have ended up being the only surviving son of Anthony Buckner, legitimate or otherwise, and perhaps his father decided to pass on his estate to his Anthony Thomas/Buckner, lacking any other close heirs. We should keep in mind though that there were two other Buckners of the same generation from the same area, Peyton and Anthony (later of Wood Co. VA). At any rate, land doesn't appear out of thin air, so it seems likely that Anthony Buckner/Thomas came into a reasonable inheritance at some point in his life.

Several Prince William Co. VA records seem to refer to him as well, particularly one in 1765 where "Anthony Buckner Kelley" and his wife Amy sold 300 acres to Francis Jackson for 25 pounds. The deed indicates that it was part of a parcel of 590 acres they bought from Mason and Mary Bennett in 1760. Deeds from 1766 and 1767 refer to his property line. It is worth noting that Anthony Buckner the immigrant (d.ca. 1689) in 1678 received a 2506 acre patent in Stafford County, which he still owned as of 1689 just before his death, so if Anthony Buckner/Thomas/Kelley had inherited that patrilineally from Anthony Jr. and Anthony Sr., then he may have sold that or some portion of it to buy the 590 acres in PWCo. Note also that the Mason Bennett in the above real estate purchase was a cousin of Cossum Bennett, Anthony Buckner Jr.'s brother in law. Unfortunately, Stafford Co. records are quite fragmentary from that period, so there are no records known which indicate when and by whom the ~500 acre Stafford plot was disposed of.

Two Halifax deeds from 15 June 1769 and 19 April 1770 also refer to Anthony Buckner's property.^[4] Thus they seem to have moved to Halifax in the late 1760s.

A last curious Prince William Co. record indicates that a deed was proved on 1 Mar 1784 by Anthony Buckner. As Anthony Buckner/Thomas/Kelley was dead by then, this probably either was Anthony Buckner later of Wood Co. VA or Anthony Buckner Jr. (the present Anthony's son). I don't think Anthony Buckner Jr. was of age by this time, so most likely the former.

In 1782, his widow Amy (Powell) Buckner was enumerated in the Virginia census in Halifax with 10 "white" individuals and 3 "black" individuals. She appears consistently in Halifax tax records at least to 1810. There is a similar 1785 entry for "Avery Backner" (according to the transcription) with 10 "white souls", which is probably her. A 1789 Halifax personal property tax list has "Amey Bucknal" (p.3, taken on July 6th) with herself as the only "white above 21" with 2 whites between 16 and 21 and 8 blacks over 21. In the same tax list, a Thomas Buckner is also listed as a "white above 21" living in the household of George Carrington (p. 6). The long-lived Amey Buckner appears again in page 3 of the 1798 Halifax personal property tax list (2 whites over 16 and 3 blacks), as does Thomas (2 whites over 16 and 2 blacks), as does an "Ellett" Buckner (p.2, with 1 white over 16, perhaps one of the many Aylett Buckners). "Anthoney Buckner", almost certainly the son in the will, appears in 1800 in nearby Pittsylvania Co. as the only white over 16 in the household.

Thomas and "Ellett" Buckner, probably originally "Aylett," do not appear to be Anthony's sons, and it now appears that that family descends from Phillip Buckner and Jane Aylett of Louisa Co. VA.

Name

Anthony Thomas /Buckner/^[5]

Sources

• Source: S118 Title: Ancestry Family Trees Publication: Name: Online publication - Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com. Original data: Family Tree files submitted by Ancestry members.; Repository: #R1 NOTEThis information comes from 1 or more individual Ancestry Family Tree files. This source citation points you to a current version of those files. Note: The owners of these tree files may have removed or changed information since this source citation was created.
• Repository: R1 Name: Ancestry.com Address: http://www.Ancestry.com E-Mail Address: Phone Number:

1. ↑ ^{1.0 1.1 1.2} St. Paul's Parish Register: Stafford-King George Counties, Virginia, 1715-1798, J.B.C. Nicklin, ed., Clearfield Press (date uncertain) - unattributed copies of the same transcriptions have also been published elsewhere)
2. ↑ Halifax Co. Willbook 1, pg. 312, see transcription
3. ↑ Halifax Co. VA Plea Book 6, p. 273) [LDS Microfilm 31921, Item 1]
4. ↑ Marian Dodson Chiarito, Halifax County, Virginia Deed Book 7 (1767-(1770), p. 365 & 504)
5. ↑ Source: #S118 Page: Ancestry Family Tree

Acknowledgments

Thank you to Clay Henson for creating WikiTree profile Buckner-277 through the import of Henson Family Tree_2013-03-12.ged on Mar 12, 2013.

Click to the Changes page for the details of edits by Clay and others.