Daniel Anderson Duncan (1721 - 1782)

Born 1721 in Surry-Sussex, Colony of Virginia [uncertain]

Husband of Elizabeth (Patterson) Duncan — married 7 Apr 1757 in Surry, Colony of Virginia

Descendants

Died Mar 1782 at about age 61 in Caswell, North Carolina, United States

Problems/Questions Profile managers: Loretta Buckner [send private message], Karen Fleming [send private message], and Jarrett Snider [send private message]

Biography

Daniel Duncan is a member of Duncan Clan.

Estimated Birth 1695-1745 -- likely 1720-1740

Estimated Marriage - Unknown 1743- Possibly 2X

1st Frances Unknown

2nd Mary (Unknown) (presumed to be Mary Church) (1720-1796 - parents unknown) - (Admin of Estate)

Death Estimate Before Feb 1794 Caswell County, North Carolina

Discrepancy

No original source records have been located to confirm birth or marriage records. It appears that some erroneous information may have been published, and perhaps republished/reported, making the “actual facts” obscure. There is a great deal of conflicting information surrounding the Duncan Families in North Carolina – Many Source-to-Source discrepancies; co-mingling of records, Lack of records; conflicting family stories; number of Duncan’s with the same names, inter-marriages, etc.

There are several Duncans that seem to originate from Albermarle Parish -- many named Nathaniel, Daniel, David etc. Therefore, it is recommended that researchers perform their own thorough analysis of the different family lines.

See Research Notes regarding Daniel/Nathaniel. Both had sons named Nathaniel (aka Nathan aka Nathanel) There is a good deal of controversy regarding which Nathaniel married Jane Rainey Nov. 6 1782 North Carolina.

Surry County VA Formed 1652 from James City County

Sussex County VA Formed 1753-4 from Surry

Family Location Surry/Sussex Virginia to Caswell Co North Carolina to Henderson Kentucky and Georgia

• This Profile Represents Daniel Anderson Duncan (1735 - 1781) m Mary Capeheart and Elizabeth Patterson (son of David and Elizabeth Duncan of Surry County, Virginia)

Discrepancy

Maintain as separate Profiles - Do Not Merge TBDEdwards-7481

Parent Conflict - presumed Rev. David Duncan (Born 1700 in Devon, England)

vs David and Elizabeth Duncan of Surry County, Virginia

Contemporary

• Daniel Duncan m Mary Church (son of David Duncan and Elizabeth (Unknown)
• Daniel Anderson Duncan (1735 - 1781) m Mary Capeheart and Elizabeth Patterson (son of David and Elizabeth Duncan of Surry County, Virginia)
• Daniel Duncan (1742 --1842) Son of Daniel Duncan and Sarah (Rice) m Zervillah (Rice
• Daniel Duncan (1742 - bef. 1842) (son of Son of Nathaniel Duncan and Jane Rainey

Daniel Duncan son of David Duncan and Elizabeth Unknown

Named in David's Will - See the 1744 will of David Duncan in Surry Co. VA with the records of Nathaniel Duncan d. 1773.)

Presumed Children

Estimated Children Births between 1744-1780 Named in Estates, but otherwise Unproven as Children (See Will Transcripts) and Marriages in Caswell)

• Possibly 2 daughters named Mary - one older as guardian/adiministrator and one younger) (p.41); (Mary (the older) may, in fact, be spouse Mrs. Mary)

Mary (the older)

Mary Duncan (the younger)

• (Mary) "Polly" Ragsdale (m. Benjamin Ragsdale 1792) ^[1]
• Frances (Francis) Duncan (m Madden) (Champness Maddin 17 Jan 1792^[2])
• Patience Wilkerson (m. Wager Wilkerson May 27 1780)
• Nathaniel Duncan (m. Jane Rainey Nov 6 1782]])
• Jessee (Jesse) Duncan (m. Hannah Paschall, dau of William Paschal Jul 14 1780)^[3]
• Elizabeth m. Unknown
• Nancy (m.Daniel Merritt Jan 27 1784
• Abner m Unknown
• Martin m. Mary Polly Ray 15 Sep 1806^[4]
• Sally Stanton (m Unknown Stanton/Staneton/Stenson/Stinson^[5]

(Possible Son-in-Laws)

• Will Rainey, Ruben Newton, Archibald Murphey, John Campbell, Daniel Merritt ; Benjamin Ragsdale

Probate/Estate

Feb 1794 Daniel Duncan – Mrs. Mary Duncan, admin estate of Daniel Duncan

"Caswell Co. NC Will Books 1777-1814, Guardian Accounts 1794-1819, Tax Lists 1784" Vol.1, by Kendall (extracts from Louis Boone 8/15/82 & 10/21/82; TN Gen. Society Lib. #3955, extracts from Evelyn Sigler 2/1/83; FHC book 975.6575 P28k v.1, SLC 2/27/93)

Will Book A, pg.182: Inv. estate of Danl. Duncan by Mary Duncan, admin. Court Dec. 1781. (pg.8)

Will Book B, pg.180: Sales of estate of Danl. Duncan on 30 Jan. 1787. Buyers: Mary Duncan, Jesse Duncan, Nathl. Duncan, Will Rainey, Reuben Newton, Archd. Murphey, John Campbell, Daniel Merritt. By Mary Duncan, adm. Court April 1787. (pg.21)

Will Book C, pg.44: Feb. 1784, Recd. of Mrs. Mary Duncan, adm. of Daniel Duncan £50 in full of legacy of said estate. /s/ Danl. Merritt for Nancy Duncan. C-44, Recd. of Mrs. Mary Duncan for legacy from Danl. Duncan. /s/ Nathl. Duncan. C-45, Frances Duncan to Mary Duncan, guardian acct. C-45, Recd. of Mrs. Mary Duncan adm. of Danl. Duncan decd. for wife Frances' legacy. /s/ Champess Madding; wit. Elizabeth Duncan. C-45, Mary Duncan (the younger) acct. with Mary Duncan (the Elder). C-46, Rec. of Mrs. Mary Duncan wife Mary's legacy from estate of Daniel Duncan. /s/ Benjamin Ragsdale. C-46, Patience Wilkerson in acct. with Mary Duncan, adm. Court July 1793. (pg.43)

^[6]

Will of Mary (Person NC)

(Mary was evidently the widow of Daniel Duncan, proved by the names of her daughters, two sons Abner and Martin were not named in the receipts filed in Daniel's estate.

Six children (Nathaniel as son but not one of 6) Sons Abner, Martin, Elizabeth, Sally Stanton, Nancy Merritt, Francis Madden, Polly Ragsdale Polly Merritt (granddau) Person Co NC Person Co. NC Wills, Inventories, tax lists, etc.; Book 1792-1797 (FHC film 19,591, SLC 8/27/82) (Person Co. NC was formed in 1791 from Caswell Co. NC)

• Pg.268: 24 March 1796, Mary Duncan of Person Co. NC, sick and weak, son Abner Duncan 1/2 land whereon I now live on the east side to be divided from the other half 109a, horse, etc.; son Martin the other half, including house, 109 acres, etc.; dau. Elizabeth Duncan, slave, etc.; son Nathaniel Duncan 5 shillings and no more; Polly Merritt my granddaughter small walnut chest; rest sold and divided between my "six" children namely Sally Stanton, Nancy Merritt, Francis Madden, Elizabeth Duncan, Polly Ragsdale, Abner Duncan and Martin Duncan. Appoint friends William Trotter and John Campbell exec. /s/ Mary (+) Duncan. Wit. H. Harrisson, Robt. Moore, Nancy Stanton. Recorded 7 Sept. 1796.

David Duncan

son of David and Elizabeth Duncan of Surry County, Virginia, and is mentioned in his father's will.

Birth Estimate 1721

Marriage

Marriage estimate 1737-1741 Surry County, Virginia

• Mary (Capeheart) (Anderson) (Parents Unknwn)^[7]
• Elizabeth (Patterson)

Death

Death Estimate proved 17 July, 1744 vs Mar 1781

"Wills and Administrations of Surry Co. VA, 1671-1750" by Davis (FHC book 975.562 S2d; SLC 8/24/82) p.55 proved 17 July, 1744

Will

DUNCAN, David; Leg. - Wife, Elizabeth Duncan, household good, horses, etc. To son, Nathaniel, all my slaves. Son, David Duncan, one negro. Son, John, two negroes, bed, etc. Son, Peter, 2 negroes, son, Daniel, 2 negroes, son Nathaniel, the land and plantation where I live, household good, etc. Daughter, Jennett. Dated (no month or day) 1744; proved 17 July, 1744. Wit. Hugh Ivey, John Hays.^[8]

Children

• Henry Abner Duncan m Sarah (Beard)
• Martin C. Duncan m Mary Polly Ray and Mary Elizabeth Polly (Ray)

Timeline

• Fact: Also Known As Daniel Duncan
• Fact: Residence (1777) St. Laurence District, Caswell County, NC
• Fact: RESIDENCE (1777) St. Laurence District, Caswell County, NC
• Fact: Military Service (1780) Revolutionary War veteran Virginia, United States
• Fact: Probate (1781) Caswell, North Carolina, United States
• Fact: Residence VA, United States
• Fact: RESIDENCE VA, United States
• Fact: Military Service US Revolutionary War
• Fact: Burial Duncan Family, Williamson, Illinois
  

  Daniel Duncan performed Patriotic Service in the American Revolution.

Daniel was born in 1721. He was a lieutenant in the Revolutionary War, and also fought in the War of 1812.^[9][10]

He was granted land in Caswell County, North Carolina,1844.^[11] He is recorded in the marriage record of his son Jesse, 1780.^[12] He passed away in 1781.^[13]

Will of David Duncan, 1744

Will of David Duncan (Daniel's father) - Recorded and proved 17 July 1744 in Surry Co., Virginia

DUNCAN, David; Leg. - Wife, Elizabeth Duncan, household good, horses, etc.

To son, Nathaniel, all my slaves.

Son, David Duncan, one negro.

Son, John, two negroes, bed, etc.

Son, Peter, 2 negroes,

son, Daniel, 2 negroes,

son Nathaniel, the land and plantation where I live, household good, etc.

Daughter, Jennett. Dated (no month or day) 1744; proved 17 July, 1744. Wit. Hugh Ivey, John Hays.^[14]

Sources

1. ↑ "North Carolina, County Marriages, 1762-1979 ," database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:F8PW-1JR : 3 November 2017), Benjamin Ragsdale and Mary Duncan, 1792; citing , Caswell, North Carolina, United States, p. Item 1, Office of Archives and History, Division of Archives and Records. State Archive of North Carolina and various county Register of Deeds; FHL microfilm 478,484.
2. ↑ "North Carolina, County Marriages, 1762-1979 ," database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:F8PW-XYN : 3 November 2017), Champness Maddin and Francis Duncan, 17 Jan 1792; Caswell, North Carolina, United States, p. Item 1, Office of Archives and History, Division of Archives and Records. State Archive of North Carolina and various county Register of Deeds; FHL microfilm 478,484.
3. ↑ "North Carolina, County Marriages, 1762-1979 ," database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:QPS9-ZKP8 : 10 March 2021), Danl Duncan in entry for Jesse Duncan and Hannah Paschell, 14 Jul 1780; citing Caswell, North Carolina, United States, p. , North Carolina State Archives Division of Archives and History; FHL microfilm
4. ↑ : Martin Duncan sold his land in 1802, Person Co. NC Deed Book C, pg.329. (It is probable that son Martin moved to Mercer Co. KY and named a son Champness Madden Duncan.)
5. ↑ Was Alexander Stinson's wife Sally's maiden name Duncan or Anderson?

   (1) Alexander's will (Caswell Co. NC Will Book A, p. 182, March 1782) names wife Sarah, daughter Nancy, father John, and grandfather Childress.

   (2) Mary Duncan's will (Person Co. NC Will Book 1, p. 268, Sep 1796) names daughter Sally Staneton and is signed by Nancy Stinson.In the list of Mary's children, Sally is first, perhaps indicating that she was oldest child. Also Nancey Stenson married John Morgan on 27 Sep 1796 in Caswell County.

   (3) Joseph Merritt, a descendant of Daniel and Mary Duncan, wrote in a family sketch in the 1890's, that Mary Duncan, nee Capehart, was widow Anderson when she married Daniel Duncan.); When Daniel's estate was divided, there was no mention of a daughter Sally.

6. ↑ Digital Copy Caswell County, North Carolina, Will Books, 1777-1814 ; 1784 Tax List, Guardians' Accounts, 1794-1819, Books 1777-1880; Katharine Kerr Kendall, Mary Frances Kerr Donaldson; Genealogical Publishing Com, 1979 - 428 pages - Ref #44-46
7. ↑ "United States Census, 1790", database with images, FamilySearch (ark:/61903/1:1:VJ1N-6HW : Fri May 19 17:02:15 UTC 2023), Entry for Mary Duncan, 1790.
8. ↑ Where The Record Is Found (Citation) "North Carolina Estate Files, 1663-1979," database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:V121-43V : 8 March 2021), Daniel Duncan, 1781; citing Caswell, North Carolina, United States, State Archives, Raleigh; FHL microfilm 1,711,174.
9. ↑ "United States Rosters of Revolutionary War Soldiers and Sailors, 1775-1783", , FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:QG2M-KQ64 : Wed Oct 04 13:39:55 UTC 2023), Entry for Daniel Duncan, 5 October 1777.
10. ↑ DAR Ancestor #: A205618
11. ↑ Kendall, Katharine Kerr. Caswell County, North Carolina: land grants, tax lists, state census, apprentice bonds, estate records. (Raleigh, North Carolina: Multiple Image Press, 1977), pg. 28. Published Online by FamilySearch International at www.familysearch.org/library/books/idviewer/490729/36
12. ↑ "North Carolina, County Marriages, 1762-1979 ", , FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:QPSM-2WNK : Wed Oct 18 07:32:34 UTC 2023), Entry for Jesse Duncan and Danl Duncan, 14 Jul 1780.
13. ↑ "North Carolina Estate Files, 1663-1979", , FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:V121-43V : Fri Nov 10 14:16:03 UTC 2023), Entry for Daniel Duncan, 1781.
14. ↑ 17 July 1744 "Wills and Administrations of Surry Co. VA, 1671-1750" by Davis (FHC book 975.562 S2d; SLC 8/24/82) pg. 55

• https://services.dar.org/public/dar_research/search_adb/default.cfm
• State Archives of North Carolina Store
• FHC North Carolina Online Genealogy Records
• Caswell County, North Carolina, Marriage Bonds, 1778-1868; Kendall, Katharine Kerr; pgs 20; 27; 102; 104; 119
• Extensive Research by David Sengel Posted: 21 Dec 2004
• "Family Tree," database, FamilySearch (http://familysearch.org : modified 02 June 2020, 11:28), entry for Daniel Anderson Duncan(PID https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/4:1:LZG2-2DY); contributed by various users.
• (sourced) [ https://www.familysearch.org/tree/person/details/LZG2-2DY Daniel Duncan (1721–1781) LZG2-2DY m Mary Capehart Anderson (1736–1796)

DNA

• Paternal and Maternal relationships are both confident based on a triangulated group on MyHeritageDNA who share a 11 cM segment on chromosome 3, consisting of Richard Douglas and Steven Bumgardner, his 4th cousin 1x removed, and Stacey Shoulders, his 7th cousin 1x removed. (Steven and Stacey are 6th cousins 2x removed.) These matches have been independently verified by via the MyHeritage Chromosome Browser. Their most-recent common ancestors are David Duncan and Elizabeth Unknown, the 6x great grandparents of Richard Douglas and 5x great grandparents of Steven Bumgardner and 7x great grandparents of Stacey Shoulders.

• Paternal and Maternal relationships are both confident based on a triangulated group on MyHeritageDNA who share a 11 cM segment on chromosome 3, consisting of Kevin Alfultis and Richard Douglas, his 7th cousin 1x removed, and Stacey Shoulders, his 6th cousin. (Richard and Stacey are 7th cousins 1x removed.) These matches have been independently verified by via the MyHeritage Chromosome Browser. Their most-recent common ancestors are David Duncan and Elizabeth Unknown, the 7x great grandparents of Kevin Alfultis and 6x great grandparents of Richard Douglas and 7x great grandparents of Stacey Shoulders.

Acknowledgments

Duncan-4183 was created by Karen Fleming through the import of IshmaelGibson_2014_0325.ged on Mar 25, 2014.