Database Errors: Upon saving on 21 May 2018, the following automated message was received:
Warning: Check the data.
A father's death date (Edwards-1874 died 1660) should not be more than nine months before one of his children's birth dates (Edwards-8770 born 1690).
A parent (Edwards-1874 born 1610) should not have been born more than 170 years before one of their children died (Edwards-8770 died 2 Nov 1781). This would mean that even if the parent gave birth at 70, the child lived to be over 100.
A parent's death date (Edwards-1874 died 1660) should not be more than 120 years before one of their children died (Edwards-8770 died 2 Nov 1781). This would mean the child lived to be over 120.
Discrepancy
family appears to originate from Hopton Castle Registers
Parent Discrepancy - Joshua may be Fictitious or unrecorded birth - same birth as Josia (listed as dau of Richard)
Likely a son (b. 1604-1615) of William or Richard vs Joshua
There is a great deal of conflicting information – Several Source-to-Source discrepancies; co-mingling, Lack of records; conflicting family stories; number of same names, No Middle Names Verified, etc. There were several Same Named Edwards' within the same timeframe (and various locations in close proximity). -- Accounts appear to be fictionalized insofar as "Joshua's Line" This genealogy seems to be inaccurate and appears to have originated with
(a) the famed Edward Heirs Lawsuit;
(b) an erroneous IGI / and
(c) Suspect Peerage entries as well as a series of books published thereafter (restating the same ancestors).
(d) Much of the Early Edwards line captured appears to be "Tree Copy to Tree Copy"; "Unsourced And Undocumented. (and generally conflicts with located record / confirmation.)
↑ [#Peerage] Gives birth date as 1610, no birth place and does not give mother, these items are all unsourced. Peerage reference is suspect - (Joshua may be Fictitious or a transcription error - See Hopton Castle Registers)
Sources 198 -Author Bruce Montgomery Edwards; The Edwards of Northhampton; Montgomery Publishing Company, 1973; Original from the University of Wisconsin - Madison Digitized Sep 7, 2007; 293 pages
Source 199 - David Dean Edwards; The Edwardes legacy; Gateway Press, 1992; Original from the University of Wisconsin – Madison Digitized Sep 6, 2007; 231 pages
Is William your ancestor? Please don't go away! Login to collaborate or comment, or
contact
a profile manager, or ask our community of genealogists a question.
Edwards-5172 and Edwards-1874 appear to represent the same person because: all appear to be intended to represent the same individual with varying information. In order to prove/disprove, profiles need to be consolidated to determine most accurate information. Several source-to-source discrepancies, co-mingled and name variations Profile cleanup to be done after merges are complete. Please do not reject merges - Please resolve obvious discrepancies and provide source; Note under Discrepancies for inclusion to Final Info. Thank you for your assistance in maintaining 1 profile per person.
Proposed Merges
Edwards-1874 Lowest ID (See Notes) (son of Joshua) m. Jonet Reese-2383
Edwards-7380 - No Source; No Parents; No Marriage; No Descendants (Not b. James City)
Please confirm any information separately from online trees, (this goes for any ancestor, but especially for the Edwards family from Glamorgan, Wales). It seem these trees may originate with a fictitious IGI user submission. See: http://boards.rootsweb.com/surnames.edwards/10292.1/mb.ashx
Edwards-1874 and Edwards-4095 appear to represent the same person because: Edwards-4095 is an 'isolated profile' -- no relationships. If more information is available, please add it to the profile. If no further information is available then because we cannot delete profiles, merging his into a profile with a similar name will be best. Please approve this merge in support of ridding Wikitree of these isolated profiles. Thank you."
Proposed Merges Edwards-1874 Lowest ID (See Notes) (son of Joshua) m. Jonet Reese-2383
Edwards-8771 (m. Jonat Reese-1683 (dup) Edwards-5172 (son of Joshua) (Cardiff s/b Wales)
(Additional Notes at Robert Edwards-859 & William Edwards-3764)