no image
Privacy Level: Open (White)

Alexander Erskine (abt. 1504 - 1580)

Alexander Erskine aka Erskine of Shielfield
Born about in Dryburgh, Berwickshire, Scotlandmap
Ancestors ancestors
Husband of — married 1559 in Stirling, Stirlingshire, Scotlandmap
Descendants descendants
Died [location unknown]
Profile last modified | Created 7 Aug 2011
This page has been accessed 2,306 times.


Contents

Biography

Alexander Erskine is a member of Clan Erskine.
Alexander Erskine of Shielfield was born about 1504. While it is not disputed that he is a descendant of Robert, 4th Lord Erskine, whether he is son or grandson has been the matter of discussion among Scottish genealogists. In Erskine-Halcro Scott maintains the Alexander was the son of James Erskine of Little Sauchie and 1st Lord of Balgownie making him the grandson of Robert.[1] Though this was published in 1895 and Scott acknowledges the contributions of Hallen, he does not address the apparent discrepancies in dates that would place Alexander's birth before that of Christian Stirling if James and Christian were his parents.[2]


Sources

References

  • Scott, Ebenezer Erskine, 1895, The Erskine-Halcro Genealogy, 2nd Edition Edinburgh, George P. Johnson, publisher
  • Hallen, Rev. A. W. Cornelius. 1890, Erskine of Little Sauchie and of Balgownie, The Scottish Antiquary or Northern Notes and Queries, Vol 5 No. 19, December 1890


Acknowledgements

  • WikiTree profile Erskine-463 created through the import of O'Bryan Family tree.ged on Sep 6, 2011 by Tim Tropeck.

Footnotes

  1. "In the first edition, published in 1890, I had been induced to suggest that Alexander Erskine, parson of Monybreck, whose name is entered by Sir Robert Douglas in his Peerage as that of a brother of the fourth Lord Erskine, had been in reality the first laird of Shielfield. I am now satisfied that my suggestion was in error, and that the Alexander Erskine who married the heiress of Shielfield was in reality of the next generation, and a nephew instead of a brother of the said Lord."
  2. “Mr. E. Erskine Scott, in his recently published account of the Erskines of Shieldfield (sic), has introduced the name of Alexander, the first Laird of Shielfield, into a tabular pedigree (I.) of the Balgownie family, and places him as youngest son of James, the first Laird. For this Mr. Scott produces no contemporaneous evidence, but relies solely on a passage to be found in a manuscript in the possession of, and printed by, Sir Walter Scott in 1824. This work was an anonymous account of the family of Haliburton, and was commenced in the latter half of the seventeenth century. It contains a story of an abduction of the heiress of Shielfield by her grandfather, Abbot James Stewart, in 1559, and of her marriage by him to Alexander Erskine, ‘a brother, as 'tis said, of Balgony, at that time a servant of the said Abbot.’ (The italics are mine; the whole passage will be found on page 31 of the reprint of the work for the Grampian Club.) The utter worthlessness of this myth can be judged from the fact that this Abbot James Stewart ceased to be Abbot in 1541; if he did not die in that year he certainly was dead before 18th February 1546 (see p. 237, L.D.). If Mr. Scott can find any reliable authority designating Alexander of Shielfield ‘brother to Balgonie,’ then he may reasonably conjecture that he was Alexander Erskine, Parson of Monybreck, but probably a layman, younger son of Robert, Lord Erskine, and brother to James, Laird of Balgownie. He is mentioned by Douglas in his account of the family of Erskine (E. Mar). Mr. Scott holds that this Alexander was a son and not a brother to James of Balgownie. This is impossible; he was of full age in 1525 (R.M.C.), and therefore must have been older than Christian Stirling, the mother of the Laird of Balgownie’s children. In 1559 he was probably about 55 years of age. Mr. Scott seems to have overlooked the fact that there existed, 31st March 1541, an Alexander Erskine of full age, and witness for the Abbot of Dryburgh (R.M.S.); he could not have been the son of James of Balgownie, he may have been his brother, and eventually the husband of Elizabeth Haliburton. Douglas’s account of the origin of the house of Shielfield is improbable. when dates now ascertained are considered. (See Scot. Antiq. p. 143.)”




More Genealogy Tools



Sponsored Search




Is Alexander your ancestor? Please don't go away!
 star icon Login to collaborate or comment, or
 star icon contact private message the profile manager, or
 star icon ask our community of genealogists a question.
Sponsored Search by Ancestry.com

DNA
No known carriers of Alexander's DNA have taken a DNA test.

Have you taken a DNA test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.

Sponsored by Ancestry ®

Family History Search.

Simplified.

Enter a grandparent's name. Just one grandparent can lead you to many discoveries.

Comments

Leave a message for others who see this profile.
There are no comments yet.
Login to post a comment.

Rejected matches › Alexander Erskine (1759-)

E  >  Erskine  >  Alexander Erskine

Categories: Clan Erskine