Contents |
Gilbert E. L. Falls, born 1835 in North Carolina, is probably the teenager with parents Gilbert and Bathsheba Falls in 1850 Polk County, Tennessee. [1] Because his father was also named Gilbert, G.E.L. will refer to the man at this entry. His parents can be traced as above to Polk County, Tennessee, and further back 1840 Gilmer County, Georgia, where where G.E.L. was married in 1853, and further back to North Carolina census.
Although his medical qualifications are in question, most records refer to him as "Dr." or as "G.E.L.", which helps separate him from references to his father Gilbert, who eventually settled in the same county of Fannin in Georgia as his son.
Gilbert Falls married Miss (Ruth) Elendar Hickey 3 July 1853 in Gilmer County, Georgia. [2]
An article below under "Barker Papers" reports a wife named Elizabeth Tilley Hickey, from an unknown source, so whether G.E.L. Falls married sisters, or this name was simply made up, is unclear, but it should not be totally ignored in light of an article below from 1883 indicating three wives for him.
Land records show that Eleandor could not sign her name. [3]
G.E.L. Falls was a local "doctor" in Blue Ridge, Georgia, but it is unclear that he was trained in either homeopathic or allopathic medicine. A descendant displayed to Clinton Slayon his certificate from Macon Medical College, presumably in Georgia. In any case, the county licensed him to practice as physician and surgeon and druggist. [4] As a licensed druggist [5] [6] and country physician, [7] [8] he mainly delivered babies.
He was an all-in-one professional man in the area and acted as a "scribe" for the many of the illiterate who applied for pension relief. Documents state that his fees were steep and he was criticized at the time for them. He was also coroner[9] and county clerk.[10]
He had numerous real estate dealings in Georgia, one being the Falls Addition to the city of Blue Ridge in Fannin County. Many are notably to family members, including to his final wife, Alice, probably as a protective measure. Many of his land transactions feature surnames of marital connections: Weaver, Green, Hickey. Note: there are almost five pages of deeds for Gilbert E L Falls in the Fannin County Court House, this citation excerpts a few. [11]
A newspaper notice, seen below, suggests that he married three times, but his family bible mentions only Ruth and Alice. This suggests that he might have married between 1880 and 1900, when Ruthelander and Alice appear respectively in census. A family story mentions a child of his borne by Mary Orton "without benefit of marriage." (See Research Notes)
He married Alice Victoria Green in 1882, when he was aged about 46 and she was aged about 17. [12] [13]
He is probably the "Dr Gilbert...of Morganton" mentioned as visiting San Antonio, Texas, in January 1888. [14] Among his real estate dealings is a 1900 land purchase for land in Fannin from George W. Green of Goliad, Texas, about 90 miles from San Antonio, possibly a relative of his wife.
He died in 1908 and is buried in Blue Ridge, Fannin, Georgia. [15]
A letter dated January 18, 1863 from Gilbert E. Falls to Gov. Joseph E. Brown is transcribed, in which Falls pled for the exemption of teachers from conscription by the Confederacy. Pointing out that the teachers were constrained from teaching for more than a few months because of the poverty of the mountain counties and the demands of farming, the retention of teachers would “to promote each child far enough in education to enable them to read the words of divine Truth.” [citation needed] It is not clear if this writer was the man at this profile, or his father Gilbert.
Shows "Family Record of Gilbert E.L. Falls transcribed from
orginal record": [13]
BIRTHS:
Gilbert Elbethel Lafayette Falls born December 16th 1835
Ruth Elender McCan Hickey was born July 30, 1833.
Gilbert Decalb Falls was born June 12th 1854
Margaret Arminda Falls was born September 2nd 1856
Martin Columbus Falls was born June 26th 1859
Evy(?) Elender Bathsheba Jane Falls was born April 30th 1861
Benjamin Elbethel Falls was born September 7th 1863
MARRIAGES:
Gilbert E.L. Falls was married to Ruth Elinder McCan Hickey July 3rd 1853 by Rev Martin Tree in Gilmer Co. Ga
Gilbert E.L. Falls was married to Alis Victory Green December 17 1882 by Rev Joseph Kincaid in Fannin Co. GA.
Alice V. Green was born March 24 1866 & married as above stated
Alice Falls was married to Mr. W. H. Travis May 15 1911.
Harry Hatfield born Nov. 19, 1890 was married to Annie Falls Dec 19--
Guy Donagan Born Aug 29 1892 were married to Texas Falls Apr. 7, 1912. (see Guy Eugene Dunagan)
OVERLEAF:
Gilbert Falls father of [illegible] G & (?) Elizabeth was borned June 9, 1794 and died July 14, 1880 Living 86 years 1 month 5 days old
Mary Juanita Donagan Borned Jan 23 1916 (see Mary Etta Juanita Dunagan))
Lillian Falls Borned Apr(?) 13, 1916
Katherine Donagan borned (see Katherine (Dunagan) Slayton}
WIllard Falls borned
[All overleaf notes might have been entered by Texicanah (Falls) McCulley, Patterson (1897-1972), but this is conjecture, as this consistently misspells Dunagan, her married name. Entry for Gilbert might have shown abbreviations of one or two children plus Elizabeth, but that is not clear]
The Falls given names have been a devilment to census takers, such as Ithil D Falls, 1860, [16] whose name sounds a lot like the Elbethel ascribed to the Gilbert E. Falls at this profile. [17]
Stories that G.E.L. Falls enriched himself with land and money in trade for medical and legal services, such as preparing pension applications for soldiers and widows, are difficult to verify, but came down to descendants and is reported in an article below: he might have exacted half of the first pension check of each soldier, widow or dependent. His name appears on many pension applications verifying that he authored them, and he made inquiries to such papers as the National Tribune, the organ of the Grand Army of the Republic, seeking details of Civil War campaigns.
Among several guardianships, he received estate funds for guardianship of Sarah (Tipton) Garland: [abstract] G E L Falls was appointed guardian of Sarah C. Tipton {minor child of Charles Tipton} and received 90.00 from her former guardian Thomas J.Bevins; Falls refused to give money to her husband John W. Garland, and Garland is sueing. The minor said she wanted the money made to her in installments at her direction, court said Falls didn't have to pay ... Oct. court 1880, page 426, petition dated 7 Aug. 1880, Gilbert EL Falls guardian of Sarah C. Tipton showeth he has fully executed guardianship of his ward and wants letters of dismissal. [18] [19]
It is not verified, but quite likely, that he delivered Alice Victoria Green, whom he was later to marry. [13] [20]
It is quite likely that he delivered Arkansas "Kansas" Falls, allegedly out of wedlock in 1882, by a Mary Orton "in between" marriages. G.E.L. Falls cannot be proven to be her father, but she carried the name Falls until her 1899 marriage to Jeff Davis Stratton in Georgia, [21], they divorced, and she is buried with married name Milsap.[22]
Marriage Problem -
One of the "two divorced wives" mentioned below cannot be found in Fannin County records (so far). But an article below names a wife as "Elizabeth Tilley Hickey."
Atlanta Constitution, Friday,13 April, 1883 - "A many -wived husband - Chattanooga, April 12 -- Dr. Gilbert E.L. Falls, late clerk of Fannin county, GA., passed through the city to-day with thirteen emigrants. In the party were two of his divorced wives, and his present wife, a beautiful girl of seventeen."
Military problem -
Shortly before his death his pension application was rejected for his claim that he was a Union scout and spy. [23] Confusingly, Confederate Service Card Index shows this distinctive name as a Sergeant in CSA units (?).[24]
During the Civil War he signed up for the Fannin County Rifles (CSA} but records say he failed to report.[25] He might have been a Union sympathizer: "You are probably already aware of this but just in case......Dr. Falls was a very strong Union supporter during the Civil War, so much in fact that a detachment of troops were assigned to protect him for a short while during the occupation. I have run across his name a number of times where he was helping widows applying for U. S. pensions. Also there were 3 Union soldiers/partisans? executed by a firing squad in Lumpkin Co. and he helped the widow of one try to bring the members to trial after the war." [26]
See the "Barker Papers" below.
Census :
1860 Fannin County, Georgia census, page 1091, Stock Hill [27]
Gilbert E. Falls 24 NC school teacher,
Ellendor 24 NC,
Margaret 4 GA,
Martin 2 GA.
1870 Fannin County, Georgia census, page 397, Morgantown } [28]
Gilbert Falls 34 GA,
Ruth 37 NC,
Margaret 13 Tenn,
Martin 11 Tenn,
James 4 GA,
Ulysses 1 GA.
{next door to father, Gilbert Falls}
1880 Fannin County, Georgia census, ED 59, page 27, Morgantown [29]
Gilbert Falls 42 NC physician,
Ruth Elendor 43 NC,
Columbus 20 Tenn,
James W. 13 GA,
Augustus U. 11 GA,
Truman W. 8 GA.
1900 Fannin County, Georgia census, page 332, ED 28, sheet 15, Blue Ridge[30]
Gilbert E.L. Falls 64 GA, Dec 1835 physician,
Alice 33 GA, Nov 1855 wife, (married 18 years, 5 children, 4 living},
George E. 15 GA, July 1884 son
John H. 12 GA, Aug 1874 son
Anbell 5 GA, Aug 1894 dau
Texicanah 3 GA, Jan 1897 dau
Additional Issue:
Census suggests these children, in addition to "Kansas" mentioned above and those in the bible record:
James William or Willard Falls - b 1866
Agustus Ulysses Falls - b 1868
Thomas Whitney Falls - b abt 1871
George Emory Falls - b 1884
John "Harry' Falls - b 1888
Annie Belle Falls - b 1894 (mar Hatfield)
Texicanah Falls - b 1897 (married Dunagan, Patterson)
Juanita Falls - b 1901 (married Mackey)
The spread of his family is attested by the number of 1930 and 1940 censuses for Falls in Fannin County. Both G.E.L. Falls and his father apparently married women as their third wives who were about half their age.
The following opinionated posting calls into question the character of G.E.L. Falls, suggesting that he hedged his bets by claiming to serve both sides during the war, and connived to make money from preparing fraudulent pension applications for himself and others. It also calls into question his qualifications as a medical doctor. It also introduces a previously unfound name for a wife as Elizabeth Tilley Hickey, when he is known to have married "Ruth Eleandor McCan Hickey" in 1853. The article mentions Gilbert Falls the father and "Dr". Gilbert the son in census, but is in error in naming Dr. Falls' wife as "Ruthelman" where it is a combination of given names as "Ruthelendor."
G.E.L. Falls appears in many of the personal articles at this site, because, fraudulent or not, he filed claims for many of the soldiers or their widows and dependents mentioned in these papers. He cannot defend himself now against these attacks on his character, but his reputation as a sharp dealer was implied by his granddaughter Katherine (Dunagan) Slayton and her sister Mary Etta Juanita Dunagan Johnson)
from "Civil War Research From the Robert B. Barker Papers" [31]
The following collection was gleened [sic] from the microfilmed accounts of Robert B. Barker, a lawyer and avid Civil War historian whose special interest was the Western North Carolina and East Tennessee area. Barker donated his fourteen volumes and a section of loose papers to the McClung Historical Collection in Knoxville, Tennessee in 1972 which they microfilmed in order to make it available to area researchers and also to preserve the now fragile material. Mr. Barker passed away in December 1980 at his home in Andrews, North Carolina.
The collection contains information on both Union and Confederate soldiers who have a Polk County connection and we share some of it here. This transcription from roll #1, Union Army Volunteers, was by PCHGS president, Marian Bailey Presswood who apologizes for any errors.
We do advise caution when reading these entries, as there were at least three men and possibly more, who committed fraud in applying for some pensions. Names of soldiers, wives, and other information was sometimes completely fabricated. In the Boyd Fraud three men were indicted for filing fraudulent claims and one, Thomas G. Boyd, was sentenced to do time in the penitentiary - the other two were deceased by that time. At least 20 men were charged with conspiracy to defraud the United States Government in the Goldman Bryson Fraud where the perpetrators obtained a stack of application claim forms and filled them out themselves, the 'claimants' never even saw 'their' applications. As far as we know, the information presented here is accurate and as stated since almost all were reviewed by an investigator and their findings reported. However, if you have and doubts about the information on your family it would be best to check other sources if at all possible.
Note: These files may be ordered from the NARA using the file numbers. SC=Soldiers Claim; WC=Widows Claim
Falls, Gilbert E. L., scout and spy, Union Army Volunteers, 1864-1865. Falls filed claim July 8, 1908 saying that he was employed by Lt. Col. Martin B. Ewing, 2nd Ohio Heavy Artillery, Union Army at Charleston, TN from 1864 to the close of the war and that as a part of is services he captured Capt. Lu Harris, a notorious bushwhacker and in addition he captured 65 head of fat hogs, weighing about 200 lbs. each and turn both hogs and bushwhacker over to Lt. Col. Martin. The Army said that they were unable to find any record of service of Gilbert E. L. Falls in the Union Army and rejected the claim for pension. As shown by the records in many pension cases of Union Army volunteers, Falls was very active in the prosecution of claims while at Morganton, Georgia and later at Blue Ridge when the county seat was moved. 'Dr.' Falls served one term as Clerk of the Superior Court of Fannin County from 1874 to 1880. He was very active in the John Lafayette Hickey case on behalf of the legal widow, Elizabeth Tilley Hickey, and made a trip by horseback to Sweetwater to see Thomas G. Boyd, pension and claim agent, in 1871. Falls' numerous letters to the Auditor of the Treasurer and the Adjutant General of the Army set off the powder which blew up the 'Boyd Frauds' and resulted in Boyd going to the penitentiary for five years. Falls testified in U. S. Circuit Court that he was a member of Capt. Goldman Bryson's Company, which was immediately disputed by A. T. Payne, Lt. of Bryson's Company who took the stand and said that Falls was never in Bryson's Company. Benjamin Brannon also testified to the same. Falls' testimony of Union service was a bit incredible since he had two periods of service in the Confederate Army, apparently deserting from both enlistments. He enlisted as a volunteer on March 4, 1862 at Morganton, in Co. H, 52nd GA Inf. for three years. He enlisted Feb. 9, 1863 in Lumpkin Co., GA in Co. E. 25th Battalion, GA Inf. for 3 years. Falls was promoted to 4th Sgt. of Co. and Muster rolls for Feb 28, 1863 show Gilbert E. L. Falls present for duty. In a special sworn statement taken by A. B. Parkey, in the pension claim of former Union army officer, Lt. Nathan B. Long, Gilbert E. L. Falls admitted that he was in the Confederate Army with Long. L. B. Crawford, Morganton merchant and Postmaster also testified that he was in the Confederate Army with both Gilbert E. L. Falls and Lt. Nathan B. Long. Gilbert E. L. Falls was indicted at Atlanta at the March term 1873 charging that he had wrongfully and illegally withheld from Malinda Dover, widow of Michael Dover, one hundred and twenty dollars of pension money received by said Falls as local agent for Malinda Dover. An arrest warrant was issued for Falls on April 14, 1973 [sic - 1873] with bond of one thousand dollars which was posted by Falls. The case dragged on so long that it seems to have been worn out on the Docket and some five years after the original indictment was returned his attorney, L. J. Gartrell obtained a nol pros and on March 27, 1878, the case was dismissed. Malinda Dover had died by that time. Falls was also investigated for many other pension frauds, and was disbarred from practice before the Pensions Office, but he went right on collecting fees from the pensioners direct - he took one half of their first check! Special Agents in their reports of investigation seem to have regarded 'Dr.' Falls as a quack who, without medical training or license, took up the practice of medicine. Several of the agents said that his reputation was not good. Gilbert Falls, age 45 was on the 1850 Polk County, TN census with wife, Bathsheba, age 43, and sons, Gilbert, age 15 and Silas, 9. Gilbert, age 42 a physician, and wife Ruthelman [Ruthelander], age 43, are on the 1880 Fannin County, GA census with children, Columbus, 20, James W., 13, Augustine M., 11, and Thomas W., 8. (S. O. 1375492)
Stories and records from Judy Jones Davis of Calera, Alabama (a major source of research and images) and the late Mary Dunagan Johnson and Katherine Lucille Slayton (sisters) , passed on to grandson of "Texie" Falls Clinton Slayton. Also, Lindsay Fiedorowicz for dogged diligence in the research of Arkansas "Kansas" Falls and Lynne Tipton for Sarah Tipton Garland and numerous references.
Have you taken a DNA test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.
Featured National Park champion connections: Gilbert is 16 degrees from Theodore Roosevelt, 23 degrees from Stephanus Johannes Paulus Kruger, 19 degrees from George Catlin, 15 degrees from Marjory Douglas, 24 degrees from Sueko Embrey, 18 degrees from George Grinnell, 28 degrees from Anton Kröller, 19 degrees from Stephen Mather, 24 degrees from Kara McKean, 17 degrees from John Muir, 20 degrees from Victoria Hanover and 22 degrees from Charles Young on our single family tree. Login to find your connection.
F > Falls > Gilbert Elbethel Lafayette Falls
Categories: Harmony Baptist Cemetery, Blue Ridge, Georgia