Joseph Lillard (abt. 1647)

Born about 1647 in , , France

Problems/Questions Profile manager: Steve Turley [send private message]

Research Notes

Traditions on Lillard Family Origins

In 1928, Ephraim Stout Lillard published a book called “Lillard: A Family of Colonial Virginia.” Though Stout Lillard’s work is something of a watershed in the Revolutionary and post-Revolutionary history of the Lillard family (and he deserves great credit as the “grandfather” of Lillard genealogy), his work suffers from a paucity of authentic sources, especially in the colonial period and earlier. It has been criticized, as David H. Lillard, Jr., author of the second edition has pointed out:

“by professional genealogists on several grounds. . . there is a general paucity of documentation to authoritative sources. . . {and} generally fails to adequately distinguish between statements or conclusions which are based exclusively on family tradition and those based on documented primary sources or authoritative secondary sources.” [1]

In preparing his second edition of the book, David Lillard went to a great deal of effort to examine the records to try to confirm Stout Lillard’s conclusions regarding the relationships of the Colonial Lillards in Culpeper County, Virginia, and the two alternative pedigrees that the original edition discusses. In fact, many subsequent researchers have accepted only one of the two pedigrees – the one regarding the medieval Welsh and French Huguenot ancestry. The other was that the family was English in origins, and begins with a John Lillard who emigrated directly from England to Virginia. Although there are a number of records in England and Scotland of the surname Lillard or Lilliard, there are actually none yet found for the surname in France.[2]

Regarding the Colonial Virginia pedigree, David was unable to find any reference in the extant records of a Benjamin Lillard who married Elizabeth Lightfoot. In my own researches so far, I was unable to find any record of a Benjamin Lillard of the right time period at all. Ephraim Stout Lillard’s conclusions regarding Benjamin and Elizabeth (Lightfoot) Lillard, and their parentage of the Culpeper County Lillards is based solely on various family traditions. In fact, though some sort of familial relationship can be guessed at, there is no primary or authentic secondary source to justify that all of the colonial Culpeper Lillards were even siblings.

David Lillard discusses the extant records of the Lillards in Prince William, Essex, Fairfax, and Orange counties, and is behooves Lillard researchers to read this chapter of his book carefully. It is his conclusion that a John Lillard of Orange County recorded in the 1720s and 1730s is the likeliest candidate for the progenitor of the Culpeper Lillards, but he specifically states that it cannot be proved unless further records are found. It cannot even be proved at this time that all the Culpeper County Lillards were even siblings, which is why David chose to present the family as separate branches, with each branch beginning with a specific Culpeper Lillard ancestor.

This person was created through the import of rsturley20100927.ged on 16 November 2010. The following data was included in the gedcom. You may wish to edit it for readability.

TAG

TAG

Source

Source: #S69

Source: #S623

Page: accessed 27 Apr 2010), http://www.genealogy.com/users/j/a/m/Joan-James-Alton/FILE/0014text.txt

Quality or Certainty of Data: 2

User ID

User ID: 1AFED854A4C89F479591F84506EEE30DDD10

Note

Note: @NI1639@

@NI1639@ NOTEIGI

REFERENCE 1: 0231075, Lillards 1415-1928, Jacques Lillard, p.21 104RST

BIRTH: Ref 1 name of father and family structure only. Place imputed by RST. Birth date of 1647 based on family structure from Ref 1 and estiamted birth date of his brother, Moise Lillard [610] 105RST

Sources

Source S623

Abbreviation: Jasper Lillard Descendants

Title: \i Descendants of Jasper Lillard\i0.

Author: James, Joan

Repository: #R232

Italicized: Y

Paranthetical: Y

Repository R232

Name: Joan James

Address: Joan James

3204 Brown St.

Alton, Illinois 62002 United States

Note: Posted information at www.genealogy.com about Lillard family

Phone Number: (618)463-0180

Source S69

Abbreviation: Ancestral File (TM)

Title: Ancestral File (TM)

Author: The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

Publication: July 1996 (c), data as of 2 January 1996

Repository: #R3

Italicized: Y

Paranthetical: Y

Repository R3

Name: Family History Library

Address: Family History Library

35 North West Temple Street

Room 344

Salt Lake City, UT 84150-3440 USA

Phone Number: 801-240-2584

Phone Number: 866-406-1830