Contents |
6 Feb 1812 Kerry, Killarney, Ireland
6 Feb 1812 Roman Catholic, Killarney, Kerry, Ireland
15 Aug 1884 Ryde, New South Wales
Since October 2018 this profile and that of a duplicate (McGuire-673) have been in either an 'Unmerged Match' or 'Pending Merge' status. They clearly represent the same person - both having supposedly married William Poulton (1804 - abt. 1887) (although there are no sources cited or thus far located to support the marriage details shown).
However, both this and the duplicate profile have different parents. In the absence of any sources to support either it might be best to disassociate both sets once the merge is completed. This Research Note is to ensure that their details are preserved in case they need to be re-associated in the future.
Parents to McGuire-291 are/ were:
Parents to McGuire-673 are/ were:
WikiTree profile McGuire-291 created through the import of export-Forest.ged on Aug 26, 2011 by Frederick Archer.
Thank you to Glenn Smith for creating WikiTree profile McGuire-673 through the import of Appleyard Family Tree.ged on May 2, 2013. Click to the Changes page for the details of edits by Glenn and others.
Have you taken a DNA test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.
Featured National Park champion connections: Bridget is 18 degrees from Theodore Roosevelt, 21 degrees from Stephanus Johannes Paulus Kruger, 20 degrees from George Catlin, 19 degrees from Marjory Douglas, 27 degrees from Sueko Embrey, 15 degrees from George Grinnell, 25 degrees from Anton Kröller, 21 degrees from Stephen Mather, 17 degrees from Kara McKean, 22 degrees from John Muir, 18 degrees from Victoria Hanover and 29 degrees from Charles Young on our single family tree. Login to find your connection.
Different parents, if parents uncertain, suggest disconnecting parents and including them in a Research Notes section in merged profile.
Duplicate found as part of http://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Project:Database_Errors Proposer is a 'Data Doctor' and not related to the Profile/s.
Different parents, if parents uncertain, suggest disconnecting parents and including them in a Research Notes section in merged profile.
Duplicate found as part of http://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Project:Database_Errors Proposer is a 'Data Doctor' and not related to the Profile/s.
While there is an issue with there being different parents, these 2 profiles undoubtedly represent the same woman as the are both associated with the same husband and cite the same death record.
Unfortunately, neither have any cited primary sources in support of her birth or marriage to William Poulton. There are no records on NSW BDM of them ever marrying in NSW.
However, this profile does at least cite some information on Ancestry, which is not necessarily a reliable source.
Do you have any suggestions on how this can all be resolved?
While there is an issue with there being different parents, these 2 profiles undoubtedly represent the same woman as the are both associated with the same husband and cite the same death record.
Unfortunately, neither have any cited primary sources in support of her birth or marriage to William Poulton. There are no records on NSW BDM of them ever marrying in NSW.
However, the other profile does at least reference some information on Ancestry, which is not necessarily a reliable source.
Do you have any suggestions on how this can all be resolved?