||Joseph Profaci is a black sheep because they were outcast, outlawed, or outlandish.|
Join: Black Sheep Project
Giuseppe Profaci is born in Villabate, in Palermo province, on 2 October 1897. He is suspected of already being involved in the Mafia in Sicily, where he served a year in a Palermo prison for theft.
At least two sources indicate Joe Profaci immigrates from Sicily on 4 September 1921. One source names the ship, the SS Providence. Another source indicates he is traveling with future boss Vincent Mangano and Vincent's brother and father. A search on SteveMorse.org for a matching travel date finds the SS Providence departing Palermo on 24 August 1921 and arriving 4 September 1921 in New York. Appearing on the manifest are:
10. Gaetano Mangano, 39 (b. 1882), married, a merchant, leaves his wife Giovanna Giannone behind in Palermo. Destination NY, his brother in law Francesco Giannone, at 25 West Broadway (near World Trade Center site in Tribeca)
11. Vincent Mangano, son, 14 (b. 1907), student Dest NY as above. “Claims US born”. Giovanna Giannone is his mother.
12. Giuseppe Profaci, 24 (b. 1897), single, merchant, leaves his father, Giuseppe behind in Palermo. Dest NY, his cousin Calogero Profaci at 225 Elizabeth St (in lower Manhattan near Little Italy).
Joe settles first in Chicago, and then moves to New York in 1925, where he enters the olive oil import business, earning his nickname, "The Olive Oil King." In Mario Puzo’s books, Vito Corleone forms the "Genco Pura Olive Oil Company" in the 1920s. This detail is lifted right out of Profaci’s life.
Profaci's relationship with Mangano allows him to build relationships with other gang leaders in New York. Besides his legitimate operation in olive oil import, Profaci is also involved in extortion, bootlegging, counterfeiting, prostitution, loan sharking, narcotics trafficking, and gambling.
Joe Profaci, age 29 (b. 1898), petitions to be naturalized in Brooklyn, NY, on 27 September 1927. Declaration of Intention No. 154662, issued in Cook County, 12 March 1924. No children.
The naturalization record for Joe Profaci available online has covered his name on the first page, but it's visible on the second. His immigration information matches the Providence: 4 September 1921. He was born 2 October 1897 in Villabate, Italy. He declared his intention to become a citizen on 12 March 1924 in Chicago. He has lived in the US continuously from his immigration in 1921 until 14 May 1926. Declaration of intention no. 154662 filed 7 June.
There are affidavits from Gerlando Casasa, a baker who lives at 115? Nostrand Av, and Arthur Massolo, an insurance agent who lives at 6219 10th Av, both in Brooklyn. They sign on 7 June 1927.
The second page gives the Certificate of Naturalization No. 2513370, issued 27 September 1927.
Profaci attends the Cleveland Mafia summit in 1928 and is arrested for bootlegging.
In the 1930 federal census of Brooklyn, ED 24-1472, taken 17 April, Joseph Profaci, age 32 (b. 1898), heads a household with his wife, Ninfa, 26 (b. 1904). They married two years previously. They own their home, which is worth $14,000. Joseph immigrated in 1921, and Ninfa in 1918. Both are naturalized citizens. He is a sales manager for a spaghetti manufacturer. ED-1472, AD 16, is bounded by Bay 8th, Cropsey Ave, 16th Ave, and Gravesend Bay in Brooklyn.
Joe and Nina have six children, according to Wikipedia, including two sons: John Jr, and Frank. Frank joins his father's crime family, now known as the Colombo Family, while John Jr. enters legitimate business. According to a profile of John Jr., he has three brothers in business with him at Colavita USA: Joseph, Anthony, and Robert. Joe has at least one daughter, who marries a gangster from Detroit.
Nina’s brother, Joseph, becomes Profaci’s long time underboss.
Olive oil is a rationed food in the latter years of World War II, when trade embargoes make it impossible to source legitimate, Italian olive oil. Demand skyrockets after the war.
Profaci is one of dozens of high level Mafia members arrested at Apalachin in 1957.
In 1959, a shipment of Sicilian oranges Joe Profaci is recorded discussing on the phone, turns out to be wax fruit covering 110 lbs of pure heroin.
Profaci and Joe Bonanno are close friends. Their families visit each other often. Profaci’s niece Rosalie marries Salvatore Bonanno. His daughter marries the son of Vito Tocco, from Detroit.
Profaci's territory is Long Island, where he has a home that was previously owned by former US President Theodore Roosevelt. 
Profaci is a devout Catholic who makes many donations to Catholic charities.
He does not pay his taxes.
Profaci dies at the age of 64, of cancer, on 6 June 1962, six months after the death of Lucky Luciano. (The American Mafia History site gives his date of death on the seventh.) A sculpture of St. Aloysius, bearing a cross and clutching a skull, stands atop Joe Profaci’s mausoleum.
John Jr. begins an olive oil import business, Colavita USA, in 1978.
Have you taken a DNA test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.