According to the Wikipedia entry, which cites Critchley, Gaetano "Tommy" Reina is born in September 1889 in Corleone to Giacomo Reina and Carmela Rumore. Giacomo and Carmela married in 1891. No baptismal record for Gaetano has been found in the Corleone records, however, he may have been born in Calatafimi.
A secondary source supports Giacomo and Carmela as Gaetano's parents. The 1909 immigration records of Antonio Riina, who is the son of Giacomo and Carmela, indicates that Antonio is joining his brother, Gaetano, in New York. Antonio was born in Calatafimi, according to the manifest. Giacomo, a field guard, and Carmela both lived in Calatafimi when they married in 1891. Giacomo and Carmela are both natives of Corleone, and returned there by the time their son, Salvatore, was stillborn in 1893. It's possible Gaetano was born in 1892 in Calatafimi. Cascio-10 22:31, 11 April 2016 (EDT). The marriage record of Gaetano and his wife Angelina also list Giacomo and Carmela Rumore as Gaetano's parents.
According to Critchley's book, Bernarda Riina, who marries Vincent Terranova, an associate of Tommy's, is Gaetano's sister. Three vital records for Bernarda confirm that her parents are Giacomo Riina and Giuseppa di Miceli. Gaetano and Bernarda are second cousins.
There is a Findagrave entry for Gaetano Riina which gives the dates 27 September 1889 and 26 February 1930 for his birth and death. His gravestone gives the years only.
In 1909, Antonino Riina, age 18 (b. 1891), immigrates to New York, arriving on 15 October. His closest relative at home is his father Giacomo Riina, who lives in the Piazza Inferiore, Corleone. Antonino, born in Calatafimi, is a farmer/laborer joining his brother Gaetano Riina, who lives at 2256 107th St, New York.
Gaetano marries Angelina Olivieri, daughter of Andrea Olivieri and Rosaria Streva, in April 1906 in Manhattan.
Gaetano and Angelina have eleven children, nine of whom survive infancy: six boys and three girls.
Their children are Carmela/Mildred (1906), Grazia (c. 1910), Giacomo/Jack (c. 1911), Rose (c. 1912), Henry (c. 1914), Sam (c. 1916), Giovanni (c. 1917), John (c. 1920), Lucia (c. 1923), Bernard (c. 1924), and Anna (c. 1926).
In the 1920 federal census of Manhattan, taken 3 January, Thomas Rena, 32 (b. 1887), heads a household at 279 E. 101st St. with his wife, Angelina, 28 (b. 1891). They were born in Italy and immigrated in 1900 or 1910. Thomas is in the ice business, working on his own account. Also at home are their children: Camillie, 12 (b. 1907), Jack, 10 (b. 1909), Rose, 9 (b. 1910), Henry, 7 (b. 1912), Sam, 5 (b. 1914), and John, eight months (b. Apr 1919), all born in New York.
Joe "the Boss" Masseria, the most powerful gangster in New York in 1930, attempts to muscle in on Reina's territory in the Bronx, and Reina resists. Masseria orders Reina's murder. Tommy Gagliano is brought into his plan, and the murder is carried out by Vito Genovese.
On the evening of 26 February 1930, Reina is shot in the head with a sawed-off double barrel shotgun, as he leaves 1522 Sheridan Avenue in the Claremont section of the Bronx. He is killed instantly. Police find on his body a handgun and $804 in cash. (Later reports incorrectly give his year of death as 1929.)
Gaetano is buried in Woodlawn Cemetery.
According to FamilySearch archives, Giacomo Riina ("Reena") dies at age 40 (b. 1890) on 26 Feb 1930, at 3183 Rochambeau Av in the Bronx, and is buried in Woodlawn Cemetery. He is married, an ice dealer by profession. His wife's name is given as Angelina Reena.
Although he has recently died, Tommy Reina heads a household in the 1930 census.
In the 1930 census, taken 5 April, Thomas Reina, 40 (b. 1890), heads a household at 3183 Rochambeau Ave. He married at age 17 (m. 1907) to Angelina, who is 38 (b. 1892). Also at home are their children Mildred, 22 (b. 1908), Jack, 20 (b. 1910), Rose, 19 (b. 1911), Henry, 17 (b. 1913), Sam, 14 (b. 1916), John, 10 (b. 1920), Lucia, 8 (b. 1922), Bernard, 7 (b. 1923), and Anna, 5 (b. 1925). Thomas and Angelina were born in Italy and their children were born in New York. Thomas immigrated in 1904 and Angelina in 1903. Thomas is an ice dealer. Mildred is a bookkeeper, Jack is a cashier, and Henry is an ice truckman. Reina’s home in the Bronx is said to be valued at $40,000. That is more than $600,000 in 2018 dollars. According to Zillow, Reina's home was built in 1930, has over 4,000 square feet, and last sold in 2009 for $555K. Its estimated value is over $735K in 2018.
After Reina's murder, Gagliano takes over Reina’s family.
Mildred marries Mafia turncoat Joe Valachi, who brings down the Lucchese crime family. Their marriage has been described as a union of underworld convenience to cement gangland hierarchy families. There had been talk that Valachi was one of Gaetano Reina's assassins.
Have you taken a DNA test for genealogy? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.