The Rodman Family genealogy does not provide "proof" of the "Whiting" marriage only a statement, no documentation, no children and no information on the parents of "Wm. Whiting".
Marriage
"Genealogy of the Rodman Family (1620-1886)" notes that Ruth Rodman, daughter of Joseph Rodman and Mary West married "William Whiting."[1]
Ancestry of the Whitney Families of Pittsfield and Camden Twp., Lorain Co., filed with the Broome Co. Historical Society, Binghamton, N.Y., which names the daughter of Joseph Rodman as being Ruth Rodman, the wife of William Whitney Not Whiting.
Whitney Genealogy of the Brothers, Judge Joshua and Gen. William Whitney of Binghamton, N.Y. by Hallam S. Whitney and Dr. F. E. Weeks
Whitney Research Group regarding William Whitney 1755-1810 and wife, Ruth Rodman by Robert L. Ward
The merge included a marriage to "William Whitney" as well as a large number of children based on "The Whitneys of Binghamton, New York And Points West."[2] Neither of these sources should be considered "proof" of either marriage and more research is needed to determine the correct name of Ruth's spouse and verify her children. Unfortunately since the merge was completed without evidence that the two profiles represented the same person, Ruth now has a large unproven family and for now, the spouse that came with the merge is left intact. Both last names have been added to the profile, however, so that Ruth shows up in possible searches for both last names.
The Whitneys of Binghamton, New York And Points West[2]
William Whitney
Research
Note that "The Descendants of John Whitney"[3] contains no information about William's marriages, including the alleged marriage to this Ruth Rodman.
Per comments by Ruth Proffett, a recent 2017 DNA test confirms the relationship between descendents of Ruth Rodman and her brother Asa Rodman. DNA proof citations needed.
Sources
DAR Ancestor Number: A097947 Rodman; A125404 Whitney
Ancestry of the Whitney Families of Pittsfield and Camden Twp., Lorain Co., filed with the Broome Co. Historical Society, Binghamton, NY. confirms Ruth Rodman, daughter of Joseph Rodman, is the wife of William Whitney (not Whiting).
↑ 1.01.11.2 Charles Henry Jones, Genealogy of the Rodman Family (1620-1886); (Philadelphia, Alles, Lane and Scott, 1886) p. 35. [Copy available at (https://archive.org/details/genealogyofrodma00jone).] Father: Joseph Rodman (b. 23 March 1733), Mother: Mary West (b. 22 July 1740). Joseph lived in Nobletown (later known as Hillsdale), Columbia, New York, Child: Ruth Rodman (b. 16 March 1759, married William Whiting. ~ Allison Mackler
↑ 2.02.12.2 *Whitney Research Group: Whitney Genealogy of the Brothers, Judge Joshua and Gen. William Whitney of Binghamton, N.Y. (1932) by Hallam S. Whitney and Dr. F.E. Weeks. Rodman, Ruth, "The Whitneys of Binghamton, New York And Points West", Florida State DAR Genealogical Records Committee Report, Series 2, vol. 58 by Mrs. John H. Shields, Philip Perry Chapter, Genealogical Records Chairman. This source needs confirmation as merge of this profile appears to have been the result of this source, but no actual information has been provided proving that the spouse of William Whitney is the same as this Ruth Rodman married to William Whiting, which is documented in the "Genealogy of the Rodman Family." Searching via Google finds one reference to "Whitneys of New York," Call Number 929.2 WHI, writing and published by the Florida State DAR. DAR records are not primary sources, so more research is needed. ~ Allison Mackler
Is Ruth your ancestor? Please don't go away! Login to collaborate or comment, or contact
the profile manager, or ask our community of genealogists a question.
Sponsored Search by Ancestry.com
DNA Connections
It may be possible to confirm family relationships with Ruth by comparing test results with other carriers of her mitochondrial DNA.
However, there are no known mtDNA test-takers in her direct maternal line.
It is likely that these autosomal DNA test-takers will share some percentage of DNA with Ruth:
My 7th great grandfather was Dr. John Rodman m. to Mary Scammon (Rodman-120). If there is enough Cm, then I feel confident that my connection would be proven by dna triangulation as I have other Rodman descendant matches. Ruth is my 4th cousin 4x removed, but I do not see my dna results listed here as a possible match. I would appreciate any help in figuring out how to do this triangulation thing.
This profile (Ruth Rodman) is getting DB errors 213 & 313.
The parents' confirmed with DNA relationship status indicators should be cleared until the DNA confirmations can be properly cited under Sources.
For guidance on providing the proper source documentation when confirming genealogy with DNA on WikiTree, go here. Please see this article for information on how to connect DNA tests to Wikitree, if needed.
Thank you.
John Kingman, Coordinator with the DNA Project
If there isn't a proper source citation the "Confirmed with DNA" relationship status should be removed (by you or another member). -- WikiTree help for confirming with DNA
thanks
The parents' confirmed with DNA relationship status indicators should be cleared until the DNA confirmations can be properly cited under Sources.
For guidance on providing the proper source documentation when confirming genealogy with DNA on WikiTree, go here. Please see this article for information on how to connect DNA tests to Wikitree, if needed.
Thank you.
John Kingman, Coordinator with the DNA Project