Jean Robertson Puzzle

Jean Robertson Puzzle

Jean Robertson Puzzle


The goal of this project is:

  • To determine the correct ancestry of Jean (Robertson) Henry, grandmother of Rev. War patriot Gov. Patrick Henry.
  • To improve the profiles of her descendants
  • To use this as a space to document our conclusions so others can see

Contents

Overview of Problem

In the older genealogies dating back a hundred years or more, she was noted down as either the sister of Rev. William Robertson of Greyfriars Chuch, or his daughter, making her either the aunt or the sister of the famous Scottish historian William Robertson.

It was accepted as fact for a long time, and her son Col. John Henry was included in lists of "Gateway Ancestors" by virtue of this link to Rev. William Robertson giving him royal ancestry.

A problem has come to light since, when it was discovered that there is, as yet, no primary documents that attest to this link. There are also lots of incorrect pedigrees for Rev. William Robertson's family, but there are some sources from which we can glean what we know right now.

What We Know

At this point in time, until further documentation can be found, all we know about her is:

  1. She lived in the Aberdeen region of Scotland, based on her husband being listed as a school teacher in Aberdour Parish and a farmer in Old Machar Parish
  2. She had two sons who emigrated to Virginia, Rev. Patrick Henry and Col. John Henry
  3. That she had a brother who emigrated to Virginia[1]
  4. She had a husband named either Alexander or Patrick. Primary documents indicate it as Patrick, whereas his granddaughter Margaret Donald writing in 1790, said it was Alexander.[1]
  5. She had three daughters, according to the Margaret Donald letter, long dead before 1790, and can be stated, with varying degrees of confidence, to be:
    1. Jean Henry who m.1 William Duguid and m.2 Alexander Donald. Proven due to the fact that she is Margaret Donald's mother, the writer of the letter
    2. Isabel Henry who m. Alexander Milne. A record of her birth exists in the Aberdour Parish records listing her parents as Jean Robertson and Patrick Henry[2]
    3. Elizabeth Henry who m. William Simpson/Simson. Tentative. A record exists in Aberdour Parish records for the birth of Ann Simson, identifying her mother as Elizabeth Henry and the witness being "Mr. Patrick Henry, Schoolmr"

For an excellent analysis of Margaret Donald's letter and the information gleaned from it, see Karen Lucas Williams's page Margaret Donald Letter to Gov. Patrick Henry

Profiles

These are the main profiles affected:

This is the profile of the previously accepted brother:

Members

Right now this project just has one member, me. I am Angela Trigg.

Tasks

Here are some of the tasks that I think need to be done. I'll be working on them, and could use your help.

  • Add in the descendants of Jean Robertson using only reliable sources, with emphasis on branches that could inherit her X chromosome or her mtDNA in hopes we can find matches to a line farther back from her.
  • Collaborate on solving the puzzle using traditional paper trails
  • Monitor her and her husband's profile to make sure they aren't added to undocumented parents, or that undocumented children aren't added

Primary Sources

Joining

Will you join me? Please post a comment here on this page, in G2G using the project tag jean_robertson_puzzle, or send me a private message. Thanks!

Sources

  1. 1.0 1.1 Margaret Donald's Letter to her cousin, Gov. Patrick Henry of Virginia, 1790
  2. "Scotland Births and Baptisms, 1564-1950," database, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:XY6T-W59 : 2 January 2015), Isabel Henry, 03 Apr 1706; citing ABERDOUR,ABERDEEN,SCOTLAND, reference ; FHL microfilm 991,252.



Inbound links

Collaboration on Jean Robertson Puzzle

  • Login to edit this profile and add images.
  • Private Messages: Send a private message to the Profile Manager. (Best when privacy is an issue.)
  • Public Comments: Login to post. (Best for messages specifically directed to those editing this profile. Limit 20 per day.)

Memories of Jean Robertson Puzzle

Photos of Jean Robertson Puzzle: 1

Jean Robertson / William Robertson connection?
(1/1) Jean Robertson / William Robertson connection? Jean Robertson Puzzle. USA 7 Aug 2018

G2G Forum




Comments on Jean Robertson Puzzle: 5


Login to post a comment.

Catambay-1
Bill Catambay
My personal endeavor is to uncover the possible connection between my 5th great grandmother, Isobel Robertson (b. 12 MAR 1730 • Canongate, Midlothian, Scotland), and Jean Robertson. My gut tells me they are related, but how far back? (Adam & Eve?)

posted by Bill Catambay

Catambay-1
Bill Catambay
Rev William Robertson; b. Borthwick, 8 Sep 1721, son of William Roberts of Greyfriars, d. 11 Jun 1793, m. 22 Aug 1751 Mary Nisbet (b. 10 Jan 1723, d. 11 Mar 1802), issue: Mary, b. 2 Aug 1752 (m. 4 Apr 1785 Patrick Brydone); William, b. 15 Dec 1753, d. 20 Nov 1835; Eleanor, b. 5 Aug 1755 (m. 8 Jun 1778 John Russell), d. 17 Jan 1837; Janet, b. 3 Dec 1756, d. Dec 1789 (unmarr); James (General), b. 26 Jan 1762, d. 29 Mar 1845; David, b. 29 Sep 1764 (m. 2 Oct 1799 Margaret Macdonald), d. 7 Sep 1845

posted by Bill Catambay

Catambay-1
Bill Catambay
Rev William Robertson; b. 30 Jun 1686 of Wemyss, Fife; 3rd son of William Robinson of Gladney + Margaret Mitchell; d. 16 Nov 1745; m. 20 Oct 1720 Eleanor Pitcairn;

issue: William (the historian); Robert, b. 10 Nov 1722, d. 15 Jan 1723; Mary, b. 6 Nov 1723 (m. 17 Oct 1751 James Syme), d. 9 Apr 1803; Margaret, b. 16 Feb 1725 (m. 15 Jun 1750 Alexander Bruce), d. May 1781; Elizabeth, b. 25 Oct 1727 (m. 2 Jun 1754 Archibald Hope); Patrick, b. 6 Aug 1729, d. 8 Sep 1790; Helen, b. 5 Feb 1734, d. 24 Jan 1816; James, b. 30 Jun, d. 1 Jul 1737; Jane, b. 4 July 1738 (m. 4 Jul 1756 William Gifford); Eupham, b. 13 Feb 1739 (m. James Cunningham), d. Mar 1807; Archibald, b. 28 Mar 1741, d. Mar 1742

posted by Bill Catambay

Catambay-1
Bill Catambay
I'm interested. I'm been killing days of my time trying to clean up my tree with regards to the Henry and Robertson connections, and feel like I am going in circles. I do have some sources that could help.

"This History of Fife Pitcairns with Transcripts from Old Charters" - includes data on the Rev William Robertson, who I also thought might be Jean's brother, but am now doubtful.

"Fasti ecclesiae scoticanae; the succession of ministers in the Church of Scotland from the reformation" - data on the ministers of Scotland, including two different Rev. William Robertson's.

posted by Bill Catambay

Groves-2482
Jeff Groves
Hi Angela:

I too am interested in confirming Jean Henry's ancestors. When I came across this link on geni.com, I dug in to it a bit and, like you, found no solid evidence of connection to "William Robertson of Gladney and Brunton" as they list him on geni.com.

I'd like to help with this project to find evidence for or against this proposed relationship.

posted by Jeff Groves