upload image

Quality Scale

Privacy Level: Open (White)
Date: 4 Apr 2017 [unknown]
Location: [unknown]
Surnames/tags: Quality Projects Categorization
Profile manager: Marcel Muise private message [send private message]
This page has been accessed 74 times.

This page is a draft new procedure. Muise-22 07:43, 9 April 2017 (EDT)

This page has an example scale to be used by projects and ONS to evaluate their profiles and measure progress, similar to Wikipedia's Scale . For now, how to apply the scale is left up to each Project and ONS leadership.

The criteria for each parameter must be met for a given Class, for the whole profile to be assessed at that level.

Parameter Stub Start C-Class B-Class A-Class

Profile just getting started

Some but not all C-Class criteria met Well written, easily read, developed biography Some but not all A-Class criteria met Very well written, interesting, and developed biography. Bi-lingual narrative included if appropriate
Sources No sources Some sources included, but not yet primary sources Cites for profile header data (birth, death places and dates) included in the biography with inline citations are used. Some primary sources cited Primary sources cited and easily verifiable online
Categorization No categories N/A Some categories included N/A All appropriate categories included such as BMD places, immigration ships, occupation, causes of death,major events
DNA None N/A mtDNA or Y-DNA descendants tested N/A mtDNA and (for males) Y-DNA descendants tested
Other Some but not all A-Class criteria met Profiles exists for parents, siblings, spouses and children. Place names are consistent with use during the relevant time period, in lieu of today's use.


On 8 Apr 2017 at 20:40 GMT Marcel Muise wrote:

This is a very basic beginning. Feel free to edit the table, post an idea here, or PM the Profile Manager. Specifically looking for feedback on should templates for each be developed, categories, both, or none.