John Tuthill
Privacy Level: Open (White)

John Tuthill (1635 - 1717)

John Tuthill
Born in Hingham, Massachusetts Baymap [uncertain]
Ancestors ancestors
Husband of — married 17 Feb 1657 in Southold, Suffolk, New Yorkmap
Husband of — married 28 May 1690 in Southold, Suffolk, New Yorkmap
Descendants descendants
Died in Southold, Suffolk, New York Colonymap
Profile last modified | Created 6 Jan 2010
This page has been accessed 2,625 times.



As found in "The Tuthill Family of Tharston, Norfolk County, England and Southold, Suffolk County, New York: Also Written Totyl, Totehill, Tothill, Tuttle, Etc. 1580-1757" by Lucy Dubois Akerly, pages 4-5:

John Tuthill was the son of Henry Tuthill and Bridget (surname unknown), born 16 July, 1635. He may have been born in England. He may have been born in Hingham, Massachusetts, since "Lincoln's History of Hingham (Massachusetts) says Henry Tuthill had a planting lot at Broad Cove in 1635, and a house lot in 1637." His brother Daniel is listed as baptized in Hingham in 1640.

His father Henry "sold his lot in Hingham 20 June, 1644, and doubtless came to Southold". John was not born in Southold, New York.

John Tuthill married Deliverance King 17 February, 1657. After Deliverance's death 25 January, 1689, John married Sarah Frost, the daughter of John Frost, on 28 May, 1690.


16 JUL 1635 Southold, Suffolk, New York
16 JUL 1635 Essex, Massachusetts


Wife: Deliverance King
17 Feb 1656/7 Suffolk, New York[1]


age 83


  1. New York City Marriages
  • John Tuthill, Jr., or 2nd (Henry 2, Henry 1), of Southold, N. Y., b. 16 July, 1635 (in England.?), d. at Southold, 12 Oct., 1717; -- m. there, 1st, on 17 Feb., 1657, Deliverance, daughter of William and Dorothy (Hayne?) Kinge, "bapt. at Salem, Mass., 1641:31:8." She d. at Southold, "25 Jan. 1688-9, aged 49 years." -- John, m. 2nd, on 28 May, 1690, Sarah, probably widow of Thomas Young, and daughter of John Frost. She d. 8 Nov., 1727.-- Issue, by 1st wife: John, b. 14 Feb., 1658; Elizabeth, b. 19 April, 1661, m. 1 June, 1681, William Wells b. 5 May, 1660; d. 17 Oct., 1696; Hannah, b. 7 Nov., 1667, d. 25 July, 1752, m., 19 Jan., 1686, Joshua Wells, b. 1664, d. 1744; Abigail, b. 17 Oct., 1670, d. 6 June, 1705, being the wife of John Parker. He was probably her 2nd husband, as she had doubtless m. Joseph Conklin, in Nov., 1690; Dorothy, b. 16 Oct., 1674; d. 24 Feb., 1683-4; Deliverance, b. 2 Aug., 1677; d. 17 Sept., 1683; Daniel, b. 23 Jan., 1679; Nathaniel, b. 10 Nov., 1683, d. at Antigua, W. I., 18 Dec., 1705; Mary (daughter of 2nd wife), d. 11 Jan., 1698-9, aged about 8 years.
  • Alphabetical Listing and then mostly in order by birth year. JOHN TUTHILL 16 July 1635 son of Henry 1612; d. 12 Oct 1717 Oysterponds (Orient) L I; m.(1) 17 Feb 1657 Southold, L I, Deliverance bapt. 31 Aug 1641 Salem, Mass; d. 25 Jan 1689 Oysterponds, dau. William & Dorothy (HAYNE) KING; m.(2) 28 May 1690 Southold, Sarah 3 Sep 1635, d. 8 Nov 1728 Southold dau. John & Mercy (PAINE) FROST & widow Thomas YOUNGS LTV (1200) 1. John 14 Feb 1658; 2. Elizabeth 19 Jan 1661; 3. Henry 1 May 1665; 4. Hannah 7 Nov 1667; 5. Abigail 17 Oct 1670; 6-7. d. y.; 8. Daniel 23 Jan 1680; 9 Nathaniel 10 Nov 1683; 10. d. y.[1]

More Genealogy Tools

Sponsored Search

Is John your ancestor? Please don't go away!
 star icon Login to collaborate or comment, or
 star icon contact private message private message a profile manager, or
 star icon ask our community of genealogists a question.
Sponsored Search by

DNA Connections
It may be possible to confirm family relationships with John by comparing test results with other carriers of his Y-chromosome or his mother's mitochondrial DNA. Y-chromosome DNA test-takers in his direct paternal line on WikiTree:

Have you taken a DNA test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.

Sponsored by Ancestry ®

Family History Search.


Enter a grandparent's name. Just one grandparent can lead you to many discoveries.

Comments: 2

Leave a message for others who see this profile.
There are no comments yet.
Login to post a comment.
Tuthill-753 and Tuthill-5 appear to represent the same person because: Same parents, birth and death dates and places. Son on -753 also on -5. Please merge
posted by S (Hill) Willson
I'm finding confusion about the children of John Tuthill-5 and John Tuthill-98. According to "Tuttle and Tuthill Lines in America" Compiled by Alva M Tuthill, Published in 1968 by the Compiler John-98's children were: john b c 1685, Mary b c 168 7, josh b c 1690, James b c 1692, Dorothy b c 1694, Freegift b August 8 1698, Daniel b c 1700, Jemima(Hannah?) b c 1703. John-5's children are listed as: John-98 b Feb 14 1658, Elizabeth b Jan 19 1661, Henry b May 1 1665, Hannah b Nov 7 1667, Abigail b Oct 17 1670, Daniel b Jan 23 1680, Nathaniel b Nov 10 1683. Also Sarah Frost was John-5's second wife not John-98's according to the same source.

I'd like to collaborate with anybody who wants to get this all sorted out.

posted by Jennifer Lapham

T  >  Tuthill  >  John Tuthill

Categories: US President Direct Ancestor