Anderson does not provide a maiden name for her.[1] Others have looked into this question and have not been able to come up with a good answer.[2] "Previous antiquarian researches claim that Sarah's maiden name, among others, could have been: Hutchinson, Darling, or They. Regrettably, none of these writers provided requisite proof for their assertions"
[Note: Birth estimated based on age 42 at death in 1666 on her gravestone . [3]]
[Note: There strong indication that her 'gravestone' was not original at her death but carved sometime later, by George Allen c 1740 [3]]
[Note: Her gravestone indicates her birth in Dorchester, New England, however Dorchester was not established in 1624 [3]]
Biography
Sarah (unk), the wife of John Whipple was born about 1624, based on her age of 42 in 1666, as listed on her gravestone. [3][4][5]
Her husband John Whipple came to New England by 1632, when he was in Dorchester in service to Israel Stoughton, carpenter. He was likely aged about 15. He was granted land in Dorchester in 1637. [4][6]
1641: October 29: Goodwife Whipple was admitted to the First Church at Dorchester. [8][4][6][7]
1658: November 15: John Whipple sold his Dorchester house and lands to George Minot. His wife Sarah relinquished her dower rights. [7][4]
1658/9: Removed to Providence, Rhode Island. [4][7]
1666: Died at Providence.
Sarah's gravestone, in the North Burial Ground at Providence reads: In Memory of Mrs. Sarah Whipple wife of Capt. John Whipple. She was born in Dorchester New England (sic) & Died in Providence Anno Dom 1666. Aged about 42 years. [4][3]
Her body was moved likely from a family burial plot to the North Burial Ground sometime after her death, and the headstone created the later date. [3][6]
Her husband, Captain John Whipple died on May 16, 1685. [4][6][3][7]
Children
John baptized in October 1641 [8]; died on December 15, 1700; married first on Mary Olney on December 4, 1663, at Providence; married second Rebecca Scott on April 15, 1678. [4][6][7]
Sarah baptized on February 6, 1642 [8]; died after May 10, 1710; married John Smith c 1662. [4][7]; married second, Richard Arnold. [6]
Samuel baptized on March 1, 1644 [8]; died March 12, 1710/11; married Mary Harris c 1669. [4][6][7]
Eleazer baptized on March 8, 1646 [8]; died on August 25, 1719; married Alice Angell on January 26, 1669/70. [4][6][7]
Mary baptized on April 9, 1648 [8]; died July 2, 1698; married Epenetus Olney on [4] March 9, 1665/6. [6][7];
William baptized on May 16, 1652 [8];died on March 9, 1711/12; married Mary (unk). [4][6][7]
Benjamin baptized on June 4, 1654 [8]; died on March 11, 1703/4; married Ruth Mathewson on April 1, 1686. [4][6][7]
David baptized on September 27, 1656 [8]; died on December 18, 1710 at Attleboro or Rehoboth, Massachusetts [4]; married first on Sarah ? Gregory[6] or Sarah ?Hearndon[7]; married second Hannah Tower on at Hingham on November 11, 1677. [6][7]
Abigail born c 1658; died on August 19, 1725; married first Stephen Dexter c 1674; married second, William Hopkins in January, 1682. [4][6][7];
Joseph born c 1662; died April 28, 1746; married Alice Smith on May 20, 1684. [4][6][7];
Jonathan born c 1664; died on September 8, 1721; married first Margery/Margaret Angell c 1688; married second Anne (unk). [4][6][7]
↑ 3.03.13.23.33.43.53.6 Sterling, John E. North Burial Ground Providence, Rhode Island, Old Section 1700-1748, Special Publication No. 5, Rhode Island Genealogical, Society, Greenville, Rhode Island, 2000, p. 13
↑ Clara Hammond McGuigan (with additional sections by Robert W. Merriam) , The Antecedents and Descendants of Noah Whipple of the Rogerene Community at Quakertown, Connecticut, Ithaca, New York: John M. Kingsbury, 1971 , p. 30
↑ 6.006.016.026.036.046.056.066.076.086.096.106.116.126.136.146.15 Whipple, Charles M. Jr., compiler. A History of Captain John and Sarah Whipple of Dorchester, Massachusetts and Providence, Rhode Island 1617-1685 : A multigenerational Study of the First Whipple family in America: Third in a series of 21st century books on the Whipple families of America, Trafford Publishing, Victoria, British Columbia, Canada, 2007 p. 4-6: 28-9
↑ 7.007.017.027.037.047.057.067.077.087.097.107.117.127.137.147.157.16 Anderson, Robert C. John Whipple in: The Great Migration Begins: Immigrants to N.E. 1620-1633, Vols. I-III, NEHGS, Boston, Massachusetts, 1995 p. 1970-4 (Online database: AmericanAncestors.org, New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2010)
↑ 8.08.18.28.38.48.58.68.78.88.9 Records of the First Church at Dorchester, in New England, 1636-1734, Geroge Ellis, Boston, Massachusetts, 1891 p. 154
Hutchinson-3435 and Unknown-300803 appear to represent the same person because: There are no sources in the Hutchinson-3435 profile, which puts this in direct conflict with the detailed sources and analysis we have put together in the Unknown-300803 profile. The profiles should be merged and the Hutchinson surname should be removed, as there are no sources to support this surname for Sarah, the wife of John Whipple.
I agree with Joe. In the absence of a source, England and "uncertain" is the most logical based on what we know of Sarah and what we know of the Massachusetts in the 1620s.
Charles M. Whipple, Jr., Captain John and Sarah Whipple of Dorchester, Massachusetts & Providence, Rhode Island, 10 Feb 2005 wrote that in 2005. I am good with 1624 "uncertain" because that fits with the marriage. Also, given that she was likely born around 1624, listing her birthplace as England "uncertain" makes the most sense, as we have no evidence that she came from a family that was in the Plymouth Colony in the 1620s.
From Charles Whipple's 2005 essay, "Within two years or so of becoming a landed proprietor, John was married to the 15 or 16-year-old Sarah?They, Darling, or Hutchinson. When or where Sarah was born is unknown. Information on her gravestone sets her birth at Dorchester in about 1624, but this is unlikely since only Plymouth Colony was in existence at that time. Sarah Whipple, on 29 October 1641, addressed as Goodwife Whipple, one of the lowest social class distinctions, was admitted to the Dorchester church. John would have had to be a member by then, as freemen were required to be members of the church."
Is there a source for her being born in England? I'm willing to say that the memorial is apocryphal, she wasn't born in Dorchester in 1624, but if she died at about 42 in 1666, then she was born about 1624. Is the thinking that she must have been born in England because there was no one in Massachusetts at the time that is similar to her but hasn't already been accounted for?
Hey Jillian - That is a fair point. Great write up on your logic for the marriage information. Thanks for your contribution.
Let me note though that many users do not offer such explanations when making changes. The Puritan Great Migration profiles need this higher level of attention when users make changes. There are typically several profile managers on profiles of PGM ancestors. As such, changes should be made with sources and/or detailed statements like the one you wrote explaining the reasoning behind the change.
merge completed. locked status may be removed, if you desire.
Let me note though that many users do not offer such explanations when making changes. The Puritan Great Migration profiles need this higher level of attention when users make changes. There are typically several profile managers on profiles of PGM ancestors. As such, changes should be made with sources and/or detailed statements like the one you wrote explaining the reasoning behind the change.