| Rebecca (Hilton) Roberts migrated to New England during the Puritan Great Migration (1621-1640). Join: Puritan Great Migration Project Discuss: pgm |
Contents |
First it must be noted that there is apparently no proof that her first name was actually Rebecca although it is asserted, without source in a variety of places. As a project-managed profile (PGM), an unproven name is sometimes left in place mainly to prevent users from creating a new (and unsourced) profile of that same name in a mistaken belief that the name is a proven fact.
Rebecca's husband Thomas Roberts "probably was married in 1627. The maiden name of his wife is not known, but there is a tradition she was sister of Edward Hilton. Further than that we know not."[1] Pre-merge parents given as: Mark Hilton and Ellen Mainwarring, without sources. If she was sister of Edward, her father would have been called William.
More information from a Roberts researcher: "It is "traditionally given that the wife of Thomas Roberts was Rebecca Hilton, sister of Edward and William Hilton". What does that mean? I cannot find anywhere anything other than that statement when looking for detail on the wife of Thomas Roberts. The baptisms of the children of William Hilton of Witton cum Twamsbrook, Cheshire are recorded in the parish records. His children include Edward, William and Richard who all immigrated to New Hampshire. There is also a son John, and daughters Margaret, Mary and Elizabeth. There is no Rebecca. There is no known date of birth and there is no known date of death. There is no record of their marriage. They did not even name a daughter after her and interestingly only one of her five children named a girl Rebecca. Everything that is written about her is pure conjecture and not fact. I'm not even sure her name was really Rebecca."[2]
Rebecca has briefly been shown on WikiTree as daughter of Mark Hilton and Ellen Mainwaring, both of whose profiles, as at 4 June 2022, lack sourcing. There appears to be no evidence for this.
The following should be considered as potential leads, but not as evidence.
Have you taken a DNA test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.
Rebecca is 16 degrees from Emeril Lagasse, 20 degrees from Nigella Lawson, 20 degrees from Maggie Beer, 41 degrees from Mary Hunnings, 25 degrees from Joop Braakhekke, 24 degrees from Michael Chow, 19 degrees from Ree Drummond, 22 degrees from Paul Hollywood, 19 degrees from Matty Matheson, 21 degrees from Martha Stewart, 27 degrees from Danny Trejo and 21 degrees from Molly Yeh on our single family tree. Login to find your connection.
H > Hilton | R > Roberts > Rebecca (Hilton) Roberts
Categories: Dover, New Hampshire | Kings Chapel Burying Ground, Boston, Massachusetts | Puritan Great Migration
We also don't know that she was a Hilton.
The available evidence is insufficient because we have not found her birth record or marriage record, and we have not found birth records for her children that name her.
I plan to revert those changes.
Hope those who feel this action was premature will comment here and provide reliable sources so that we may collaborate further.--Gene
edited by GeneJ X
edited by Bobbie (Madison) Hall
edited by Michael Cayley
Unless you or another WT member can find good evidence for her parents, I would be inclined to remove the unsupported parents when completing the merge, but to add a research note mentioning what I have just said in the preceding paragraph.
An alternative is first to ask a question in G2G to see if anyone has any sourcing to support the tradition.
I am taking your reply as agreement from PGM that I can complete the merge, so I will do so, and add the research note. Please edit the research note as you think appropriate :-)
edited by Michael Cayley
I see the original post from 2015 asking the same question so rather than re-invent the wheel I'll put an updated comment on it. I still don't see anything in the G2G post or in the sources here or on Thomas that provide a primary source for her first or last name.
edited by Brad Stauf
Cheers, Susan