At one time, it was speculated that a John Whitlock, born 1585, in Cholesbury, Buckinghamshire, England, was the immigrant to Connecticut, or perhaps his father, and also the father of Hannah (Whitlock) Baldwin and Rose (Whitlock) Parker. Further research by the Whitlock Family Association has proved this to be a false lead. The association with Cholesbury belongs strictly to the Baldwin Family.[1]
Suggested scenario: John Whitlock, male, b. 1585, Cholesbury, Buckinghamshire, England allegedly married Sarah Vile July 10, 1610 at Buckinghamshire, England. They were parents of Hannah Whitlock[2]
The logic here does not fit. John of Connecticut's children were underage in 1659 when he died. John's son, David's children were born about 1680-1695, estimating David's birth at say 1650, but not earlier than 1639. John Jr's children were born in a similar time frame. The possible daughter Sarah was 12 in 1667 making her birth in 1655.
It is illogical that a John and Sarah married in 1610, were having children in 1650.
John, Rose and Hannah Whitlock have no known relationship. Sarah Vile was determined to be speculation.[3]
About 1624 to before 14 Oct 1659
John Whitlock was born about 1624.
John was an early settler of Fairfield, Connecticut.[4]
John Whitlock died before 14 Oct 1659, when an inventory of his estate was made. He died intestate. Children included David, John and daughters. His widow married Henry Whelpley and d. probably about 1661.[5]
Children:
David Whitlock m. Mary Sherwood
John Whitlock married Sarah Sherwood
Daughters - One of these was probably Sarah Whitlock who was mentioned by Winthrop in 1667 lived at Thomas Sanford's in Milford, fatherless and motherless.
Sources
↑ Four articles published in the "Whitlock Family Newsletter": 2005.12.05 "Whitlocks of Cholesbury, Buckinghamshire" (re John Whitlock b.1585?); 2011.06.05 "Whitlocks of Cholesbury, Buckinghamshire - Update." (Research to try to prove or disprove connection); 2011.09.09 "Whitlocks of Cholesbury, Buckinghamshire - Update." (No Whitlocks listed in Cholesbury parish registers (1576-1901)); 2011.12.12 "Whitlocks of Cholesbury, Buckinghamshire - Update" (Conclusion - only connection is through Baldwin family). These are downloadable pdf at Whitlock Family Association Website
↑ Netherlands, GenealogieOnline Trees Index, 1000-2015 (Ancestry.com Database), original source: https://www.genealogieonline.nl/ "Stamboom-van- acker-saesen Tree (no longer online as of 1.28.22)
↑ Schenck, Elizabeth Hubbell. The history of Fairfield, Fairfield County, Connecticut, from the settlement of the town in 1639 to 1818. (New York: The author 1889) p. 67
Is John your ancestor? Please don't go away! Login to collaborate or comment, or
contact
a profile manager, or ask our community of genealogists a question.
Sponsored Search by Ancestry.com
DNA Connections
It may be possible to confirm family relationships with John by comparing test results with other carriers of his Y-chromosome or his mother's mitochondrial DNA.
However, there are no known yDNA or mtDNA test-takers in his direct paternal or maternal line.
It is likely that these autosomal DNA test-takers will share some percentage of DNA with John:
Are there any sources showing he was in New England by 1640? I am not seeing any sources for that in his profile, but perhaps I have missed something. He does not have a listing in Anderson's Directory..., and the G2G post does not an immigration date either, but says he was in Salem before he moved to Connecticut.
I'm thinking this is probably two different people.
1. John Whitlock m. Sarah Vile perhaps parents of Hannah and Rose. Death dates unknown. (I can't find any confirmation of these dates and/or relationships). A Hannah m. a Baldwin of Cholesbury.
2. John Whitlock m. Unknown. died Fairfield 1659. Parent of David and John (m. Sarah Sherwood)
Questioning the birth information, listed on the profile. Isn't Netherlands, Genealogie just another set of online trees. Likewise Sarah Vile. We don't even know the wifes first name, how can we know the second?
Thank you
https://ia801406.us.archive.org/23/items/historyoffairfie01sche/historyoffairfie01sche.pdf
Numerous Whelpleys - see p 422
1. John Whitlock m. Sarah Vile perhaps parents of Hannah and Rose. Death dates unknown. (I can't find any confirmation of these dates and/or relationships). A Hannah m. a Baldwin of Cholesbury.
2. John Whitlock m. Unknown. died Fairfield 1659. Parent of David and John (m. Sarah Sherwood)
Please see the question in G2G