On the 3rd of May 1794 William Willis and Horace Smith made bond in the sum of 50 pounds stating that "there be no lawful cause to obstruct" the marriage of William Willis and Nancy Smith. [1] We assume that of the two bond makers, William was the prospective groom, and that Horace Smith was a kinsman of Nancy., but not her father, as on the same day Thomas Smith certified that he gave his consent for his daughter Nancy to marry William Willis. [2]
William and Nancy's marriage took place the 10th of May 1794 in Mercer, Kentucky.[3] The marriage did not succeed, as the 1810 census shows Nancy Willis living by herself in Madison County Kentucky, with three children. William, however, has not died as in 1814 he gives his daughter Rachel permission to marry Christopher Durbin in Madison County.[4]
According to an 1816 court record clarify's Nancy and Williams relationship
Clearly William and Nancy have separated. Divorce at that time was not an option for most people, and in Williams case it appears that abandoned his family. It is not clear what happened to him afterwards. A substantial number of genealogists have concluded that he remarried. Some, for example, point to an 1803 marriage record in Pittsylvannia County, Virginia where a William Willis married a Polly Dalton. Some even show him as marrying multiple wives. We have seen no evidence put forward to show that this (these?) William Willis are in fact the same William who married Nancy Smith. In our opinion, the fate of Nancy's husband is unknown.
We know that William and Nancy ad at least three children, per the 1810 census. One of those children was Rachel Willis who married Christopher Durbin in 1814, as discussed previously. Marriage bonds, and parental permission to marry identify a second child as McKinzie Willis
Analysis in progress...10 Aril 2023
Currently, 10 April 2023, it seems unlikely that Williams parents were Joseph Willis and Mary. Joseph was almost certainly the son of Joseph Willis and Hannah of Brunswick County Virginia. Three of their sons, Joseph, Edward, and John, immigrated to the Madison County area around 1780, settling in the Chaplain Fork watershed. There were other Willis families who settled at the same time in Chaplain Fork, descendants of a Richard Willis and Ann (often identified as Ann Crowder), who settled in Mecklenburg County, Virginia. Mecklenberg is adjacent to modern Brunswick County. Descendants of Richard have YDNA tested and are placed in the Southern Group, Subgroup C, of the Willis YDNA project. The ancestor of that group is almost certainly descended from the Willis line that settled in the 1640's in Gloucester Virginia, either through Francis of Ware River (Gloucester County) or Henry of Fredericksburg (Spotsylvania County).
Joseph of Brunswick County acquired land in Brunswick County while living in Gloucester County. While we do not as yet know who his father was, it is very likely that he is in the branch leading from Francis of Ware River.
YDNA tests show that descendants of William, husband of Nancy Smith, and father of McKinzie Willis, share a YDNA signature that places them in the in the Southwest Virginia and Kentucky YDNA project. That signature does not match that of the Southern YDNA group. As a result, William can not be the son of Joseph Willis and Mary.
1. [Kentucky US County Marriage records 1783-1965]
2. image of original on Ancestry
3. Virginia US Compiled Marriages 1740-1850
4. Kentucky US Marriage records 1783-1965
5 Virginia US Compiled Marriages 1740-1850.
6. [TBD]
Have you taken a DNA test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.
William is 19 degrees from Emeril Lagasse, 23 degrees from Nigella Lawson, 22 degrees from Maggie Beer, 45 degrees from Mary Hunnings, 25 degrees from Joop Braakhekke, 31 degrees from Michael Chow, 17 degrees from Ree Drummond, 24 degrees from Paul Hollywood, 22 degrees from Matty Matheson, 24 degrees from Martha Stewart, 27 degrees from Danny Trejo and 26 degrees from Molly Yeh on our single family tree. Login to find your connection.