This is my maternal great-great grandmother (AKA Grammy East). Caroline/Carolina A. is found on many of the genealogy records. We do not have a copy of her birth/marriage/death records, so we have no confirmation. There IS a photo of her tombstone (from Find-A-Grave.com), and we've SEEN it in person (Berwick, Columbia County, PA - the original Pine Grove Cemetary, not the annex) ... but the name Carrie is on it, which was her nickname.
Have you taken a DNA test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.