no image
Privacy Level: Open (White)

Margaretha Sarah (Ledbetter) Baugher (abt. 1770 - 1839)

Margaretha Sarah Baugher formerly Ledbetter
Born about in Conewago Township, York, Province of Pennsylvaniamap
[sibling(s) unknown]
Wife of — married 1821 in Galatin, Gallatin, Illinois, United Statesmap
[children unknown]
Died at about age 69 in Shelby, Illinois, United Statesmap
Profile last modified | Created 9 May 2011
This page has been accessed 413 times.

Contents

Biography

Margaretha Sarah Ledbetter was born about 1770 in Conewago Township, York, Pennsylvania, daughter of Mary Churchill Bassett (1738–1803).

Margaretha (14) married John Jacob Baugher (24) in 1785.

Children

Research Notes

Both of these statements cannot be true:

  1. Margaretha died on July 21, 1839 in Shelby, Illinois, United States, aged 68.
  2. In 1865, Margaretha (94) was living in Windsor, Shelby County, Illinois. [1]

Sources

  1. "Family Tree," database, FamilySearch: modified 05 June 2022, 05:01), entry for Margaretha Sarah Ledbetter; contributed by various users.

See also:


Acknowledgements

This profile was created through the import of breesefam.ged on 09 May 2011.





Is Margaretha your ancestor? Please don't go away!
 star icon Login to collaborate or comment, or
 star icon contact private message private message private message a profile manager, or
 star icon ask our community of genealogists a question.
Sponsored Search by Ancestry.com

DNA
No known carriers of Margaretha's ancestors' DNA have taken a DNA test. Have you taken a test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.


Comments: 10

Leave a message for others who see this profile.
There are no comments yet.
Login to post a comment.
The best source based research I have seen, and I've looked pretty hard, indicates that Sarah Ledbetter is not the mother of any of Jacob's children. Jacob married someone in PA named Catherine who is on the baptism record of Jacob Baugher Jr. She is the presumed mother of all of his older children.

In between marriages to Catherine Unknown and Sarah Ledbetter is a third spouse, Margaretha. The presumed mother of Jacob's younger children is Margaretha Unkown.

There does look to be a record of marriage for Sarah Ledbetter to Jacob Baugher based on the above link to the genealogy forum. But it is in 1821 after the birth of Jacob's children. The same source indicates Sarah previously married someone named Louis Ledbetter, and had children with that marriage. Her marriage to Jacob would have been her 2nd marriage, with no issue. Her name at birth was not Ledbetter based on this research. Because it is source based (baptism records in PA for mother Catherine, marriage record in Galatin Illinois in 1821) it does look convincing.

I would like to know what sources indicate Sarah Ledbetter is the mother of Jacob's children. There is nothing on either of Sarah's profiles (Ledbetter-2474 and Ledbetter-56) that indicate this. Thanks

posted on Ledbetter-2474 (merged) by Jared Stiffler
edited by Jared Stiffler
I've been researching this more for the proposed merge. There is a good discussion on a Genealogy Forum https://www.genealogy.com/forum/surnames/topics/baugher/142/

Also, there is a find a grave memorial for a daughter to Jacob Baugher named Susan https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/68689035/susan-goodwin But I think it is wrong. I put in a suggestion for an edit, as the marriage record and death record for her daughter indicate a last name of Boher. Also, her birth in Indiana is very irregular for Jacob Baugher's other children. I don't know of any Indiana residence for Jacob Baugher.

posted on Ledbetter-2474 (merged) by Jared Stiffler
This link might be helpful https://www.genealogy.com/forum/surnames/topics/baugher/139/

It indicates a marriage date and location for Margaretha (1-17-1821 in Gallatin Co IL) to Jacob. It also indicates documented sources for a first marriage exist, and that the children were born to the first spouse, but did not provide any sources.

The same thread contains a more detailed discussion later with better details on Sarah Ledbetter, and a mention of the location of the marriage record https://www.genealogy.com/forum/surnames/topics/baugher/142/

Also this same thread contained an unsourced list of Jacob's children:

"Elizabeth Susan Baugher George William Baugher b Mar 8, 1788 John Jacob Baugher II b. abt 1790 Isaac Joel Baugher b. abt 1800 John Jesse Baugher b Sept 28, 1809 Thomas Elder Baugher b Oct 9, 1810 William Baugher Susan Baugher (possible that she is the same person as Elizabeth Susan Baugher) John Baugher (b. about 1790).Could he be the same person as John Jacob Baugher II?"

No sourcing, but it does include a "Susan." This along with a documented marriage for Sarah Baugher to Samuel Woodside, and a documented marriage for Samuel's brother James Woodside to Susan Baugher, indicate the theory is plausible that Susan is a sister of Sarah Baugher.

Also, I did find a female head of household in 1820 Gallatin census named Sarah Ledbetter. Family Search has her attached to a profile that would make her a 10 year old head of household (something must be off), she's in the 26-45 column I believe. There are also children in the household. I haven't cross referenced with the 1830 Shelby Illinois census yet to see if it looks like a consistent household. (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:XHG3-TQ4)

posted by Jared Stiffler
edited by Jared Stiffler
Ledbetter-2474 and Ledbetter-56 appear to represent the same person because: This rejected match needs an explanation for the rejection. There are problems with both profiles but they are very likely reflecting the same person. It is unlikely that John Jacob Baugher and Margaretta were married in Illinois in 1785. It is also unlikely there are 2 Margaretta Ledbetter's who married someone named Baugher and were both born in 1770. Nancy Baugher is clearly connected to at least 2 of the families that some of John Jacob Baugher's children married into (Woodside and Hamilton).
posted by Jared Stiffler
edited by Jared Stiffler
Ledbetter-2474 and Ledbetter-56 do not represent the same person because: This merge looks nothing like my profile. Too many things missing or not accurate. Please feel free to contact me with more information for a future merge.
posted by Melissa Birkland
Ledbetter-2474 and Ledbetter-56 appear to represent the same person because: Yes I agree with the merger. Thank you
Ledbetter-2474 and Ledbetter-56 do not represent the same person because: I will not agree to this merge. I have no intention of merging Ledbetter and Baugher
posted by Melissa Birkland
There doesn't seem to be any disagreement about Sarah marrying someone with the last name Baugher on either profile, although one uses the AKA title for the name Baugher. The question as best as I can frame it is if Jacob is the father of Susan (Baugher) Woodside. The best source based research I have seen, and I've looked pretty hard, indicates that Sarah Ledbetter is not the mother of any of Jacob's children. Jacob married someone in PA named Catherine who is on the baptism record of Jacob Baugher Jr. She is the presumed mother of all of older children.

In between marriages to Catherine Unknown and Sarah Ledbetter, it is believed he had a spouse with the first name of Margaretha or Margaret. She is considered to be the mother of Jacob's younger children. Since this profile uses the name Margaretha Sarah Ledbetter, it is possible it is a conflation of Jacob's 2nd and 3rd spouses.

There does look to be a record of marriage for Sarah Ledbetter to Jacob Baugher based on the above link to the genealogy forum. But it is in 1821 after the birth of Jacob's children. The same source indicates Sarah previously married someone named Louis Ledbetter, and had children with that marriage. Her marriage to Jacob would have been her 2nd marriage, with no issue. Her name at birth was not Ledbetter based on this research. Because it is source based (baptism records in PA for mother Catherine, marriage record in Galatin Illinois in 1821) it does look convincing.

I would like to know what sources indicate Sarah Ledbetter is the mother of Jacob's children. There is nothing on either profile that indicates this. Thanks

posted by Jared Stiffler
edited by Jared Stiffler
Ledbetter-748 and Ledbetter-56 appear to represent the same person because: Hi. Clear duplicate
Ledbetter-2259 and Ledbetter-748 appear to represent the same person because: Same name, dates, spouse
posted on Ledbetter-748 (merged) by Sandi Strong

Featured Eurovision connections: Margaretha is 33 degrees from Agnetha Fältskog, 24 degrees from Anni-Frid Synni Reuß, 27 degrees from Corry Brokken, 22 degrees from Céline Dion, 26 degrees from Françoise Dorin, 27 degrees from France Gall, 29 degrees from Lulu Kennedy-Cairns, 26 degrees from Lill-Babs Svensson, 22 degrees from Olivia Newton-John, 33 degrees from Henriette Nanette Paërl, 34 degrees from Annie Schmidt and 21 degrees from Moira Kennedy on our single family tree. Login to see how you relate to 33 million family members.

L  >  Ledbetter  |  B  >  Baugher  >  Margaretha Sarah (Ledbetter) Baugher