Mary (Tuthill) Horton (1649 - 1729)

Born 1649 in Southold, Suffolk, New York

Wife of Joshua Horton — married 1665 in Suffolk, Livingston, New York

Descendants

Died 25 Jun 1729 at about age 80 in Southold, Suffolk, New York

Problems/Questions Profile managers: Doug Lockwood [send private message] and Rusty Erpenbeck [send private message]

Biography

Mary Tuthill was the daughter of Henry Tuthill and Bridget (surname unknown).^[1]

Note: this private publication states three daughters of Henry Tuthill the immigrant and wife Bridget without giving any primary or contemporaneous source. These 3 daughters are not supported by Anderson's Great Migration or any other scholarly work on this family (see Tuttle-7 profile for sources). Unless an actual source for the parentage of Mary Tuthill can be found, her parentage should be considered unknown.

Sources

1. ↑ Tuttle - Tuthill Lines in America compiled by Alva M. Tuttle, Tuthill-286 was created by Rusty Erpenbeck through the import of rusty1.GED on Jan 22, 2016.

• Dexter, Franklin Bowditch. Biographical Sketches of the Graduates of Yale College (Holt, 1885) Vol. 1, Page 427.
  • This source states the Joshua Horton/Mary Tuthill marriage without primary source but makes no claim for her parentage.
• Yates Publishing, U.S. and International Marriage Records, 1560-1900 (Provo, UT, USA, The Generations Network, Inc., 2004)

Name: Mary Tuthill

Gender: Female

Birth Place: NY

Birth Year: 1647

Spouse Name: Joshua Horten

Birth Place: NY

Spouse Birth Year: 1643

• Horton Genealogy or Chronicles of the Descendants of Barnabas Horton, of Southold, L. I., 1640 compiled by Geo. F. Horton, M. D. Published by Home Circle Publishing Co., Philadelphia 1876. Page 11: Second Generation — Joshua 1: Joshua, son of Barnabas Horton 1, born at Southold, L. I., in 1643; married, about 1667, Mary Tuthill. In 1673, '76, '78 and '95 he deeds land to various persons. In 1676 he is one of the patentees of Southold, and has six males and five females in his family. He is a Lieutenant in 1693. (See Moore's Indexes of Southold, p. 88) He died in Southold, 1729. His wife died 2 January, 1718. Children, all born in Southold:1. Joshua, ensign, born 1669. 2. Joseph, born 1671; married. 3. Sarah, born 1673; married Richard Terry, son of Richard 1. 4. Mary, born  ; married 2 January, 1708, Zaccheus Goldsmith. 5. Bethia, born  ; married in Jan., 1716, Ichabod Hallock. She died 1753. 6. Keziah or Zerniah, married Israel Cose (Note: Israel Cose crossed out - replaced by what looks like Samuel Case) 7. Ephraim, born 1786; married, in 1707, Martha Vail.https://archive.org/details/hortongenealogyo00hort
  • This publication makes no claim as to Mary's parentage and does not include primary sources
• Tuttle - Tuthill Lines in America compiled by Alva M. Tuttle published 1968 Estel Printing Service, Columbus, Ohio - Alphabetical Listing and then mostly in order by birth year. MARY TUTHILL c. 1649 Southold, L I dau. Henry 1612; d. 25 Jun 1729 age 80; m. c. 1665 Joshua c. 1643; d. 17 Jun 1729 son of Barnabas & Mary (LANGTON) HORTON (LTV - Lotta Tuthill Vail - contributing compiler) (1533) 1. Joshua 1669, d. 1749 Elizabeth, N.J.; 2. Elizabeth; 3. Bethia 1679; 4. Ephraim 1686, d. 1733; 5. Mary 1687; 6. Zerviah, liv. 4 Dec 1753, m. Samuel c. 1687 Southold, d. 10 May 1755 son Henry & Tabitha (Vail) CASE. A Mary c. 1725, m. 7 May 1745 Wm REEVE: a descendant of Edwin BALDWIN, of Summit, NJ 1968 cont (1533). - HENRY TUTHILL bapt. 28 Jun 1612 Tharston, County Norfolk, England son of Henry 1580 & Alice GOOCH; d. c. 165O age 38 Southold, LI ; 1637 had lot in Hingham, Mass. but not known when came over; sold lot Jun 1644 & to Southold where brother John had been some years; m. Bridget __________ ; (she m.(2) Southold, William WELLS & d. soon.) (LTV - Lotta Tuthill Vail - contributing compiler) Children of Henry Tuthill and Bridget: 1. John 16 July 1635; 2. Elizabeth c. 1637; 3. Nathaniel c. 1639; 4. Daniel bapt. 30 Aug 1640 Hingham, Mass.; 5. Sarah c. 1642 d.u. (died unmarried); 6. Ann c. 1648-9, 7. Mary c. 1649. https://dcms.lds.org/delivery/DeliveryManagerServlet?dps_pid=IE96257
  • This publication does not list primary sources and simply states Mary, Ann & Sarah as daughters of Henry the immigrant with no proof. It is contradicted by Anderson's Great Migration Directory, by "The Tuthill Family of Tharston, Norfolk Co., England and Southold, Suffolk Co., New York" ... The Tuthill Family of Tharston: pg. 482 both of which DO list primary sources.