Helen Gordon’s father was who?

Question

Per clanmacfarlanegenealogy helen is ID I42490. The notes say

• 1 - Thomas Fraser of Durris, who m. Helen, dau of Sir Alexander Gordon, of Midmar, 2nd son of George, Earl of Huntly,  4th or 5th Earl?
  2 - Thomas Fraser, 6th of Durris, m. Helen, dau. of James Gordon, [3rd] of Abergeldie and Midmar
  As can be seen above sources differ on the identity of her father.