Do you use Relationship Status and should we expand/improve their use?

+6 votes
1.0k views
Note: Looking for discussion and alternative ideas.

On the edit page of each profile is the option to designate whether a parent is Non-biological, Uncertain, Confident, and Confirmed by DNA.  Once checked, the Uncertain and DNA information appear both on the Profile page and on the Family Tree Page. (and other places too I believe?)

I do not know how the Non-Biological shows, can someone give an example?  My half-brother was raised by my father but I know who his father is so this information appears only in their Bios. Thus I can not add my father as Non-biological.

Recently, I have been re-working my branches through my 3rd Great Grandparents and I was thinking that having this information on the Ancestor List (Ahnentafel Ancestor List) might be useful. I could see how deep my DNA confidence goes by generation or see who is marked Uncertain.   

However, I have noticed that if a profile is marked Confident, nothing appears (space and code considerations I presume) but if nothing is marked, then, like Confident, nothing shows. (I have that right, yes?) This could be confusing in that I can not tell if I am Confident or I have just not marked the box.  This is important to me.  

Knowing that the relationship is Confident means that I have evidence in the Sources showing the relationship.  But if I have just not yet marked the box, I would not know if it is Confident or Just Not Marked. (Again, do I have this right, I see nothing to indicate a difference). Neither show on the Profile or elsewhere.

Perhaps we can include just a check mark? (Like the one on DNA, or some other kind of indicator) This would distinguish it from profiles who have not been marked.

This would allow me to find those profiles that are unmarked and set about determining if I in fact do have evidence to add as a source.

Perhaps this is something found in the Suggestions app (WikiTree+)?

So, to summarize.

1. Should we expand the use of the Relationship Status?  (Add it to the Ancestor List for example)

2. Should we have an identifying Icon for the Confident status to distinguish between Unmarked relationships and Confident relationships.  This would serve as an aid in finding Unmarked relationships for evidence and sourcing evaluations.
in WikiTree Tech by Michael Stills G2G6 Pilot (528k points)
recategorized by Michael Stills

Michael,

Suggestions 452-464 in WikiTree+ include unset relationship status options of various kinds.

See:

https://wikitree.sdms.si/default.htm?report=err6&Query=&MaxErrors=1000&ErrorID=452

But then go to the drop down menu on left and see the other options through 464

Very good, thank you Jillaine.
Jillaine,  What am I doing wrong.

1. In the suggeston box, I choose, 452 Father Status not set.

2. In the Tree section, I enter Stills-18 and set for 8 generations.  I leave it set for all relative types.

3 I press Tree suggestions.

I have 0 suggestions for 8 generations,  I tried 10 as well and have 0.

However, Elijah John Ricker-181 does not have his father status set and he does not show up in the suggestions.  Elijah is 6 generations from me.
Mikael, Ales runs the updated Suggestion report on Monday (unsure what time zone).
Yes, thanks Leigh Anne.

However, the problem is that I profiles that are not showing up in the Suggestions app.  The error has been there some time but the Suggestions app is not finding them.

Isn't it the case that to get Profile Completeness suggestions you need to add your own profile to Category: Suggestions - Include Profile Completeness ?

This is obliquely hinted at here:

https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Help:WikiTree_Plus#Usage_tips_and_improvements

Well hmm...Thanks Jim, we'll give it a try.

Please log in or register to answer this question.

Related questions

+3 votes
1 answer
+7 votes
1 answer
230 views asked Nov 18, 2017 in Policy and Style by Barry Smith G2G6 Pilot (293k points)
+7 votes
4 answers
+13 votes
3 answers
+6 votes
2 answers
139 views asked Sep 15, 2017 in Policy and Style by Lisa Roberts G2G6 Mach 2 (28.5k points)

WikiTree  ~  About  ~  Help Help  ~  Search Person Search  ~  Surname:

disclaimer - terms - copyright

...