no image
Privacy Level: Open (White)

Lucy (Willoughby) Carew (abt. 1330 - bef. 1390)

Lucy Carew formerly Willoughby
Born about in Beddington, Croydon, Surrey, Englandmap
Daughter of and [mother unknown]
[sibling(s) unknown]
Wife of — married 1343 in Englandmap [uncertain]
Wife of — married after 1352 in Beddington, Surrey, Englandmap
Descendants descendants
Died before before about age 60 [location unknown]
Problems/Questions Profile manager: Janet Gunn private message [send private message]
Profile last modified | Created 3 Jan 2011
This page has been accessed 2,728 times.

Biography

In 1345 Richard Willoughby and his wife Elizabeth paid a fine of 100s for purchasing the manor of Beddington without license. They do not appear to have held property in the area before that time. Richard WIlloughby acquired a mill in Beddington in 1347.

Their daughter (and only child), Lucy, married, about 1343, Thomas Huscarl, who held the neighboring manor in Beddington Huscarl, in Surrey, and the manor of Purley Magna, in Berkshire.[1] That year the manor of Purley was vested in Sir Thomas and Lucy and the heirs of their bodies, with contingent remainders to Sir Thomas's son from a previous marriage, John and his heirs.[2]. In 1349 the manor of Beddington Huscarl was settled on Thomas Huscarl, his wife Lucy and their son Thomas in tail male. (Thomas's older son John, had apparently died before 1349). [3] They also appear to have had a daughter Joan.

Lucy was still living with her first husband, Thomas Huscarl in 25 Edward III (1352)[4].

In 1352 Richard Willoughby and Elizabeth leased (for life) the manor of Beddington to Nicholas Carew. After the death of Thomas, his widow Lucy married Nicholas Carew (possibly coincident with the lifetime lease). In 1363 Richard's widow, Elizabeth, converted the manor in fee to Nicholas Carew.

In 1369 the trustees for Thomass Huscarl (son of Thomas and Lucy) remitted their right to Beddington Huscarl to Nicholas Carew. (Does this mean that the younger Thomas had died?) Between then and 1379 several other members of the Huscarl family remitted their interests in Beddington Huscarl to Nicholas Carew. Subsequently the two manors (Beddington and Beddington Huscarl) were merged.

When Nicholas Carew died in 1390, his will mentioned

- Joan Huscarl, a nun, (presumably daughter of Lucy and Thomas Huscarl)
- Margaret Turbevyle (his daughter)
- Lucie, prioress of Roosparre (his daughter).
- Nicholas (his son)

The will makes no mention of his wife, Lucy, so she presumably died before 1390.

Research Notes

Many on line sites say that Lucy Willoughby is the daugher of Richard Willoughby of Wollanton (abt. 1290 - 1362) Justice of the King’s bench, and his third wife, Elizabeth Velletort. But this appears to be false.

The sources cited for Lucy (Willoughby) Carew make it clear that Lucy was the only heir of her father, Richard Willoughby of Beddington.[5]

Willoughby of Wollaton had 7 chidren. His sons, Richard, Thomas, Roger, Hugh, and Edmund Willougby, were his heirs. In addition, his daughters, Mary/Marjory Mallory and Isabel Peche, inherited land from their mother, Isabel Mortein. (No "Lucy" inherited anything from Richard Willougby of Wollaton.)

Furtheremore, Lucy Willoughby can not be the daughter of Elizabeth (Valletort) Willoughby (abt. 1285 - aft. 1363).

Various on-line sites (but without reliable sources) give Elizabeth Valletort's date of birth as 1280, 1282, 1285,1292. Even without a reliable date of birth, she was married 3 times, • to Richard Tremenet, and had a son, also Richard Tremenet before his death before 1316 • by 1316 to Richard Champernoun, and had 4 children, • In 1343 to Richard Willoughby of Wollaton, Nottinghamshire. Even if her marriage to Tremenet was very short, and she married him very young, she would have been in her 50s or 60s when she married Willoughby, so the multiple statements that she had no children by Richard Willoughby of Wollaton are very likely to be true.

Lucy Willoughby married her first husband, and had a child, before 1349. Elizabeth Valletort didn't marry Richard Willoughby of Wollaton until 1343. Any child of Richard WIlloughby of Wollaton and Elizabeth Valletort would have been less than 6 years old in 1349.


Sources

  1. The History and Antiquities of the County of Surrey by Re Owen Manning and Willaim Bray Vol II 1804 pg 522
  2. 'Parishes: Purley', in A History of the County of Berkshire: Volume 3, (London, 1923) pp. 417-422. British History Online https://www.british-history.ac.uk/vch/berks/vol3/pp417-422 [accessed 4 April 2024]]
  3. 'Parishes: Beddington', in A History of the County of Surrey: Volume 4, (London, 1912) pp. 168-178. British History Online https://www.british-history.ac.uk/vch/surrey/vol4/pp168-178 [accessed 4 April 2024]
  4. 'Beddington', in The Environs of London: Volume 1, County of Surrey, (London, 1792) pp. 49-67. British History Online https://www.british-history.ac.uk/london-environs/vol1/pp49-67 [accessed 4 April 2024]
  5. The History and Antiquities of the County of Surrey by Re Owen Manning and Willaim Bray Vol II 1804 pg522




Is Lucy your ancestor? Please don't go away!
 star icon Login to collaborate or comment, or
 star icon contact private message the profile manager, or
 star icon ask our community of genealogists a question.
Sponsored Search by Ancestry.com

DNA
No known carriers of Lucy's DNA have taken a DNA test. Have you taken a test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.


Comments: 7

Leave a message for others who see this profile.
There are no comments yet.
Login to post a comment.
This Lucy Willoughby appears very likely to be the daughter of Sir Richard Willoughby who died 1362 and his third wife, Elizabeth de Valletort, the widow of Sir Richard Champernoun of Modbury, Devon who died 1338. See https://www.nottingham.ac.uk/manuscriptsandspecialcollections/collectionsindepth/family/middleton/biographies/biographyofsirrichardwilloughby%28c1290-1362%29.aspx

This clicked for me when I saw that Elizabeth de Valletort's mother was Lucy/Lucia Brito/Bret. Her father was Hugh de Valletort of Tawton, Devonshire. This Lucy would have, therefore, been born after 1338, so let's say 1339, which works with her son Nicholas being born say 1354-1359. See also https://www.british-history.ac.uk/london-environs/vol1/pp49-67#anchorn6 which makes it clear that the Richard Willoughby acquired the manor Lucy inherited by purchase, supporting that he was from outside that area.

posted by Lisa Paye
NO!

See revised Research Notes for details. But the biggest factor is that Lucy was married, and had a son, by 1349 - Elizabeth Valletort did not marry Richard Willoughby of Wollaton until 1343.

posted by Janet Gunn
Ok the "NO!' is not very friendly and I'm a friendly sort of person. According to Lucy's son Nicholas' profile, his birth is stated as abt "1359." You state 1349 which is not correct. You are probably right and I'm probably wrong, but I am far from am amateur, you know nothing about my expertise, and it would be nice to be welcomed rather than rejected rather rudely out of hand. It is not unreasonable given the time period to posit that a woman born abt 1343 could have given birth to someone born about 1358-1359. Sadly, there are much younger mothers of this and other eras.

One point that you miss is that just because a daughter was called an heir of her father, does not mean she was the only daughter. She could well have been the only daughter - or child - of her mother with that husband. If you have studied the ancient wills as I have - and I have, extensively, you will have to agree with me on at least this.

Also, I did not arrive at my post by consulting "online trees" but rather by consulting actual sources.

posted by Lisa Paye
edited by Lisa Paye
The biography says:

"Their daughter, Lucy, married first, Thomas Huscarl, who held the neighboring manor in Beddington Huscarl. In 1349 the manor was settled on Thomas Huscarl, his wife Lucy and their son Thomas in tail male. "

I have not created profiles for either Thomas Huscarl, because I was focusing on the Carew marriage. But the "husband and son by 1349" is right there in the biography.

“A Topographical History of Surrey”, by E.W. Brayley Volume 4, pg 52 , talking about the manor of Beddington Huscarle, says that “Richard Willoughby had an only daughter, Lucy”.

I did not intend to be rude, but I do not think it is "friendly" to say that I have the wrong parents when you have not carefully read the biography.

posted by Janet Gunn
edited by Janet Gunn
I carefully read the bio, notwithstanding the shade you are attempting to throw - but am suggesting that it needs further consideration in the spirit of collaboration on which WikiTree is based. Perhaps you prefer for the question to be posed on a message board and see if the time line is unrealistic in which case I happily desist.
posted by Lisa Paye
You are welcome to start a G2G on it.

Willoughby-146 was removed as her father 3 years ago.

posted by Janet Gunn

Featured German connections: Lucy is 21 degrees from Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, 27 degrees from Dietrich Bonhoeffer, 25 degrees from Lucas Cranach, 25 degrees from Stefanie Graf, 21 degrees from Wilhelm Grimm, 26 degrees from Fanny Hensel, 28 degrees from Theodor Heuss, 21 degrees from Alexander Mack, 37 degrees from Carl Miele, 17 degrees from Nathan Rothschild, 25 degrees from Hermann Friedrich Albert von Ihering and 20 degrees from Ferdinand von Zeppelin on our single family tree. Login to see how you relate to 33 million family members.

W  >  Willoughby  |  C  >  Carew  >  Lucy (Willoughby) Carew