In the 2013 Royal Ancestry Vol. IV page 671, Richardson states this persons name was Margaret (or Margery) le Gras, daughter of William le Gras. Her maternal grandfather was John Fitz Gilbert, the Master Marshal.[4]
Sources
↑ 1.01.11.21.31.41.51.61.7Royal Ancestry: A Study in Colonial and Medieval Families, by Douglas Richardson, Vol IV, page 39-40 and page 671
↑ Douglas Richardson, Royal Ancestry, Vol. IV, p. 39-40
↑ Douglas Richardson, Royal Ancestry, Vol. III, p. 64-65.
↑ Royal Ancestry 2013 D. Richardson Vol. IV p. 671-674
Is Margaret your relative? Please don't go away! Login to collaborate or comment, or contact
the profile manager, or ask our community of genealogists a question.
Rod Piper, I gave the documentation for the relationships in detail within this profile and on William's profile. In order to change what is presented, we would need to establish new and more credible documentation, i.e. sources. You gave Medlands which is considered reliable, but Richardson reads Medlands and other primary sources. So why would he decide William is the son of William?
It may help to read the following linked message board where experts such as Douglas Richardson discuss the primary source documents for the relationships they establish in their books. It is a Google group for a [Society on Medieval Genealogy https://groups.google.com/g/soc.genealogy.medieval/c/ZPIUJnysSYo/m/RXmUaVC8uZoJ]. The way I read it, there is no correction needed here, as it confirms the data on our profile. Do you see it differently?
Marshal-38 and Gras-53 appear to represent the same person because: As per discussion on G2G and notes on profile of Marshal-38, the LNAB for this profile should be Gras, Marshal-38 had been mistakenly attached to her grandparents as her parents.
I have done all that that can be done to this point, with consensus of all who replied. If anyone disagrees, they have not yet replied.
We are at a standstill until a Leader removes the PPP from this profile, so that John Fitz Gilbert and Sybilla can be removed as parents and 2) Unknown Marshal and William le Gras can be installed as parents, so that 3) this profile can be re-connected to Ralph Somery as his wife and to Ralph Somery (the son), as his mother.
It all checks out with Douglas Richardson's Royal Ancestry (of which I own the set) and the Internet database by Mr Marlyn Lewis - who cites Richardson. See link to his site on this profile. See link to G2G question in my Comment below.
This Margaret's profile is connected to her grandparents instead of her parents. Her LNAB is not Marshal, it is Gras. Please see the G2G question on this. Thank you.
A profile with the correct LNAB and parents is newly created: Margaret Gras.
Please remove the project protection temporarily from this profile, Margaret Marshal-38, and propose a merge of Marshal-38 into Gras-53, to fix the error in the LNAB on this profile.
Featured German connections:
Margaret is
23 degrees from Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, 30 degrees from Dietrich Bonhoeffer, 25 degrees from Lucas Cranach, 28 degrees from Stefanie Graf, 26 degrees from Wilhelm Grimm, 27 degrees from Fanny Hensel, 32 degrees from Theodor Heuss, 24 degrees from Alexander Mack, 40 degrees from Carl Miele, 20 degrees from Nathan Rothschild and 22 degrees from Ferdinand von Zeppelin
on our single family tree.
Login to see how you relate to 33 million family members.
http://fmg.ac/Projects/MedLands/enguntac.htm#MargaretCrassusM1RalphSomery
edited by Rod Piper
It may help to read the following linked message board where experts such as Douglas Richardson discuss the primary source documents for the relationships they establish in their books. It is a Google group for a [Society on Medieval Genealogy https://groups.google.com/g/soc.genealogy.medieval/c/ZPIUJnysSYo/m/RXmUaVC8uZoJ]. The way I read it, there is no correction needed here, as it confirms the data on our profile. Do you see it differently?
edited by April (Dellinger) Dauenhauer
So yes, the security level is "open" but until the "Project Protection" is temporarily lifted, the parents cannot be changed.
It is something only a designated Leader can lift or add. I should have put the question in the Forum instead of here. Thank you Robin for caring!
We are at a standstill until a Leader removes the PPP from this profile, so that John Fitz Gilbert and Sybilla can be removed as parents and 2) Unknown Marshal and William le Gras can be installed as parents, so that 3) this profile can be re-connected to Ralph Somery as his wife and to Ralph Somery (the son), as his mother.
It all checks out with Douglas Richardson's Royal Ancestry (of which I own the set) and the Internet database by Mr Marlyn Lewis - who cites Richardson. See link to his site on this profile. See link to G2G question in my Comment below.
Have you read the G2G thread on this family? It explains a lot.
A profile with the correct LNAB and parents is newly created: Margaret Gras.
Please remove the project protection temporarily from this profile, Margaret Marshal-38, and propose a merge of Marshal-38 into Gras-53, to fix the error in the LNAB on this profile.
Please join the discussion on this change in the G2G Forum at Are John Fitzgerald Marshal and Sybilla Evreux the parents of Margaret (Margery) who married Ralph Somery?
The complete family diagram and sources are there.
For some reason it did not format correctly but it is fixed now.
Thank you for your attention to this necessary fix on this profile.