Is something wrong with Wiki Tree Roll of Honor Free Space Page?

Question

http://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Space:WikiTree_Profiles_Roll_of_Honor

I tried to leave a comment today (14 Aug 2016) on the Roll of Honor Free Space Page but it seems that the ability to leave a comment has been disabled. Was this intentional?

In addition, I have added several profiles to Wiki Tree that deserve to be on the Roll of Honor because they were either KIA, WIA, and/or received the MOH, Silver Star, or Distinguished Flying Cross. I made my request in June via the comments on the Roll of Honor Free Space Page and these profiles still have not been added to the Roll of Honor Free Space Page (they all have Wiki Tree Profiles with Sources). However, someone made a request after my request and those profiles were added but the ones I requested were not added.

So, please add the following profiles to the Wiki Tree Roll of Honor Free Space Page (or unlock the Free Space Page so that those of us willing to add to the list can or add me [[Guerra-340]] to the trusted list so that I can add profiles):

These are the men that need to be added alphabetized by last surname

|[[Adams-25005|Adams]]||Lucian||26 Oct 1922||31 Mar 2003||WW II||Army||

|[[Anderson-24748|Anderson]]||Lance Corporal Richard Allen||16 Apr 1948||24 Aug 1969||Vietnam||USMC

|[[Austin-|Austin]]||Private First Class Oscar Palmer||15 Jan 1949||23 Feb 1969||Vietnam||USMC 22 Apr 1968-23 Feb. 1969

|[[Barkley-912|Barkley]]| Private David B. ||31 Mar 1899||9 Nov 1918||World War I||Army||

|[[Benavidez-27|Benavidez]]|| Roy Perez||5 Aug 1935||29 Nov 1998||Vietnam||Army||||WIAx5, MOH, PH x5

|[[Bordelon-204|Bordelon]]||Staff Sgt William James||25 Dec 1920||20 Nov 1943||WW II||USMC||Netherlands, OMG

|[[Cano-105||Cano]]||Pedro Cano||July 7, 1920||June 24, 1952||WW I||Army|| WIA, MOH

|[[Carswell-317|Carswell]]||Major Horace "Stump" Carswell

|[[Castañeda Peña-1|Castañeda Peña]]||Mike||6 Nov 1924||5 Sep 1950||Korean War||Army||PH x3 before KIA, MOH

|[[Cole-10722|Cole]]||Lt Col Robert George||19 Mar 1915||18 Sep 1944||WW II||Army||

|[[Creek-168|Creek]]||Lance Corporal Thomas Elbert||7 Apr 1950||13 Feb 1969||Vietnam||USMC

|[[Davis-8073|Davis]]||Major George Andrew||1 Dec 1920||10 Feb 1952||Korean War||USAF

|[[Dealey-5|Dealey]]|| Cmd Samuel David||13 Sep 1906||24 Aug 1944||WW II||Navy

|[[Edwards-13393|Edwards]]|| Maj. Daniel Richmond||9 Apr 1897||21 Oct 1967||Great War||Army

|[[Erevia-1|Erevia]]| Santiago Jesus||15 Dec 1946||22 Mar 2016||Vietnam||Army

|[[Fields-2790|Fields]]||Capt. James H.||16 Jun 1920||17 Jun 1970||WW II||Army

|[[Fowler-5983|Fowler]]||2nd Lt Thomas Weldon||31 Oct 1921||3 Jun 1944||WW II||Army|| Carano, Italy

|[[Garcia-2872|Garcia]]||Candelario||26 Feb 1944||10 Jan 2013||Vietnam||Army||WIA, MOH,SSM, BSM, PH,

|[[Garcia-2862 |Garcia]]||CSM Macario]||20 Jan 1920||24 Dec 1972||WW II||Army||WIA, MOH, BSM, PH

|[[Gomez-927|Gomez]]||Sgt Miguel Ramirez||29 Sep 1921||24 Jun 1945||WW 2||KIA (Tokashiki Island, Kerama Retto Islands, Pacific)

|[[Gonzalez-2223|Gonzalez]]||Sgt Alfredo "Freddy" Cantu||23 May 1946||4 Feb 1968||Vietnam||USMC 1965-68 KIA, MOH, PH

|[[Guillen-69 |Guillen]]|| Ambrosio||7 Dec 1929||25 Jul 1953||Korean War||USMC||, KIA, MOH

|[[Hanson-3545 |Hanson]]|| Jack Glennon||18 Sep 1930||7 Jun 1951||Korean War||Army||KIA, MOH

|[[Harrell-1757|Harrell]]||William George||16 Jun 1922||9 Aug 1964||WW II||USMC||WIA, MOH, PH

|[[Harris-20478 |Harris]]||Second Lieutenant James Lindell||27 Jun 1916||7 Oct 1944||WW II||Army||KIA, MOH

|[[Harrison-9761|Harrison]]||Comm. William Kelly||30 Jul 1870||15 Aug 1928||Mexican Campaign (Veracruz)||Navy||MOH, PH

|[[Hawkins-5952|Hawkins]]||First Lieutenant William Deane||18 Apr 1914||21 Nov 1943||WW II||USMC||KIA, MOH, PH, Tarawa

|[[Hayden-2086|Hayden]]|| David Ephraim||2 Oct 1897||18 Mar 1974||Great War||Navy||MOH, SSM

|[[Hughes-3348|Hughes, Jr.]]||2nd Lt Lloyd Herbert||12 Jul 1921||1 Aug 1943||WW II||Army AC||KIA, MOH, PH, Campina, Romania

|[[Hutchins-1933|Hutchins]]||Seaman First Class Johnnie David||4 Aug 1922||4 Sep 1943||WW II||Navy R||KIA, MOH, PH

|[[Kearby-18|Kearby]]|| Colonel Neel Ernest||5 Jun 1911||5 Mar 1944||WW II||Army AC||KIA, MOH,

|[[Keathley-52|Keathley]]||Staff Sergeant George Dennis||10 Mar 1917||14 Sep 1944||WW II||Army||KIA, MOH, BSM, PH, Mount Altuzzo, Italy

|[[Kilmer-338|Kilmer]]||John Edward||15 Aug 1930||13 Aug 1952||Korean War||Navy||KIA, MOH
 

|[[Kimbro-79|Kimbro]]||Technician Fourth Grade Truman||27 May 1919||19 Dec 1944||WW II||Army||KIA, MOH, PH

|[[Knight-7728|Knight]]||Lieutenant Jack Llewellyn||29 May 1917||2 Feb 1945||WW II||Army||KIA, MOH, LoiKang, Burma

|[[Knight-7729|Knight]]||First Lieutenant Raymond Larry||15 Jun 1922||25 Apr 1945||WW II||Army AC||WIAx2, KIA, MOH,PHx2

|[[Lee-16321|Lee]]||PFC Milton Arthur||28 Feb 1949||26 Apr 1968||Vietnam||Army||KIA, MOH

|[[Leonard-7269|Leonard]]||First Lieutenant Turney White||18 Jun 1921||6 Nov 1944||WW II||Army||KIA, MOH, Germany

|[[Logan-2524|Logan]]||James Marion||19 Dec 1920||9 Oct 1999||WW II||Army||WIA, MOH, PH

|[[Lopez-1928|Lopez Mendoza]]||Jose "Kid" Mendoza||10 Jul 1910||16 May 2005||WW II||Army|WIA, MOH, PH

|[[Lummus-166|Lummus]]||First Lieutenant Andrew Jackson||22 Oct 1915||8 Mar 1945||WW II||USMC-R||KIA, MOH, PH

|[[Martinez-2163|Martinez]]||Benito||21 Apr 1932||6 Sep 1952||Korean War||Army||KIA, MOH

|[[Mathis-1337|Mathis]]||First Lieutenant Jack Warren||25 Sep 1921||18 Mar 1943||WW II||Army AC||KIA, MOH, PH, Vegesack, Germany

|[[McCleery-106|McCleery]]||Sergeant Finnis Dawson||25 Dec 1927||11 Jul 2002||Vietnam||Army||WIA, MOH, SSM, BSM w/valor, PHw/2 oakleaf clusters

|[[Mitchell-13557|Mitchell]]||Frank Nicias||18 Aug 1921||26 Nov 1950||Korean War||USMC||KIA, MOH, SSM w/v,  BSM, PHx2

|[[Moreland-789|Moreland]]|| Whitt Lloyd||7 Mar 1930||29 May 1951||Korean War||USMC||KIA, MOH

|[[O'Brien-3795|O'Brien]]||George Herman||10 Sep 1926||11 Mar 2005||Korean War||USMC|KIA, MOH, PHx2

|[[Pendleton-1268|Pendleton]]||Corporal Charles Frank||26 Sep 1931||||Korean War||Army||KIA, MOH, PH

|[[Roan-94|Roan]]||Private First Class Charles Howard||16 Aug 1923||18 Sep 1944||WW II||USMC-R|KIA, MOH, PH

|[[Robinson-17821|Robinson, Jr.]]||First Lieutenant James E.||10 Jul 1918||6 Apr 1945||WW II||Army||KIA, MOH, PH

|[[Rodriguez-2145|Rodriguez]]||Cleto L.||26 Apr 1923||7 Dec 1990||WW II||Army||WIA, MOH, BSM x2,  PH

|[[Steindam-9|Steindam]]||1st Lt Russell Albert||27 Aug 1946||1 Feb 1970||Vietnam||Army 1968-70||KIA, MOH, PH

|[[Stone-9465|Stone]]||Col. James Lamar||27 Dec 1922||9 Nov 2012||Korean War||Army||WIA, MOH, SSM, BSM, PH

|[[Wallace-8067|Wallace]]||PFC Herman C.||12 Jun 1924||27 Feb 1945||WW II||Army||KIA, MOH, PH, Germany

|[[Watkins-4768|Watkins]]|| Travis Earl||5 Sep 1920||3 Sep 1950||Korean War||Army||KIA, MOH, BSM, PH

|[[Whiteley-319|Whiteley]]|| Capt. Eli Lamar||10 Dec 1913||2 Dec 1986||WW II||Army WIA, MOH, PH

|[[Wilson-34554|Wilson]]|| Private First Class Alfred Mac||13 Jan 1948||3 Mar 1969||Vietnam||USMC 1967-69||WIA, KIA, MOH, PH

|[[Young-19128|Young]]||Staff Sergeant Marvin Rex||11 May 1947||21 Aug 1968||Vietnam||Army 1966-68||KIA, MOH, PH
 

 

 

Answer 1

Hello Kirsty you should be able to leave a message on the Roll of Honor page that hasn't been disabled, there is no way to do that, plus that is not something we would do. We have removed the table from the main Roll of Honor page so now we only add the profiles to the KIA, POW, MIA,  WIA and all the medal pages. All these pages are open and you can find the links to each page at the top of the Roll of Honor page.

We made sure all the profiles that were on the Roll of Honor table were added to the correct pages before we removed it. We think all these profiles deserve to be on the Roll of Honor, but the way the pages were set up we were duplicating the profiles, plus the table was getting far to long Terry

Comments

Thank you. Sometimes technology is not so great.

As far as the list above, I added all the KIA and MOH Recipients to their appropriate pages. I did not add the ones who were WIA to the WIA page but if they received the MOH they are on that page. Adding WIAs is on my "To-Do" list if it has not been done.

Starting next week, I intend to add some KIA for the various Spanish Wars (and their opponents/combatants) to KIA Free Space. I do have some questions about some people and what list if any they should go on. For example, Moctezuma II ("Commander", "King" of the Aztecs), Wikipedia states he was KIA; Aztec history states the Spaniards killed him; the Spaniards state he was killed by projectiles that his own people threw at him. Technically, he was a POW in his own "camp".

Next, the Spanish Conquest of Peru (and part of the Inca Empire)...warning it is kind of messy...

Francisco Pizarro, his brothers (all but one were KIA/Murdered/Assassinated/Executed), Diego Almagro (the elder), Diego Almagro (the younger),  Atahualpa, and Túpac Amaru were KIA/Executed.

Atahualpa was arrested and put on trial found guilty and executed all in the same day (or a few days - does not really give elapsed time) and as a POW. Diego Almagro (the elder) and Pizarro had a disagreement and became enemies. 1536 – Gonzalo Pizarro steals Manco Inca's wife, Cura Olcollo. Manco rebels and surrounds Cuzco. Juan Pizarro is killed, and Inca general Quizo Yupanqui attacks Lima

1538 – Hernando Pizarro executes Diego de Almagro (the elder)

1539 – Gonzalo Pizarro invades and sacks Vilcabamba; Manco Inca escapes but Francisco Pizarro executes Manco's wife, Cura Olcollo (civilian casualty?)

1541 – Francisco Pizarro (and his half-brother Francisco Alacazar) are murdered/assassinated during an attack/battle by Diego de Almagro II and other supporters of Almagro

1544 – Manco Inca is murdered by supporters of Diego de Almagro.

1572 – Viceroy of Peru, Francisco Toledo, declares war on the Neo-Inca State; Vilcabamba is sacked and Túpac Amaru, the last Inca emperor, is captured and executed in Cuzco

 

---

Hello Kirsty I have ask Terri the leader of the Roll of Honor which pages your profiles should be added to. As soon as I find out I will let you know. It looks like you have done lots of research  on your Roll of Honor profiles.Thank you for adding your profiles to our project Terry