no image
Privacy Level: Open (White)

Anne (Baldridge) Butler (abt. 1625 - 1732)

Anne Butler formerly Baldridge aka Baynham
Born about in Englandmap
Ancestors ancestors
Wife of — married about 1646 in Marylandmap
Wife of — married before 2 Nov 1662 in Westmoreland, Virginiamap
Descendants descendants
Died at about age 107 in Westmoreland, Virginiamap
Profile last modified | Created 7 Sep 2011
This page has been accessed 3,229 times.
NOTE 1: In researching the Butler family, I have come across a substantial number of individuals who claim that the Anne Baldridge, who was married to (1) Alexander Baynham, and (2) Thomas Butler II, is the same person as the Jane (MNU) who was Thomas Butler’s wife at the time of his death. This is not correct and will be proven below.
The Birth Date is a rough estimate. See the text for details.

Biography

Cross of St George
Anne (Baldridge) Butler was born in England.
Flag of Virginia
Anne (Baldridge) Butler lived in Virginia.

Anne Baldridge, the daughter of James and Dorothy Baldridge, was probably born in England between 1625 and 1629.[1][2][3][4] She was married about 1646/47 to a man named Capt. Alexander Baynham.[5][6][7][8] Alexander, who had also been born in England, is believed to have been transported into the Colony of Maryland by one of the Baldridge brothers, probably Thomas, as a servant.[9] This is confirmed by a demand from Thomas Baldridge on 1 Nov 1642 for pay for his servant, Alexander Banum [sic], for service during an expedition against the Indians that ended on 13 Oct 1642.[10]

Although the actual place where Alexander Baynham and Anne Baldridge were married is not known, the first document to have been uncovered that substantiates their marriage was found in the publication Barbados Records: Wills and Administrations, 1639-1680. Under the date 10 Aug 1648, "Alex. Baynham" and "Ann X Baynham" witnessed the will of a Mr. Andrew Sanders. [4] Thomas Baldridge of Barbados wrote to his cousins Thomas and James Baldridge of Virginia on 9 Sep 1649, "Elexand [Alexander] and his child are well, but he has sent me word today that his wife is ill."[11] Alex and Anne later settled in that portion of Northumberland County, Virginia that was formed into Westmoreland County, Virginia in 1653.[12]

According to the publication Virginia Colonial Abstracts, 1632-1810 by Beverly Fleet, further proof that Alexander Baynham was married to Ann Baldridge is found under the date 20 Feb 1650/51 when Alexander Baynham received a land grant of 150 acres for transporting himself, his wife Anne, and son Alexander.

Children:

  1. Alexander Baynham, b. bef. 9 Sep 1649.
  2. Anne Baynham, b. aft. 1650; d. 1732; m. 1) abt. 1667, John Butler; m. 2) bef. 2 May 1688, Alexander Webster; m. 3) Aft. 1703, Joseph Bailey.
  3. Elizabeth Baynham, b. aft. 1650
  4. Mary Baynham, b. aft. 1650

Shortly after Westmoreland County was formed, Alexander Baynham was appointed its first High Sheriff on 3 April 1653.[13] He later served as a Burgess from Westmoreland County, Virginia in 1654, and as a Justice and as a Captain of the militia for Westmoreland, County in 1655.[14] Alexander apparently died in Westmoreland County, Virginia, although the actual date of his death is not known.

Although no marriage record has been found for Thomas Butler, II, and the widow, Anne (Baldridge) Baynham, it is believed that it probably took place about 1660/61.[15][5] This is based on the fact that Thomas Butler, II was not mentioned in the will of James Baldridge which was written on 26 Novr 1658 and probated on 10 Jan 1659/60, but he did sign as a witness. However, he and his son Joshua Butler were mentioned in the will of Anne's mother Dorothy Baldridge which was written on 2 Nov 1662 and probated on 11 March 1662/63. She also mentions the three surviving daughters of Alexander Baynham and Anne.

"Joshua son of Thomas Butler... son in law Thomas Butler to be exr."

When Anne (Baldridge) Baynham Butler died is not known. What is known, is that a woman named Jane was the wife of Thomas Butler when he died in 1678, as she was appointed Administratrix of his estate on 27 Feb 1677/78.[16] Jane was apparently a third wife of Thomas as neither she nor Anne were the mother of Joshua, which is substantiated by Dorothy Baldridge's will.

Sources

  1. Letter of Thomas Baldridge of Barbados written in 1649 mentions Alexander, Anne and their child. "Westmoreland General Records Book I". In Fleet, Beverly. Colonial Virginia Abstracts, Vol. I. p. 656.
  2. The Ark and The Dove. by USGenNet.org Patrons Rhoda Fone & Carole Hammett, 2001.
  3. Newman, Harry Wright. The Flowering of the Maryland Palatinate. Washington, D.C.: the Author ( 1961). pp. 339-343.
    James Baldridge, Gent. Transported. No proof of entry.
  4. 4.0 4.1 Sanders, Joanne McRee, comp.. Barbados Records: Wills and Administrations, 1639-1680, Vol. 1, p. 316. Also Caribbean, English Settlers in Barbados, 1637-1800. (familysearch.org/Ancester.com).
  5. 5.0 5.1 "Will of Dorothy Baldridge." Fothergill, Augusta Bridgland. Wills of Westmoreland County, Virginia, 1654-1800. Richmond, VA: Appeals Press (1925). p. 6.
  6. 1658-1758 Charles County, Maryland Families. "The first 100 years." Compiled by Mike Marshall. Genealogy of the Marshall Family. (Includes Some Documents Pertaining to Northern Neck Virginia Families). http://wc.rootsweb.ancestry.com. Rootsweb has been swallowed by Ancestry.com and this source can no longer be accessed.
  7. Fleet, Beverly. Virginia, Colonial Abstracts, 1632-1810, Vol. I. Reprint. Baltimore, MD: Genealogical Publishing Company (1988). NORTHUMBRIA COLLECTANEA 1645-1720, M to Z. (Originally published as Volume 20 of Virginia Colonial Abstracts). p. 637.
    ”Baineham, Alex: Certif for 150 acres for importing ‘Himselfe, Anne his wife, Alexand’r Baineham.’” 20 Feb 1650/1. 1.49.
  8. Genealogical information regarding “William A. Hagey - Berryman Archive, Richmond Virginia. Information posted on 6 July 1999 by William Deyo. Genealogy.com.
  9. ”Alexander Baynham (c1620-c1660) of Maryland and Virginia.” Bob’s Genealogy Filing Cabinet of Southern and Colonial Genealogies.
  10. Ibid. Citing: Archives of Maryland, Vol 3. p. 119.
  11. "Westmoreland General Records Book I". In Fleet, Beverly. Colonial Virginia Abstracts, Vol. I. p. 656.
  12. The Handy Book for Genealogists. 8th Edition. Logan, Utah: The Everton Publishers, Inc., 1995. NOTE: This reference is for the formation of Westmoreland County only.
  13. Fleet, Beverly. Virginia, Colonial Abstracts, 1632-1810, Vol I. Reprint. Baltimore, MD: Genealogical Publishing Company (1980). p. 659.
  14. Tyler, Lyon Gardiner, ed. Encyclopedia of Virginia Biography, Vol. I. New York, NY: Lewis Historical Publishing Company (1915). p. 183.
  15. “Will of James Baldridge.” Fothergill, p. 4.
  16. Westmoreland County, Virginia Court Orders, 1675-1689. Utah: Filmed by the Genealogical Society of Utah at the Virginia State library in Richmond, VA (1947) p. 105. NOTE: It is almost impossible to make out the faded writing and shorthand on this page. Available at FamilySearch.

Acknowledgements

  • Thank you to Dennis Pfiester, for his firsthand knowledge.
  • WikiTree profile Baldridge-36 created through the import of Family Nov 2011.GED on Sep 6, 2011 by Jim Tarbet.
  • WikiTree profile Baldridge-56 created through the import of grover.ged on Jan 27, 2012 by Rhonda Shuck.
  • WikiTree profile Baldridge-74 created through the import of gedcom for wikitree.ged on Dec 23, 2012 by Kelly Midura
  • Thank you to Timothy Wells for creating WikiTree profile Baldridge-76 through the import of My-Family-6-Feb-2013.ged on Feb 6, 2013.




Is Anne your ancestor? Please don't go away!
 star icon Login to collaborate or comment, or
 star icon contact private message private message private message private message a profile manager, or
 star icon ask our community of genealogists a question.
Sponsored Search by Ancestry.com

DNA Connections
It may be possible to confirm family relationships with Anne by comparing test results with other carriers of her mitochondrial DNA. However, there are no known mtDNA test-takers in her direct maternal line. It is likely that these autosomal DNA test-takers will share some percentage of DNA with Anne:

Have you taken a DNA test? If so, login to add it. If not, see our friends at Ancestry DNA.



Comments: 34

Leave a message for others who see this profile.
There are no comments yet.
Login to post a comment.
Baynham-291 and Baldridge-36 appear to represent the same person because: You have the maiden name incorrect. Ann is a BALDRIDGE, widow of Alexander BAYNHAM
posted by Robin White
Ann is widow of Alexander BAYNHAM
posted on Baynham-291 (merged) by Robin White
Does anyone have this record mentioned under RESEARCH in this profile: WESTMORELAND COUNTY, VIRGINIA ORDER BOOK 1684-1685; pg. 57 names James as Jane's father (cf. Extracts from Legal Documents)
posted by Robin White
Not sure if this is the record discussed above:

1684-1685 Westmoreland Co VA Order Book; Page 57 [2 Dec. 1685] Charles Porter assignee of Mrs. Jane Butler, deceased, vs. Capt. John Lord. The defendant nonsuites the plaintiff.

This Jane is deceased.

posted by Robin White
Baldridge-689 and Baldridge-36 do not represent the same person because: It is quite explicit in Jane’s profile that she married Anne’s spouse after Anne died: “After Jane's sister Anne's death, Anne's widower, Alexander Baynham married Jane.”

Ergo, these are two separate people. Therefore, these are set as a Rejected Match.

Baldridge-689 and Baldridge-36 appear to represent the same person because: Same person
posted by Robin White
Baldridge-689 and Baldridge-36 appear to represent the same person because: I believe these two women should be merged into Ann BALDRIDGE. The will of Anne's mother does not name a daughter, Jane.
posted by Robin White
Is there any source for Jane's marriage to Francis Thornton? Francis Thornton (1651-1726) was married to a different Jane, who also happened to be a widow of a John Harvey.
Unknown-254749 and Baldridge-36 do not represent the same person because: These are two different woman. Baldrige-36 was married to someone else when Jane was already married to John Harvey.
posted by Ric Tobin
Baldridge-36 and Baldridge-689 do not represent the same person because: Believe to be two different women
posted on Baldridge-689 (merged) by Robin White
Baldridge-36 and Baldridge-689 appear to represent the same person because: Same parents, same birth date, same spouses.
posted on Baldridge-689 (merged) by Gudula (Retz-Schmidt) Suskin
edited by Gudula (Retz-Schmidt) Suskin
[Comment Deleted]
posted on Baldridge-689 (merged) by Robin White
deleted by Robin White
I agree. Would you initiate a merge?
posted on Baldridge-689 (merged) by Gudula (Retz-Schmidt) Suskin
The only thing I know is they married before her mother's will was written on 2 Nov 1662
posted on Baldridge-689 (merged) by Robin White
Bill Hagey and I corresponded for many years and, hopefully, that correspondence is preserved in his files. We solved many mysteries in the Butler family together. His discovery of the maiden name of Sarah (Butler) Berryman came after correspondence with me on the subject. I had identified that it was Benjamin Berryman's daughter, Elizabeth, named as "Elizabeth Cox" in the will of Ann Bayly. I had given this information to my dear friend, Richie Mae Jarrett, now deceased, who had passed it on to Bill Hagey, who then contacted me. I had theorized from circustantial evidence that Sarah was a Miss Butler, but did not have proof. Bill Hagey soon found the proof in the records of Stafford County abstracted by Sam and Ruth Sparacio, which stated that Ann Webster had previously been married to John Butler. I descend from Vincent Cox, son of Elizabeth (Berryman) Newton Cox, above. I also have several descents from the Butler family. I descend from Thomas Butler and his second wife, Ann (Baldridge) Baynham, widow of Alexander Baynham. You have an error in identification of Anne Baynham's parents. Her mother was not Jane Baldridge. I discovered that Alexander Baynham's wife was Ann, not Jane, from the immigration account in the Northumberland County, VA, records. Bill Hagey took this further to discover some of the true connections of the woman thought to have been Jane Baldridge. I later found even more earlier marriages for her, as I will explain. Alexander Baynham married Ann Baldridge. They had a son, Alexander (from the Northumberland records, who apparently did not survive) and three daughters, including Anne Baynham, who married (1) John, (2) Alexander Webster, and (3) Joseph Bayly. When Alexander Baynham died, his widow, Ann, nee Baldridge, married Thomas Butler. Thomas Butler had first been married to woman who appears to have been a relative of Philip Thomas and William Booth. From a process of elimination, it was by this first wife that Thomas had John Butler who was the first husband of Anne Baynham. John Bulter and Anne Baynham would have been stepbrother and sister, but no blood relation. After the death of his second wife, Ann (Baldridge) Baynham Butler, Thomas Butler married a third time to Jane, the widow of Henry Brooks and previously the widow of David Wickliffe. It is my theory, that this Jane was the sister of Thomas Butler's first wife (note the connections to Philip Thomas and William Booth in regard to Jane's family by Henry Brooks; Benjamin Berryman and Nathaniel Pope were involved in the estate of Philip Thomas in right of their wives who were his legatees). Caleb Butler (whose daughter, Jane, married Augustine Washington, father of President George Washington) called Ann [Ann (Baynham) Butler Webster Bayly], wife of Joseph Bayley, his sister. I am not sure if Caleb was a son of Thomas Butler by the first or second wife, but either way, Ann could have been called "sister". She would have been his half-sister if Caleb's mother was Ann (Baldridge) Baynham Butler or his step-sister if Caleb's mother was Thomas Butler's first wife. Anyway, after the death of Thomas Butler, his widow, Jane, married, as her 4th husband, John Berryman, who was the father of Benjamin Berryman by a former marriage to, traditiionally, Jane Tucker. After the death of John Berryman, Jane married (5) John Harvey and later (6) Francis Thornton. All of this would be in Bill Hagey's genealogical correspondence with me. I hope this helps to clarify some of the confusion over the multiple marriages of these people.

Correspondence from Bill Deyo from Genealogy.com [1]:

posted by Robin White
edited by Robin White
2 Nov 1662, her mother, Dorothy Baldridge, in her will, lists her three Baynham grandchildren, Elizabeth, Anne and Mary.

She makes her son-in-law, Thomas Butler her executor, and leaves a legacy to her grandson Joshua Butler. (Westmoreland Wiil Book I, p. 188.) Therefore, Anne married before this date.

posted on Baldridge-689 (merged) by Robin White
Is there any source for Ann's marriage to Thomas Butler II?

Gudula

posted on Baldridge-689 (merged) by Gudula (Retz-Schmidt) Suskin
In the biography, there is some contradictory information as to whether her father was James Baldridge (Baldridge-77) or Joseph Baldridge (Baldridge-37).

Gudula

TY for the insight. Would you please make the necessary corrections?
posted by Dennis Pfiester
I don't have sufficient information to make a decision. So I left a Research Note. Can anyone help?
posted by Gudula (Retz-Schmidt) Suskin
edited by Gudula (Retz-Schmidt) Suskin
Hello: At this link https://www.colonial-settlers-md-va.us/getperson.php?personID=I050049&tree=tree1 there are only two brothers-- James and Thomas Baldridge--and their respective records make no mention of a Joseph. However, there is the possibility that the source referenced in the bio that gives us the name of 'Joseph' erred in a simple switch in names, because there is a St. Joseph's manor that figures largely in the history of these Baldridge brothers. http://www.milaminvirginia.com/Links/RUSH/First_Settlers_of_the_Northern_Neck_of_Virginia.html It's just a thought. Like you, I can find no evidence of a Joseph in the history of these brothers (and their wives). But clearly there are records, or traditions, that link James with Dorothy.
posted by Rebecca Rose
Another possibility is that I'm finding that Ann and Jane are often confused with each other in family trees. Ann married Joseph (Bayley?) This could be another reason for the creation of a 'Joseph' Baldridge, who does not seem to exist. Also, I found two James Baldridge profiles, initiated a merge.
posted by Rebecca Rose
Jane supposedly was the daughter of Joseph Baldridge, and Ann supposedly was the daughter of James Baldridge. I have been wondering myself, if Ann Baldridge and Jane Baldridge might be the same person. That could explain why they were both married to Alexander Baynham as well as to Thomas Butler II, for which I can't find any other explanation.
Baldridge-356 and Baldridge-36 appear to represent the same person because: Spouse/family the same. Sorry to have made a duplicate, the checker didn't pick up the name I entered.
posted by Thomas McGurk
TY for the insight. Would you please make the necessary corrections?
posted by Dennis Pfiester
Baldridge-65 and Baldridge-36 appear to represent the same person because: Hello! I believe these two profiles are for the same person. Please merge if you agree. Thanks!
TY for the insight. Would you please make the necessary corrections?
posted by Dennis Pfiester
Baldridge-36 and Baldridge-327 appear to represent the same person because: Duplicate
posted by Topher Sims
Baldridge-76 and Baldridge-36 appear to represent the same person because: Same person
posted by Kelly Greenup
TY for the insight. Would you please make the necessary corrections?
posted by Dennis Pfiester
Baldridge-112 and Baldridge-36 appear to represent the same person because: Hello! These two profiles appear to be for the same person. Could you take a look at them, and if you agree they are the same, complete the merge?

Thank you, Lynden Raber Rodriguez

TY for the insight. Would you please make the necessary corrections?
posted by Dennis Pfiester
Baldridge-56 and Baldridge-36 appear to represent the same person because: Hello! I think these two profiles are for the same person. They appeared together on a descendancy page as two separate wives. So, that is the reason I believe they are the same. Could you take a look, and if you also agree, complete the merge?

Thank you, Lynden Raber Rodriguez

TY for the insight. Would you please make the necessary corrections?
posted by Dennis Pfiester

B  >  Baldridge  |  B  >  Butler  >  Anne (Baldridge) Butler

Categories: Estimated Birth Date