Tommy, you wrote "I would like to show you one example when adding register district on locations birth or death make no sense. This woman's death, Elizabeth Henrietta Price, was registered in Southampton. Meanwhile she died in the wreck of ship Hilda in Saint Malo, France. I checked the distance, it is more then 307 km.
For this reason I claim that the place of registration is not the same as the place of birth or death. I suppose, too, if somebody die in a car accident 200 miles from home his family will register it in own district not in district of accident."
Tommy, you really need to learn about how deaths are registered in England if you continue to create English profiles. The bodies of Edith Price and her husband were recovered from the sea and taken to Southampton, the nearest English port. There they had a Coroner's inquest and the Coroner issued the death certificates with the details of how they were drowned when the SS Hilda was wrecked at St Malo. This is why they had their death certificates issued at Southampton (from the contemporary newspaper reports which are easily found online). It is rude to say that "registration districts make no sense" when you don't bother to work out why the registration happened where it did. And from the death registration you can pin-point the place of death if you investigate.
You are incorrect with your second assumption. A death within the land mass of the UK is registered in the Registration District in which the event occurred. My uncle had his death recorded at the football match he was attending some 15 miles from where he lived. The same ruling applies to births and marriages.
Your answer confirms what I claim. A registration place isn't birth/marriage/death place. So, if I would like to be reliable I should add county as birth place because adding registration town is misleading. Maybe I'm wrong but in my opinion adding West Sussex is safer than Worthing
Greetings! Are you aware Wikitree has a Poland Project? Check out our page to see what we are doing in Wikitree, how you can help and utilize the Project: Poland/Resource Library to see what information is out there to help you in your research.
If you are new to Wikitree and are having a difficult time getting started, check out a Welcome to Wikitree page which will help you with the basics of Wikitree.
If you are interested in becoming a member, simply pick a team that interests you from the following page: Space:Poland,_Volunteer_Tasks and let us know by replying to this comment. The only requirements for ongoing membership in the Poland Project are that you join a team and respond to the periodic check-ins from the Project Leaders/Coordinators. We recognize that people lead busy lives and are grateful for any and all contributions you can make. Once you have joined a team, please join the Poland Project Google Group to receive project updates and participate in project and team discussions. You can also follow Project news via the tags 'Poland_Europe' or 'Polish_Roots' or 'Polska' on G2G.
The Poland Project is very busy categorizing villages in Poland. If we have created a village category for you, please help us by adding it across other profiles you manage, where applicable. You can also assist us by finding and adding it to other Wikitree profiles from the same village through the Find link at the top right of your page. Scroll to the bottom, "Search for Any Text". Categorizing = connecting users or profiles. We appreciate any help you have to offer!
Any little contributions you can make is greaty appreciated! Do you want me to add you under the Cemetery Team (you already made one cemetery successfully!)
For this reason I claim that the place of registration is not the same as the place of birth or death. I suppose, too, if somebody die in a car accident 200 miles from home his family will register it in own district not in district of accident."
Tommy, you really need to learn about how deaths are registered in England if you continue to create English profiles. The bodies of Edith Price and her husband were recovered from the sea and taken to Southampton, the nearest English port. There they had a Coroner's inquest and the Coroner issued the death certificates with the details of how they were drowned when the SS Hilda was wrecked at St Malo. This is why they had their death certificates issued at Southampton (from the contemporary newspaper reports which are easily found online). It is rude to say that "registration districts make no sense" when you don't bother to work out why the registration happened where it did. And from the death registration you can pin-point the place of death if you investigate.
You are incorrect with your second assumption. A death within the land mass of the UK is registered in the Registration District in which the event occurred. My uncle had his death recorded at the football match he was attending some 15 miles from where he lived. The same ruling applies to births and marriages.
Your answer confirms what I claim. A registration place isn't birth/marriage/death place. So, if I would like to be reliable I should add county as birth place because adding registration town is misleading. Maybe I'm wrong but in my opinion adding West Sussex is safer than Worthing
If you are new to Wikitree and are having a difficult time getting started, check out a Welcome to Wikitree page which will help you with the basics of Wikitree.
If you are interested in becoming a member, simply pick a team that interests you from the following page: Space:Poland,_Volunteer_Tasks and let us know by replying to this comment. The only requirements for ongoing membership in the Poland Project are that you join a team and respond to the periodic check-ins from the Project Leaders/Coordinators. We recognize that people lead busy lives and are grateful for any and all contributions you can make. Once you have joined a team, please join the Poland Project Google Group to receive project updates and participate in project and team discussions. You can also follow Project news via the tags 'Poland_Europe' or 'Polish_Roots' or 'Polska' on G2G.
The Poland Project is very busy categorizing villages in Poland. If we have created a village category for you, please help us by adding it across other profiles you manage, where applicable. You can also assist us by finding and adding it to other Wikitree profiles from the same village through the Find link at the top right of your page. Scroll to the bottom, "Search for Any Text". Categorizing = connecting users or profiles. We appreciate any help you have to offer!