New Research supports Last Name at Birth was Abbott
Margaret's last name at birth is Abbott. Some Internet genealogies identify her incorrectly as Margaret Bayl(e)y, daughter of William Bayly of Westbury, Gloucester, England, but Margaret Bayley was a different person, married to a different John Warren (see sources on Margaret Bayl(e)y's profile. The 1614 will of William Bayly of Westbury is said to refer to John Warren as "now husband of my daughter Margaret" (see http://homepages.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~sam/warwills2.html and http://bigelowsociety.com/rod/warren1.htm), however, the John Warren who married Margaret of Westbury was not the same John Warren who lived in Nayland, Sussex (100+ miles distant from Westbury).
There is a marriage record between a John Warren and a Margret Abbott on 4 Nov 1612 at St Barnabas church in Chappel, Essex, 10 miles away from Nayland, Suffolk, which seems plausible.[1]
A Margret Abbott, daughter of Thomas Abbott, was baptized in that same church on 27 Jul 1589.
[2]
Biography
Margaret (Abbott) Warren was born in England.
Margaret (Abbott) Warren was born in Chappel, Essex, England.
Birth and Baptism
Margaret Abbott was baptised 27 July 1589 at Chappel, Essex, England, the daughter of Thomas Chappel and probably his only known wife, Anne.[3][4]
Marriage
Margaret Abbott married John Warren on Nov 1612 at St Barnabas church in Chappel, Essex.[5][6]
John was a son of John Warren & Elizabeth Scarlett, of Nayland, Suffolk, England.[7]
Anderson's earlier research suggested Margaret married John Warren by 1615, no location mentioned. [8] Torrey places their marriage in England also by 1615.[9]
John baptised 12 May 1622, Nayland, Suffolk, England,[10] married Michal Jennison alias Bloyss, 11 Jul 1667, Watertown, Middlesex, Massachusetts Bay Colony,[11] d. 27 Jan 1703, Watertown, Middlesex, Massacusetts Bay Colony.[12]
Mary bap. 12 Sep 1624, Nayland, Suffolk, England,[7] m. John Bigelow 30 Oct 1642, Watertown,Middlesex, Massachusetts Bay Colony,[13] Mary Warrin Biglo died 19 Oct 1691, Watertown, Massachusetts Bay Colony.[14]
Daniel baptised 25 Feb 1626/7, Nayland, Suffolk, Englandm=,[15] m. Mary Barron, 10 Dec 1650, Watertown, Middlesex, Massachusetts Bay Colony[16], d. after 1698.
Elizabeth bap. 2 July 1629, Nayland, Suffolk, England,[17] m. James Knapp alias Knopp prob. bef. 1655,[18] d. 12 Jan 1715/6, Watertown, Middlesex, Massachusetts Bay Colony.[19]
Threlfall also mentions Susan, who would have been baptized on 14 April 1612 in Nayland, Suffolk, England. Although not clear, it would seem that he credits the information to Bond's Genealogies of the families and descendants of the early settlers of Watertown, Massachusetts.[20] Bond, however, never mentioned Susan.[21] Since Threlfall's essay contains a few mistakes and very few citations to support his claims and also no trusted sources could be found so far to demonstrate Susan's existence, she will not be included here as one of John and Margaret's children. The list proposed by Anderson seems to be more consistent with the primary soruces and trusted secondary sources found to date.[8]
Life in England
Since all their children were baptized in Nayland, Suffolk, England, it seems safe to assume that was also where the couple resided before immigrating to New England.
Immigration
John and Margaret were among those who joined the exodus to America. They seem to have come to New England in 1630, from Nayland, Suffolk, England, with the Winthrop fleet. The fleet arrived in New England between June and July 1630.[22] Despite claims on several genealogies on the internet that John Warren and his family traveled with Governor Winthrop aboard the "Arabella", no documentation has been found to support that. Furthermore, it has not been possible to identify the name of the ship which carried John Warren and his family to New England.[23] Despite the absence of primary sources listing Margaret and their children by name among those who came with the Winthrop Fleet, Margaret and their children John, Mary, Daniel and Elizabeth appear in several colonial records and would have probably arrived with John Warren.
Death
Margaret died 6 November 1662 in Watertown, Massachusetts[24]. Her husband died in Watertown, Middlesex County, Massachusetts, on 13 December 1667[25].
Research Notes
From "Bullard and Allied Families" – John Warren had a homestead and seven other lots, aggregating 188 acres. he died December 13, 1667, aged 82 years. His wife Margaret (surname unknown), died November 6, 1662. His will dated November 30, 1667, was proved December 17 of that year..."
Per SAVAGE, VOL 4 DICT. FIRST SETTLERS OF New England: WARREN, JOHN, Watertown, came probably in 1630, in the fleet with Sir Richard Saltonstall, then aged about 45, and having wife and children (four certainly are named in his will, and of them only Elizabeth could be born here). His wife Margaret died 6 November 1662. She was probably the mother of all his children John, born 1622; Mary; and Daniel, born 1628; beside Elizabeth who married about 1654, James Knapp. Mary married 30 Oct. 1642, John Bigelow.
Sources
↑Marriage:
"FreeReg UK Parish Register database"
Essex; Chappel; St Barnabas; Parish Register; File line number: 46 FreeReg Transcription (accessed 23 November 2022)
Margret Abbott marriage to John Warren on 4 Nov 1612 in Chappel, Essex, England.
↑Baptism:
"FreeReg UK Parish Register database"
Essex; Chappel; St Barnabas; Parish Register; File line number: 127 FreeReg Transcription (accessed 23 November 2022)
Margret Abbott baptism on 27 Jul 1589 (born 27 Jul 1589), daughter of Thomas Abbott, in Chappel, Essex, England.
↑ "FreeReg UK Parish Register database"
Essex; Chappel; St Barnabas; Parish Register; File line number: 127 FreeReg Transcription (accessed 23 November 2022)
Margret Abbott baptism on 27 Jul 1589 (born 27 Jul 1589), daughter of Thomas Abbott, in Chappel, Essex, England.
↑ England, Essex Record Office. Chappel, St Branabas. Baptisms, 1538-1764. Baptism of Margaret, daughter of Thomas Abott born and baptized the 17 day of july 1589. Reference: D/P 87/1/1. Requires subscription $.
↑Marriage: "FreeReg UK Parish Register database", Essex; Chappel; St Barnabas; Parish Register; File line number: 46, FreeReg Transcription (accessed 23 November 2022)
Margret Abbott marriage to John Warren on 4 Nov 1612 in Chappel, Essex, England.
↑ England, Essex Record Office. Chappel, St Branabas. Marriages, 1539-1753. John Warren and Margaret Abbott were married 5 November 1612. Reference: D/P 87/1/1. Requires subscription $.
↑ 7.07.17.27.37.4 Genealogical Research in England: Nayland parish records. The New England Historical and Genealogical Register. (64:353) Boston, MA: New England Historic Genealogical Society, 1910, p. 353.
↑ 8.08.1 Anderson, Robert Charles, John WarrenThe Great Migration Begins: Immigrants to New England 1620-1633, Volumes I-III. Pages 1932-34 (Online database: AmericanAncestors.org, New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2010)
↑ New England Marriages to 1700. (Online database. AmericanAncestors.org. New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2008.) Originally published as: New England Marriages Prior to 1700. Vol. 3. Boston, Mass.: New England Historic Genealogical Society, 2015, p. 1600.
↑Baptism: "Suffolk Baptism Index 1538-1911 FindMyPast Transcription (accessed 26 November 2022) John Warrin baptism on 12 May 1622 (born 1622), son of John, in Nayland, Suffolk, England.
↑Watertown Records (Fred G. Barker, Watertown, Mass., 1894-) Vol. 1, p. 29. Early Vital Records of Massachusetts from 1600 to 1850. Marriage records for Watertown, Massachusetts, Watertown - Marriages.
↑ "Massachusetts, Town Clerk, Vital and Town Records, 1626-2001," database with images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:FHCG-8W5 : 20 May 2022), John Capt. Warren, 27 Jan 1703; citing Death, Watertown, Middlesex, Massachusetts Bay Colony, British Colonial America, Massachusetts Secretary of the Commonwealth, Boston; FHL microfilm 007009514.
↑ "Massachusetts, Town Clerk, Vital and Town Records, 1626-2001," database with images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:QPZT-M851 : 11 May 2022), John Bigulah and Mary Warin, 30 Sep 1642; citing Marriage, Watertown, Massachusetts Bay Colony, British Colonial America, Massachusetts Secretary of the Commonwealth, Boston; FHL microfilm 007011107.
↑Baptism:
"Suffolk Baptism Index 1538-1911" FindMyPast Transcription (accessed 26 November 2022)
Daniel Warrin baptism on 25 Feb 1626 (born 1626), son of John, in Nayland, Suffolk, England.
↑Baptism:
"Suffolk Baptism Index 1538-1911" FindMyPast Transcription (accessed 12 November 2022)
Elizabeth Warrin baptism on 2 Jul 1629 (born 1629), daughter of John, in Nayland, Suffolk, England.
↑Marriage:
"U.S., New England Marriages Prior to 1700"
Genealogical Publishing Co.; Baltimore, MD, USA; Volume Title: Third Supplement to Torrey's New England Marriages Prior to 1700 Ancestry Sharing Link - Ancestry Record 3824 #900179582 (accessed 17 November 2022)
Elizabeth Knopp marriage to James Knopp in About 1655.
↑ "Massachusetts, Town Clerk, Vital and Town Records, 1626-2001," database with images, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:FHCG-D6G : 20 May 2022), Elizabeth Knap, 12 Jan 1716; citing Death, Watertown, Middlesex, Massachusetts Bay Colony, British Colonial America, Massachusetts Secretary of the Commonwealth, Boston; FHL microfilm 007009514.
↑ Bond, Henry & Jones, Horatio Gates. Genealogies of the families and descendants of the early settlers of Watertown, Massachusetts, including Waltham and Weston : to which is appended the early history of the town. Vol. 1. Boston: N.E. Historic-genealogical Society, for the benefit of the "Bond fund", 1860, p. 960.
↑ Threlfall, John B. Fifty great migration colonists to New England & their origins. Madison, WI: Pub. by author, 1990, p. 481.
↑ Anderson, Robert Charles. The Winthrop Fleet of 1630. NEHGS, 2012. Pages 43. 312. 436. 661-665. 701, 703.
↑ Banks, Charles Edward. The Winthrop fleet of 1630; an account of the vessels, the voyage, the passengers, and their English homes from original authorities. Boston, Houghton Mifflin company, 1930, Illustrations between p. 48 and 49.
Leslie Mahler, "The English Origin of George(1) Abbott of Rowley, Massachusetts" TAG Vol. 85(2011):26, citing Chappel, Essex, parish register [Family History Library (FHL), Salt Lake City, film #1,565, 700, item 6]
Leslie Mahler, "Margaret Abbott, Wife of John1 Warren of Watertown, Massachusetts, and Sister of George1 Abbott of Rowley, Massachusetts" TAG 92(2021, pub. 2022):63-64
I would assume that since you are a Data Dr. you have sources. If that is the case, then you have my OK. However, I think you may need to contact GPM Project since they are a shared Project Mgr. Not sure if the Project puts you on as a trusted member or me.
Hal
Margaret has been attached to the wrong mother. Thomas Abbott was married to two women both named Anne. Margaret's mother was the second Anne who died in 1612. She's atached to the first Anne who died in 1582, who couldn't possibly be her mother. I can't make those changes without permission. Pretty please and thank you! :)
Thank you Gene! Jo Fitz-Henry from the England project has access to the parish records throught the Essex Record Office and offered to go through the records with me. We were able to map out some of the Abbotts from Chappel, Essex, births, marriages and burials. There are gaps in the surviving records, but what we could find gave us a pretty good idea of the family in England.
TYTY to both you and Jo. It isn't easy to undertake family cluster analysis using those old English records. Fortunately, we've got the right folks on the task. --Gene
There has been a lot of controversy concerning these 2 files dating back to at least 2015. I just adopted the file recently because Margaret is my GGA. I see the reasons for the dispute. The only things that match are the dod & locations of the dod. There are no sources including the info on her Profile. If there are sources to prove these are the same person someone needs to update the Profile with valid sources.
Since I'm new to the Profile it's best that this is directed to the PGM. I wouldn't change anything without their approval.
Hal
Thanks Hal. We will be adding to the profile information from the recent 2021 article in ‘’The American Genealogist’’ very soon. We (PGM) will take good care of the updates.
Excellent job with the merge! I'll try to go to the FHC next week to get this done. I think it's a 2 page article, so should be pretty straightforward. I'll keep you posted.
I just added possible marriage and baptism sources. I also just noticed previous comments about the TAG article adressing that. I'll try to find it. I'll remove the sources later if necessary. I also realize a profile has already been created for Margaret Abbot (Abbott-5406).
Abbott-5406 and Unknown-298071 appear to represent the same person because: They are the same person (see Leslie Mahler's article in the most recent TAG).
The most recent issue of "The American Genealogist" has an article identifying her as Margaret Abbott (bp. 27 July 1589 in Chappel, Essex, where she married John Warren 5 Nov 1612), sister of George Abbott (Abbott-89). Leslie Mahler, "Margaret Abbott, Wife of John1 Warren of Watertown, Massachusetts, and Sister of George1 Abbott of Rowley, Massachusetts" TAG 92(2021, pub. 2022):63-64.
Hello Profile Manager, I’m helping Ronald Barnes to look into whether or not Margaret Unknown is the same person as Margaret Bailey Bailey-10743 or Bailey-30527. If it's OK, I would like summarise the text recently added to the Acknowledgments section into a Research Notes section, which I can then update as our research progresses. Thanks!
Would it not still be better to discuss it on G2G first? Most of what is posted belongs on the profile of her husband. Notes as to her origins is already discussed. There is also a link to Margaret Bayley already at the top of this profile where the information also already exists.
Thank you Joe. I'm not planning to make any substantive changes to the profile at this stage. Rather just to tidy things up to more clearly identify the issues. I expect I will have some sources to add to Bailey-10743, which will hopefully help to clarify whether or not she is the same person. There's still more research to be done on the English side and, once that's more complete, we will hopefully have a clearer idea about whether to put a question on G2G or not.
*Reliable* sources should always be placed in the 'sources' section, they do not belong under 'acknowledgments.' And it is never appropriate to indulge in personal rants on a profile, or to refer to project members as 'nazi gestapos.' Sharon is correct in saying that PGM (as well as WikiTree generally) does not recognize ancestry trees as a reliable source. I am leaving Mr. Barnes's comments up at least temporarily so other project members will be aware of them. However, please remember that the honor code requires we treat each other with civility and that principle will be enforced.
It appears that two completely unrelated people have been confounded in this profile. Neither Bond nor Anderson mentions a last name for Margaret. The source of this last name and parents seems to be a reference in the 2 March 1613/14 will of William Bayly of Westbury, Gloucestershire, that mentions mentions John Warren, "now husband of my daughter Margaret". See http://homepages.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~sam/warwills2.html and http://bigelowsociety.com/rod/warren1.htm
This is not a plausible relationship. Westbury, Gloucestershire, and Nayland, Sussex, are nowhere near each other.
Bayley-195 and Bayly-5 appear to represent the same person because: Clearly the same person. I've not investigated the records to see what the better LNAB is, but I note that there are records for her parents under the spelling Bayly.
Featured German connections:
Margaret is
19 degrees from Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, 18 degrees from Dietrich Bonhoeffer, 21 degrees from Lucas Cranach, 17 degrees from Stefanie Graf, 16 degrees from Wilhelm Grimm, 20 degrees from Fanny Hensel, 24 degrees from Theodor Heuss, 15 degrees from Alexander Mack, 32 degrees from Carl Miele, 17 degrees from Nathan Rothschild, 20 degrees from Hermann Friedrich Albert von Ihering and 16 degrees from Ferdinand von Zeppelin
on our single family tree.
Login to see how you relate to 33 million family members.
I would assume that since you are a Data Dr. you have sources. If that is the case, then you have my OK. However, I think you may need to contact GPM Project since they are a shared Project Mgr. Not sure if the Project puts you on as a trusted member or me. Hal
Working to change the mother now. Seems we had an errant marriage end date of 1612 associated with the first wife.
As your time permits, hope you will confirm that I got this update correct.--Gene
There has been a lot of controversy concerning these 2 files dating back to at least 2015. I just adopted the file recently because Margaret is my GGA. I see the reasons for the dispute. The only things that match are the dod & locations of the dod. There are no sources including the info on her Profile. If there are sources to prove these are the same person someone needs to update the Profile with valid sources. Since I'm new to the Profile it's best that this is directed to the PGM. I wouldn't change anything without their approval. Hal
S Willson, PGM Co-Leader
edited by Marcia (Bonnet) Benjamin
Ian
edited by I. Speed
Jen, for PGM
Ian, co-Leader, England Project
Jen, for PGM
The reasons why Bailey-10743 is not accepted as spouse of Warren-238 are covered in Unknown-298071.
This is not a plausible relationship. Westbury, Gloucestershire, and Nayland, Sussex, are nowhere near each other.
Thanks