G2G: Which companies actually offer Neanderthal DNA results? [closed]

+5 votes
941 views
Just asking out of curiosity.

I am currently reading a book called the Sixth Extinction (Elizabeth Kolbert) and one of the chapters talks about Neanderthals and Homo sapiens, and both the differences and similarities between them.

I did my DNA test with FT DNA and its says I have "Ancient origins" ancestry but judging by what the blurb says - nothing further back than 45,000 years - which to me seems to be Homo Sapiens only.

I then uploaded my DNA to My Heritage but I cannot find any Neanderthal DNA results.

So which companies actually do offer a Neanderthal result?

I am curious.

Thank you.
Closed with the note: Answer received
in The Tree House by Golden Owl (1.5m points)
closed by Robynne Lozier

5 Answers

+4 votes

23AndMe 

My report says that I have 321 Neanderthal variants and "You have more Neanderthal variants than 97% of 23andMe customers.

However, your Neanderthal ancestry accounts for less than 4% of your overall DNA."

by Owl (750k points)

maternal haplogroup is U5a2


+4 votes
I had mine done by 23 And Me. They identified 274 genetic variants that can be traced to the Neanderthals for me.
by Owl (23.3k points)

+4 votes
Upload your Family Finder results to yourDNAportal.com (its free).  They report your Neanderthal traits (as well as DNA matches, ethnicity, etc). Then you can add your public yourDNAportal ID to your DNA tests page at https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Special:DNATests

My yourDNAportal results were:

4 Neanderthal traits
Neanderthal score based on 3,805 markers
Analysis of 1,328 Neanderthal markers associated with various health risks and diseases

Then you can view those health related traits.

Adding your WikiTree ID to yourDNAportal allows your matches to view your ancestral tree in WikiTree.  Invite your matches in yourDNAportal to join WikiTree.
by Owl (826k points)
edited by Peter Roberts

Thanks Peter. Checking out that web site!!

+6 votes

I read the book by David Reich, Who we are and how we got here. He is a Harvard scientist who helped run some of the first studies confirming the "intermixing" of Homo sapiens and Homo neanderthalensis

It's a "popular science" book -- not a textbook on evolutionary biology, not to mention a collection of journal articles. But still, it is more than most people read.

Reich's collaborator Nick Patterson is an applied mathematician who developed a simple statistic to prove with high probability when genetically distinguishable populations admix -- for instance, to prove that the homo sapiens who left the Near East and spread throughout Europe and Asia admixed with Neanderthals.

But this test only proves that admixture occurred -- it doesn't tell you which DNA portions you have that came from Neanderthals.

I had been wondering how it was determined which DNA portions in modern humans were confirmed as coming from Neanderthal ancestors.  This article:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4031459/

seems to me to state that the answer is quite boring. The bottleneck, it seems, was getting really high quality sequences of Neanderthal genomes. Once this was done, you could compare with a lot of modern human genomes, which are much easier to sequence. At some loci, 100% of the homo sapiens specimens had the same nucleotide (i.e., A, T, C, or G) while the sampled Neanderthal genome differed. My thinking was that even if you checked this, there was no guarantee that the Neanderthal didn't just have a "private variant" produced in, say, the previous 30 generations of Neanderthals -- not representative of all Neanderthals. But this seems to be how these DNA positions are identified. So perhaps there are some that are specific to the Neanderthal sequence, and not characteristic of all Neanderthals. But this is a small percentage, and the more Neanderthal genomes are sequenced, the smaller this percentage can be made.

To answer your question: my 23andme results report on Neanderthal variants. Each company customizes the chip it uses a little. No major test measures your enitre genome, so they customize to determine which positions they measure. 23andme might be the only company to customize to include these Neanderthal positions. 

by Owl (369k points)

So my answer seems to be - just 23 & Me. Thanks Barry!!

I have uploaded my raw data to - your DNAportal - as per Peters suggestion above. No matches yet, but it is still a relatively new website - so it may be some time before I find any matches.

+4 votes
I did Helix through National Graphics DNA Genographic Project.  Nat Geo is no longer offering this and will shut down it's site for this Project June 30 2020.

Had nothing but trouble with both Helix and Nat Geo.  Wasted money as far as I am concerned, but it did say I was 1.2% Neanderthal which is standard for my genetic heritage.

That being said, I am not interested in a Paleo diet.  LOL
by Owl (240k points)

Related questions

+16 votes
2 answers
+18 votes
2 answers
asked Dec 26, 2019 in The Tree House by Owl (85.0k points)
+7 votes
2 answers
asked Jan 16, 2016 in The Tree House by Owl (223k points)
+10 votes
1 answer
+5 votes
1 answer
...