I think we're all a little confused here.
Joseph Costley was born 1822 in Arkansas, married Elizabeth Wilhelm.(Her brother Henry lived near them or with them, as noted on census records) He lived until 1907. I have in fact seen his
One of their children was David F. Costley, married to Deliah White, of whom my father is decended from. A daughter of theirs is Sarah Costley married Thompson. Another daughter, Catherine Costley, married Swain.
Interesting thing is Joseph, and his children filed for recognition of Cherokee blood in 1907. I've got some of those documents saved. It was rejected for lack of evidence. Joseph, who was pushing 90 claims he was born to parents he doesn't remember, and I suspect it was James Costley who died in 1834 and the UNK Cherokee with a stated name on application of McIntyre.
I have been unable to locate any further actual FACTS about Joseph's birth...