G2G: Are the York families connected?

Question

I'm trying to find out the origin of my York line in NY when I decided to take a peek at my DNA on Ancestry again. For people who had up somewhat decent family trees, I noticed I, my sister, and my aunt matched a few people in common but not on the same DNA segments (I'm guessing at least, under the tab for matches in common with these various people, my sister, aunt, and I weren't listed as matches for each other).

• My, my sister, and my aunt's York-link is York-2413.

1. Match to descendant of York-635
2. Match to descendant of York-441
3. Match to descendant of York-3587
4. Match to descendant of York-3988
5. Match to descendant of York-1035
6. Match to descendant of York-317
7. Match to descendant of York-463 (full sibling of #8)
8. Match to descendant of York-463 (full sibling of #7)
9. Match to descendant of York-320 (daughter of #10)
10. Match to descendant of York-320 (mother of #9)

Any advice? I have reached out to all these people on Ancestry with no response.